Welcome, Guest. Please login or register for free.
Did you miss your activation email?
Friday 27 November 09 18:52 UTC (UK)
Welcome Home Help Surnames Library Shop Search Login Register

+  RootsChat.Com
|-+  England (Counties as in 1851-1901)
| |-+  England - General
| | |-+  Durham (Moderator: sillgen)
| | | |-+  Stuck - looking for ideas
« previous next »
Pages: [1] 2 Print
Author Topic: Stuck - looking for ideas  (Read 977 times)
allans
RootsChat Member
***
Posts: 123


Public Tree on Ancestry


WWW
Stuck - looking for ideas
« on: Tuesday 04 April 06 10:36 UTC (UK) »

(also posted on Northumberland)
On the 1851 census Ann Lee Prudhoe, widow, has 2 sons
John Lee Prudhoe
William Lee Prudhoe
Both their birth certs are registered by their mother and no fathers name is given.
There is the following Marriage entry in St Andrew's PC, Newcastle 30/8/1835
William Prudhoe of this parish
Ann Lee of this parish by banns
both marked
witness George Liddle - marked
Elizabeth Thompson - marked


William's MC gives William Lee Prudhoe as his father
John's MC gives Robert Lee Prudhoe as his father

Marriage entry in PR St Mary's Church, Gateshead 10/2/1867 -
John Lee Prudhoe, 21, Batchelor, Glassmaker
son of Robert Lee Prudhoe, Glassmaker, 20 Hopper St
Hannah Wilson, 19, Spinster, John Wilson, Blacksmith, 11 Leonard's Court
He signed, she marked
Witness WIlliam Lee Prudhow - marked
Elizabeth Dyer - marked

Where do I go from here?
Anyone got access to bastardy records?

Logged

Tweedie, Garnett,  Smith - !!!, Fearnley,
Bennetts, Waterhouse, Horobin, Tranter
GeoffP
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 2030


My Irish Grandmother Julia Sexton(Moxham)


Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #1 on: Tuesday 04 April 06 10:58 UTC (UK) »

I think that the 1841 Census would be an interesting next step. It might help determine whether Ann Lee Prudhoe was living with or married to William Prudhoe. Unfortunately I do not have access to the 1841 Census.
                                                          Regards
                                                                      Geoff
Logged

Any census information included in this post is Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk

   Peirce/Pierce/Pearce: Hungerford,Berks/Burbage Wilts.              
   Moxham: Monkton Farleigh, Wilts
   Sexton:Cork,Ireland, New York
Michael Dixon
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 2624



Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #2 on: Tuesday 04 April 06 14:16 UTC (UK) »

Allan,

So Ann Lee marries William Prudhoe in Newcastle on 30 Aug 1835.

10 years later the birth of a John Lee Prudhoe is registered within Gateshead Registration District, recording no father.
(Sept Qtr 1845)

Also within Gateshead, in Dec Qtr, 1848. the birth of a William Prudhoe is registered.

Census 1851 for Winlaton, ( Piece 2403 Folio 183 Page 26) shows widow Ann Prudhoe with 5 yr old John and 3 yr old William.

Marriage of Ann Prudhoe/Robert Gray registered June Qtr 1856 in Gateshead RD

( OK ...None of this news to you)

But when John Lee Prudhoe marries Hannah Wilson in Gateshead on10 Feb 1867, his father is recorded as
Robert LEE Prudhoe.

Does the middle name "LEE" also appear on William's marriage record, for both him and his father, William Prudhoe.

It seems strange that these Prudhoe seniors,  carry as a second/middle name, the same name as the maiden name of their wive/partner.

Maybe it indicates that officials did not accurately record the marriage info ?

As Geoff suggests, the answer lies within the Census 1841 info. (sorry I have no access to 1841)

Michael Dixon,
Blyth, Northumberland

Logged

Names.

GALLAGHER ( + variations).
Areas. Co Sligo, Co Leitrim, Co Mayo. IRELAND.
Ontario, CANADA
Lowell, Ma, USA
Counties of Northumberland & Durham, ENGLAND
-------------------------------------------------------------------
MALEY/MELIA/MALLEY  - with or without " O "
Westport Co Mayo. Northumberland
-------------------------------------------------------------------
DIXON
Cumberland.. Brampton, Carlisle, ENGLAND
Helen K
RootsChat Veteran
*****
Posts: 886



Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #3 on: Tuesday 04 April 06 14:36 UTC (UK) »

Hi allans

I think you may have the wrong 1861 for William as stated in your Northumberland post - anyway see what you think of the following.

1841 Census
HO107/302/9  Folio 15  Page 25
Blaydon (Parish of Winlaton)

William PRUDHOE 30 Waterman Y (born in County)
Ann PRUDHOE 25 N (not born in County)


1851 Census
HO107/2403  Folio 183  Page 26  Sch 99
Blaydon Staith, Blaydon, (Parish of Winlaton)

Ann PRUDHOE Head Widow 35 Laundress Northld Hexham
John PRUDHOE Son 5 Scholar Durham Winlaton
William PRUDHOE Son 3 Durham Winlaton


1861 Census
RG9/3809  Folio 10  Page 13  Sch 58
Blaydon, (Parish of Winlaton)

Robert GRAY Head Mar 31 Horse Nail Maker Northumberland Newcastle
Ann GRAY Wife Mar 45 Northumberland Hexham
John Lee PRUDHOE Son in Law Un 15 Apprentice Durham Blaydon
William PRUDHOE Son in Law Un 12 Apprentice Durham Blaydon

(Read Son in Law as Stepson in 1861)

If that 1835 Marriage you refer to is correct I would have expected several or more children born before John in 1846ish.  There could have been children staying in a different household in 1841, but because relationships aren't recorded you can't tell whose children they are.

I would try a separate request for Winlaton and/or Blaydon Baptisms and Burials for all children born to William and Ann PRUDHOE.

Regards

Helen K
Logged

Census transcriptions are Crown Copyright of the National Archives
GeoffP
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 2030


My Irish Grandmother Julia Sexton(Moxham)


Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #4 on: Tuesday 04 April 06 15:41 UTC (UK) »

Well done Helen, that all makes very good sense.
                                                        Regards
                                                                     Geoff
Logged

Any census information included in this post is Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk

   Peirce/Pierce/Pearce: Hungerford,Berks/Burbage Wilts.              
   Moxham: Monkton Farleigh, Wilts
   Sexton:Cork,Ireland, New York
Helen K
RootsChat Veteran
*****
Posts: 886



Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #5 on: Tuesday 04 April 06 16:40 UTC (UK) »

Thanks Geoff - and I think Michael makes a good point about the Marriage Certificate of John and the use of the LEE name.  That's a bit strange.

Did these two boys know who their father was ?  It seems from their Birth Certificates he was not named - so it's possible mother Ann was unmarried, although the 1851 records her as a Widow (was that to save face?).

The 1841 Census hasn't really helped.  That couple could be totally unconnected.

I think as well as wanting the Baptism entries for John Lee and William I'd be wanting to be certain if Ann PRUDHOE was married or not at that time.

That means getting the Marriage Certificate to Robert GRAY in June Quarter 1856 as provided by Michael above.

We'll wait and see what allans thinks.

Regards

Helen K

Logged

Census transcriptions are Crown Copyright of the National Archives
allans
RootsChat Member
***
Posts: 123


Public Tree on Ancestry


WWW
Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #6 on: Tuesday 04 April 06 18:27 UTC (UK) »

I concur with everything Helen says

There is no definite tie with '41 couple.
There is a long gapfrom '35 marriage to the 2 boys on the '51.
A search for other children may add something.

MC for GRAY would also have her parents names
thus, irrespective of her saying she is a widow, will indicate her surname at birth
and hence if she was married to Prudhoe or was a Prudhoe herself

out of curiosity - tried IGI search - complete blank
Other pssibility is to check Hexham, her place of origin.

Or as i started - anyone got access to bastardy records - how was she getting an income after the botys beirth to her marriage to GRAY.
Logged

Tweedie, Garnett,  Smith - !!!, Fearnley,
Bennetts, Waterhouse, Horobin, Tranter
Michael Dixon
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 2624



Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #7 on: Wednesday 05 April 06 07:23 UTC (UK) »

Allans,

Did  "Bastardy Records" exist in England in mid C19th ?

As far as I know, illegitimate children were baptised/registered etc, the same as illegitimate ones.

Michael Dixon
Logged

Names.

GALLAGHER ( + variations).
Areas. Co Sligo, Co Leitrim, Co Mayo. IRELAND.
Ontario, CANADA
Lowell, Ma, USA
Counties of Northumberland & Durham, ENGLAND
-------------------------------------------------------------------
MALEY/MELIA/MALLEY  - with or without " O "
Westport Co Mayo. Northumberland
-------------------------------------------------------------------
DIXON
Cumberland.. Brampton, Carlisle, ENGLAND
allans
RootsChat Member
***
Posts: 123


Public Tree on Ancestry


WWW
Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #8 on: Wednesday 05 April 06 07:53 UTC (UK) »

In so far as having a bastard child could prevent women from gaining financial help under the poor laws - yes I believe they did.

I picked up on an earlier reply that the use of the maternal surname as a childs middle name is considered unusual - it occurs several times through my family tree, on various independant branches in Scotland, Yorkshire and Cornwall.
Logged

Tweedie, Garnett,  Smith - !!!, Fearnley,
Bennetts, Waterhouse, Horobin, Tranter
lizdb
RootsChat Marquessate
********
Posts: 9414



Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #9 on: Wednesday 05 April 06 08:20 UTC (UK) »

(also posted on Northumberland)

Marriage entry in PR St Mary's Church, Gateshead 10/2/1867 -
John Lee Prudhoe, 21, Batchelor, Glassmaker
son of Robert Lee Prudhoe, Glassmaker, 20 Hopper St
Hannah Wilson, 19, Spinster, John Wilson, Blacksmith, 11 Leonard's Court


Can anyone with access to 1861 census find a Robert Lee Prudhoe with son John Lee Prudhoe (aged about 15)?

If so that would prove this is a different John Lee Prudhoe.

Logged

Edmonds/Edmunds - mainly Sussex
DeBoo - London
Green - Suffolk

census information is Crown Copyright from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk
Michael Dixon
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 2624



Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #10 on: Wednesday 05 April 06 08:35 UTC (UK) »

Allans,

The use of a maternal surname as a child's middle name also occurs regularly in Northumberland and Durham ( and very probably in other places too)

But I was not referring to the Prudhoe children having their mother's maiden surname as a second name.

In your original posting, you had their father(s) also having that same maternal surname as a middle name ?

In affect you were saying that the Prudhoe male(s) who married/partnered Ann LEE, either took her LEE name as a middle name or had it from the start ??  

Look at the second paragraph of your original query where you write....

" William's MC gives William LEE Prudhoe as his father.
John's MC gives Robert LEE Prudhoe as his father"


Michael Dixon
Logged

Names.

GALLAGHER ( + variations).
Areas. Co Sligo, Co Leitrim, Co Mayo. IRELAND.
Ontario, CANADA
Lowell, Ma, USA
Counties of Northumberland & Durham, ENGLAND
-------------------------------------------------------------------
MALEY/MELIA/MALLEY  - with or without " O "
Westport Co Mayo. Northumberland
-------------------------------------------------------------------
DIXON
Cumberland.. Brampton, Carlisle, ENGLAND
allans
RootsChat Member
***
Posts: 123


Public Tree on Ancestry


WWW
Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #11 on: Wednesday 05 April 06 08:42 UTC (UK) »

quite right - I hadnt thought of that
Logged

Tweedie, Garnett,  Smith - !!!, Fearnley,
Bennetts, Waterhouse, Horobin, Tranter
marilyn-b
RootsChat Extra
**
Posts: 10



Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #12 on: Thursday 15 February 07 23:33 UTC (UK) »

Hi,

Just found these postings whilst doing a general search for the surname Prudhoe, which is my direct line.

I am almost sure that the family you mention are my great great grandfather's relatives.

His name was Edward Prudhoe, born 1814 in Blaydon, and his parents were Edward and Ann (maiden name Dodds)

Edward and Ann's children included (along with my great great grandfather),  John (born1803), William (born 1806), Thomas (born 1809) and Mary (born 1811).

On the 1851 census, Edward and John are both living in Blaydon Staith with their respective families, and the family you have mentioned (Ann, now widowed, and her two sons John Lee and William) are also living in Blaydon Staith.

On the 1871 census, John Lee Prudhoe and my great great grandfather Edward are still living a few houses apart from each other.  William, John Lee's brother married a Yorkshire girl and is living there with his family.

As the last post in this thread was submitted last year, I hope that you will see this entry, as we obviously must share the same ancestry and it would be interesting to compare notes.

Marilyn
Logged

Prudhoe-Blaydon,Durham; Williams-Harlech, Wales;  Godfrey-Liverpool;  Blamey-Dartmouth, Devon; Hansen-Odense, Denmark;  Evans-Liverpool;  Blair-Carlisle;
GeoffP
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 2030


My Irish Grandmother Julia Sexton(Moxham)


Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #13 on: Friday 16 February 07 07:52 UTC (UK) »

Hi Marilyn,

I suggest that you send a pm as I see that Allans has not been on line since April last year.
                                 Regards
                                                        Geoff
Logged

Any census information included in this post is Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk

   Peirce/Pierce/Pearce: Hungerford,Berks/Burbage Wilts.              
   Moxham: Monkton Farleigh, Wilts
   Sexton:Cork,Ireland, New York
marilyn-b
RootsChat Extra
**
Posts: 10



Re: Stuck - looking for ideas
« Reply #14 on: Friday 16 February 07 10:43 UTC (UK) »

Thanks Geoff, I have sent Allan a message through Rootschat, but I don't know whether  he is still a member.

If I do not receive a reply from him I notice he has a website of his own which gives an email address for him, so I will send him an email.

Thanks again for your help,
Marilyn


Logged

Prudhoe-Blaydon,Durham; Williams-Harlech, Wales;  Godfrey-Liverpool;  Blamey-Dartmouth, Devon; Hansen-Odense, Denmark;  Evans-Liverpool;  Blair-Carlisle;
Pages: [1] 2 Print 
« previous next »


[Copyright] [Shrink Link] [About Us] [Terms of Use]
All Census Lookups are Crown Copyright, National Archives for academic and non-commercial research purposes only
RootsChat.com cannot be held responsible directly or indirectly for the messages or content posted by others. Inline images in messages are the copyright of the respective linked sites.
RootsChat.com, Europa House, Bury, Lancashire, BL9 5BT

In loving memory of Eric George Davies, 1934-2009, the father of RootsChat.com































Powered by SMF 1.0.7 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines LLC
0.049:18