Hi Arranroots
Thought I might update you. I recently searched the 1911 census for a William Matthews born 1851 monmouthshire and low and behold one came up for that date born Goytrey. He was a widower working as a colliery labourer above ground. The 1901 address in Senghenydd by 1911 was occupied by Edith and Edward Baverstock with their children. It is the first census entry since 1851 with a William Matthews being born 1851 in Goytrey.
I also recently did a search on the monmouthshire site. In the buriel index for Goytrey there is a:
Matthews, Matilda, 1955, Jul, 30, Myrtle Cott Goytre,
Matthews, Sarah , 1919, Jan, 12, Myrtle Cottage Goytrey,
Matthews, Wm George, 1920, Sep, 29, Glan Ely Hos Pentwyn Farm,
Matilda and Sarah would be william matthews's sister and mother. I wondered whether the William George was Edith Matthews father (she died 1913) so his only relatives by that time would be his siblings but thus far I have been unable to trace a death index entry for either William Matthews or any combination thereof. However, I have to say I think given everything its is more likely than not George William Matthews is my gg grandfather. Am I grasping at straws?
thanks for the help Sarenid