Welcome, Guest. Please login or register for free.
Did you miss your activation email?
Thursday 26 November 09 01:54 UTC (UK)
Welcome Home Help Surnames Library Shop Search Login Register

+  RootsChat.Com
|-+  England (Counties as in 1851-1901)
| |-+  England - General
| | |-+  London and Middlesex (Moderators: dawnsh, Valda)
| | | |-+  Two Elizabeth Lloyds? - compare signatures
« previous next »
Pages: [1] Print
Author Topic: Two Elizabeth Lloyds? - compare signatures  (Read 290 times)
rjknott
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 1783



Two Elizabeth Lloyds? - compare signatures
« on: Thursday 17 September 09 18:18 UTC (UK) »

The 1841 census has:

HO107/709  book 4  folio 27
Kingsland Road, Hackney/Shoreditch

Elizabeth Lloyd   40   Chandler   Y  
Susannah Lloyd   12   Y
Ann  Lloyd   8   Y
George  Lloyd  4   Y
Elizabeth Lloyd  1   Y

A couple of doors down the road is:

William Lloyd   30   Hatter   Y   ('my' William Lloyd was b1800)
William Lloyd   15     Y

Registers reveal the following children of William (hatter) and Elizabeth Lloyd:

Susannah Mary Lloyd b 1828
Sarah Ann Lloyd b 1831
George Lloyd b 1835
Elizabeth Lloyd b 1840

It would appear that the enumerator has got William's age wrong (although I haven't found William Jr's baptism, so they may be unconnected), but the problem is this entry in the marriage registers:

16 Nov 1834   St James, Clerkenwell
William Lloyd, bachelor
Elizabeth Northover, spinster

The most obvious answer is that the 'bachelor' is wrong and William married two wives called Elizabeth (there is a possible death). Is there another explanation?

Richard
« Last Edit: Friday 18 September 09 16:37 UTC (UK) by rjknott » Logged

Knott,Boutell,Warman,Winder,Webster,Uings,Evans,Drage
Pike,Pike,Watson,Pratt,Homewood,Stephenson,Brown,Pattison
Holmes,Tomlinson,Moorby,Cardus,Gill,Lambert,Binns,Emmott
Fenning,Pudney,Wilson,Walker,Hine,Treeby,Knox,Butler
Jack,Carswell,Gardiner,Alexander,Gibb,Watson,Naismith,Telfer
Gray,Inglis,Gibb,Watson,Taylor,Taylor,Gaff,Henderson
Gayford,Clarke,Palmer,Jessup,Smart,Hutson,Lloyd,Northover
Ridley,Lee,Bird,Mingings,Moore,Colthart,Lawson,Hind
Valda
Moderator
RootsChat Marquessate
*******
Posts: 9698



Re: Two Elizabeth Lloyds?
« Reply #1 on: Thursday 17 September 09 18:44 UTC (UK) »

Hi

Have you obtained the birth certificate of the youngest child to confirm her mother's maiden name was Northover?


Regards

Valda
Logged

This information is Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk
rjknott
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 1783



Re: Two Elizabeth Lloyds?
« Reply #2 on: Thursday 17 September 09 19:03 UTC (UK) »

Indeed I have. I should have put that in the posting.
William (b1800 Dunmow, Essex) and Elizabeth (b1799 Shoreditch) nearly made it to their Golden Wedding despite marrying fairly late).

Richard
Logged

Knott,Boutell,Warman,Winder,Webster,Uings,Evans,Drage
Pike,Pike,Watson,Pratt,Homewood,Stephenson,Brown,Pattison
Holmes,Tomlinson,Moorby,Cardus,Gill,Lambert,Binns,Emmott
Fenning,Pudney,Wilson,Walker,Hine,Treeby,Knox,Butler
Jack,Carswell,Gardiner,Alexander,Gibb,Watson,Naismith,Telfer
Gray,Inglis,Gibb,Watson,Taylor,Taylor,Gaff,Henderson
Gayford,Clarke,Palmer,Jessup,Smart,Hutson,Lloyd,Northover
Ridley,Lee,Bird,Mingings,Moore,Colthart,Lawson,Hind
danuslave
RootsChat Veteran
*****
Posts: 953


My fashion sense isn't any better now!


Re: Two Elizabeth Lloyds?
« Reply #3 on: Thursday 17 September 09 19:35 UTC (UK) »

Quote
Is there another explanation?

Hi Richard

Two issues here

In 1841 the ages of people over 15 were supposed to be rounded down to the nearest 5 years (though often they weren't) so William the hatter could have been born 1807-1811.  Meaning he could be old enough to be William jnr's father.

You seem to be assuming that William and (an) Elizabeth would have been married before the children were born - NOT TRUE.  It was quite common for couples to marry after they had had some or all of their children. 

So basically, there is nothing in what you have found that is inconsistent with 

William (technically a bachelor) and Elizabeth (ditto spinster) marrying after they had 3 children and then going on to have 2 more.

Proving it of course is a whole different matter   Cheesy

Linda
Logged
rjknott
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 1783



Re: Two Elizabeth Lloyds?
« Reply #4 on: Thursday 17 September 09 20:54 UTC (UK) »

Yes, I know the ages are rounded down in 1841; my comment referred to the fact that William was actually over 40, so 30 seemed quite a long way out (although I have seen worse).

And while I accept that William and Elizabeth could have had children before getting married it's unusual for them to have been entered as man and wife in the baptismal records; normally the mother is entered under her maiden name and the father not mentioned at all.

That said, your scenario is one I have considered, although I thought the possibility of 'bachelor' being wrong as a possibility.

Richard
Logged

Knott,Boutell,Warman,Winder,Webster,Uings,Evans,Drage
Pike,Pike,Watson,Pratt,Homewood,Stephenson,Brown,Pattison
Holmes,Tomlinson,Moorby,Cardus,Gill,Lambert,Binns,Emmott
Fenning,Pudney,Wilson,Walker,Hine,Treeby,Knox,Butler
Jack,Carswell,Gardiner,Alexander,Gibb,Watson,Naismith,Telfer
Gray,Inglis,Gibb,Watson,Taylor,Taylor,Gaff,Henderson
Gayford,Clarke,Palmer,Jessup,Smart,Hutson,Lloyd,Northover
Ridley,Lee,Bird,Mingings,Moore,Colthart,Lawson,Hind
Valda
Moderator
RootsChat Marquessate
*******
Posts: 9698



Re: Two Elizabeth Lloyds?
« Reply #5 on: Thursday 17 September 09 21:55 UTC (UK) »

Hi

Were the children baptised in the same church the marriage took place in, or at least the children either side of the marriage?

Regards

Valda
Logged

This information is Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk
nigelp
RootsChat Member
***
Posts: 211



Re: Two Elizabeth Lloyds?
« Reply #6 on: Thursday 17 September 09 22:43 UTC (UK) »

Hi Richard,

Do you know whether the marriage of William Lloyd to Elizabeth Northover has any relevance?

There is a marriage of a William Lloyd to an Elizabeth Day in St James, Clerkenwell in 1824. This appears more appropriate to the dates for the baptism entries and the entries for the family in the 1841, 1851 and 1861 Censuses. There is an Elizabeth Day, daughter of Robert, baptised at St John, Hackney on 27 April 1800.

William could perhaps first have married Elizabeth Day and then Elizabeth Northover.

Nigel
Logged

Alcock (Ashill), Barber (Chilcompton), Breeze (Ovington), Carey (Salisbury and Warminster), Collacott (Combe Martin and Shebbear), Creamer (North Elmham), Goss (Bristol and Combe Martin), Musselwhite (Britford and Downton), Sparkes (North Elmham), Thorogood (Little Hallingbury), Turner (Codford, Salisbury and Warminster), Wakefield (Briston and Hindolveston)
rjknott
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 1783



Re: Two Elizabeth Lloyds? - compare signatures
« Reply #7 on: Friday 18 September 09 06:18 UTC (UK) »

Valda: Susannah was baptised at Batholomew the Great, but the other three were at St Leonard's Shoreditch (so either side of the 1834 marriage).

Nigel: thank you for the Lloyd/Day marriage. Elizabeth's birth certificate in 1840 names her mother as Northover (see posts 2/3 above). Yes, I am exploring the possibility that William married two Elizabeths (see post 1) and your find  looks important - I'm not sure how I missed it.

The following sequence now looks possible:
1824  Marriage at St James, Clerkenwell
1827/1831 Baptisms of children
1832  Elizabeth Lloyd, age 33, buried at St James, Clerkenwell
1834 Marriage at St James, Clerkenwell
1836/1840 Baptisms of children

The less good news is that William's signatures at each wedding are attached and don't seem to support the case particularly strongly, although there are similarities.

Richard


* William1824.jpg (5.27 KB, 158x59 - viewed 60 times.)

* William1834.jpg (8.06 KB, 218x64 - viewed 61 times.)
« Last Edit: Friday 18 September 09 19:52 UTC (UK) by rjknott » Logged

Knott,Boutell,Warman,Winder,Webster,Uings,Evans,Drage
Pike,Pike,Watson,Pratt,Homewood,Stephenson,Brown,Pattison
Holmes,Tomlinson,Moorby,Cardus,Gill,Lambert,Binns,Emmott
Fenning,Pudney,Wilson,Walker,Hine,Treeby,Knox,Butler
Jack,Carswell,Gardiner,Alexander,Gibb,Watson,Naismith,Telfer
Gray,Inglis,Gibb,Watson,Taylor,Taylor,Gaff,Henderson
Gayford,Clarke,Palmer,Jessup,Smart,Hutson,Lloyd,Northover
Ridley,Lee,Bird,Mingings,Moore,Colthart,Lawson,Hind
rjknott
RootsChat Aristocrat
******
Posts: 1783



Re: Two Elizabeth Lloyds? - compare signatures
« Reply #8 on: Friday 18 September 09 17:03 UTC (UK) »

William's signature in 1861 on his daughter's marriage certificates may help.
(Unfortunately he didn't sign when any of his other children married).

Richard


* Lloyd1861.jpg (7.53 KB, 382x58 - viewed 51 times.)
Logged

Knott,Boutell,Warman,Winder,Webster,Uings,Evans,Drage
Pike,Pike,Watson,Pratt,Homewood,Stephenson,Brown,Pattison
Holmes,Tomlinson,Moorby,Cardus,Gill,Lambert,Binns,Emmott
Fenning,Pudney,Wilson,Walker,Hine,Treeby,Knox,Butler
Jack,Carswell,Gardiner,Alexander,Gibb,Watson,Naismith,Telfer
Gray,Inglis,Gibb,Watson,Taylor,Taylor,Gaff,Henderson
Gayford,Clarke,Palmer,Jessup,Smart,Hutson,Lloyd,Northover
Ridley,Lee,Bird,Mingings,Moore,Colthart,Lawson,Hind
Pages: [1] Print 
« previous next »


[Copyright] [Shrink Link] [About Us] [Terms of Use]
All Census Lookups are Crown Copyright, National Archives for academic and non-commercial research purposes only
RootsChat.com cannot be held responsible directly or indirectly for the messages or content posted by others. Inline images in messages are the copyright of the respective linked sites.
RootsChat.com, Europa House, Bury, Lancashire, BL9 5BT

In loving memory of Eric George Davies, 1934-2009, the father of RootsChat.com































Powered by SMF 1.0.7 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines LLC
0.061:20