Hi - just looking at confusion of how many entries there are and where - and trying to clarify..
There appear to be three births one in each 1843 quarter of March, June and September.
Freebmd and cheshirebmd appear to have the same three. Ancestry has only two of them (one is missing, and one is duplicated/mis-transcribed) so it does appear to be a muddle. Hopefully this is clear...
If you search at Cheshire BMD it gives Maiden names for 2 of the three. But it does NOT tell you which quarter - just that they are 1843
CHESHIRE BMD (Local Reg Office Refs)
www.cheshirebmd.org.uk WHALLEY John GRIMSHAW 1843 Ashton Town Tameside Cheshire AST/10/63
WHALLEY John 1843 Eastham Cheshire West Cheshire EAS/2/94
WHALLEY John ASHTON 1843 Heaton Norris Stockport Cheshire HEA/7/77
if you search at freebmd it gives you the quarter - but NOT the maiden names.
Looking at the districts I think the three listed here match the ones at Cheshire BMD
FREEBMD.ORG.UK (GRO Ref)
March quarter 1843
Whalley John Wirral 19 321 (I think this is Eastham one)
Jun quarter 1843
Whalley John Stockport 19 249 (I think this is probably Heaton Norris one)
Sept quarter 1843
Whalley John Ashton 20 2 (this is the Ashton one)
on Ancestry (GRO Ref) you get:
John Whalley
Apr-May-Jun 1843
Registration District: Stockport (Cheshire)
Volume: 19
Page: 249 (plus the mis transcribed p 219 entry)
John Whalley
Jul-Aug-Sep 1843
Registration District: Ashton Under Lyne (Lancashire)
Volume: 2 (mis-transcribed should be vol 20)
Page: 2
The third entry in Wirral is not showing up on Ancestry. The page is digitised if you go page by page but it must be mistranscribed or missed out.
Also ....Just in case the cert you get is not right...
There is also a John Walley (without H) in Nantwich (Bunbury) to consider.
Two entries for him from the two sources - one giving Nantwich and one the more specific Bunbury (which is in Nantwich Reg District)
From Cheshire BMD
WALLEY John 1843 Bunbury Cheshire East Cheshire BU/04/065
From Free BMD
Dec 1843
WALLEY John Nantwich 19 138
Milly