Hi 'Calverley Lad',
Reference your query re whether you are going off track. The truth is, I have no idea where the track is.
As you have probably gathered, I'm looking for the origin of one Benjamin Handley who married at Dronfield, Derbyshire, in 1812, and who subsequently baptized two of his sons 'Charles'. He may or may not have had the same parents as John Handley who had a son baptized 'Charles' at Dronfield in 1808.
From the 1841 census and a burial record, it appears that Benjamin was born in about 1782 in Yorkshire.
I have to ask myself, why all this enthusiasm for naming sons 'Charles'. The usual answer would be that the father was following tradition and naming his first son after himself or his father.
Looking for a possible father for Benjamin on this basis, I can only come up with one. Namely Charles Hundley (but often Handley), a stuffweaver, who married Jane Williams at St Peter, Leeds, in July 1780. One baptism is recorded to this couple, namely Richard at St Peter in 1785, and three burials which all relate to children born in or after 1785. There is therefore and unfilled five year gap into which 'my' Benjamin could nicely fit.
Charles Hundley was a prominent Leeds radical and was one time secretary of the Leeds Constitutional Society, an organization that campaigned for the reform of Parliament.
On the 15th March 1794 Charles (under the name Handley) was brought before York Assizes on what appears to be a trumped up charge of dispersing a seditious paper. You have to remember that this was in the period following the French Revolution and the 'establishment' was getting a bit twitchy. He was sentenced to two years imprisonment in York Castle.
It appears that in 1801 Charles was the master of Knottingley Workhouse, and that in October of that year he went to Rotherham to give evidence in a settlement case. Whilst in Rotherham he was arrested and charged with stealing two pairs of shoes. Whether he did or not we'll never know. He was sentenced to three months imprisonment at Wakefield.
He was released from Wakefield on the 6th January 1802. After this date he disappears from the radar, but he must have died and he must have been buried. Question is, where? Dronfield would be excellent, but I may be just dreaming.