You are all amazing! They definitely were not in Carbondale in 1850, as the girls, Sarah, Anna and Margaret can be found in Montrose Wisconsin in the 1850 census after their father had died. I suspect they moved from Pennsylvania around 1840. A letter written by Margaret in 1900 states "Father and mother had two children when they came to this country. Their first child was a boy who died when it was small. All the rest were girls, five of them. I am the youngest. Their names were Mary and Sarah, Hannah, Ann and Margaret. We left Carbondale PA when I was 2 or 3 years old." We know that Sarah was born in 1830 in Wales...and Anna in 1836 in Pennsylvania...and Margaret in 1838 in Pennsylvania. We don't know what happened to Hannah. Mary died in Missouri, along with her mother as they were moving to Wisconsin. A marriage certificate of Margaret's shows the mother's name as Margaret, and she went by the name Hattie. Osprey, I think they could have married in 1827 and that is worth my investigating further. Thank you so much for your searches and information. (I know that Evans is a common Welsh name...but if the mother, Margaret was an Evans, it is of interest to note that Sarah also married an Evans who had immigrated from Wales. Long shot, but perhaps families knew each other. ) Thanks again for your help! Jean