RootsChat.Com

Scotland (Counties as in 1851-1901) => Scotland => Lanarkshire => Topic started by: Chris5856 on Friday 22 December 17 17:22 GMT (UK)

Title: More help- Different maiden names. Why?
Post by: Chris5856 on Friday 22 December 17 17:22 GMT (UK)
I have a real problem. For ages I thought these were two different families, but a birth confirms they are not.

Benjamin Galbraith was born 18 March 1867. It says on his birth cert that his mum and dad, John Galbraith & Ann Mackie were married on 2 November 1860 in Aberdeen.

A search on Scotlandspeople does indeed find that John & Ann were married on that date, but Ann's surname on that document in Reid. In Other births of their children she uses the name Reid and other its recorded as Mackie or McKay.  Cross referencing and addresses through Census returns confirm the children. But for some reason I cannot for the life of me wonder why she's using two different maiden names.

Any suggestions?

Chris
Title: Re: More help- Different maiden names. Why?
Post by: Ayashi on Friday 22 December 17 17:25 GMT (UK)
Could she be illegitimate or mother remarried?

I have a family where the mother was Elizabeth Jane Uglow HAMLEY, the illegitimate daughter of Elizabeth HAMLEY by an unspecified UGLOW. On the birth certs of the couple's three daughters her maiden name is correctly HAMLEY, however on the birth cert of their only son I always joke that the husband had a little bit too much cheer over it before registering, as he registered the baby with maiden name UGLOW.

As far as I know Elizabeth never used the name UGLOW, but she did use WALKER for a while (the name of the man she had illegitimate children with) and ROBBINS (the name of her step-father).
Title: Re: More help- Different maiden names. Why?
Post by: MaureeninNY on Friday 22 December 17 17:55 GMT (UK)
Were Ann's parents listed on the marriage to John ?

Maureen
Title: Re: More help- Different maiden names. Why?
Post by: philipsearching on Friday 22 December 17 23:10 GMT (UK)
Were Ann's parents listed on the marriage to John ?

Maureen

Or mother's maiden name on Ann's birth record?

Philip
Title: Re: More help- Different maiden names. Why?
Post by: wivenhoe on Saturday 23 December 17 02:01 GMT (UK)

"... In Other births of their children she uses the name Reid and other its recorded as Mackie or McKay."

For each birth certificate that you have -

Where mother is named REID, who is the informant?

Where mother is named MACKIE etc, who is the informant?

For the marriage certificate that you have, 2 Nov 1860, can you please list all the information.

Can you please identify this family in 1861 and 1871 census.