Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - scrimnet

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 ... 688
10
World War Two / Re: RASC / Desert Rats Ambulance/lorry drivers
« on: Saturday 29 April 23 17:56 BST (UK)  »
I have a couple of ambulance drivers in WWI (not WwII)

Both of them were in the RAMC (Royal Army MEDICAL corps) not the RASC (Royal Army SERVICE Corps).   They both had medical training gained when they were in the territorials 1911-1914.

The RASC drove the ambys, just liek the RLC , their successors do today. Medical Orderly's, or Combat Med Techs do thier med stuff.
I was with 4 GS Med Rgt for 2 years when the unit was operational in Iraq and Afghan.
Drivers drive, med staff do med stuff. Unless the RASC driver has been shot then they might drive...

I hear what you say, but Iraq was 2003, very much later than 1939-1945.

Whatever the circumstances during the war, after the war he worked for an employer of over 1,000 personnel in the first aid station.

I was pointing out that nothing had changed from the formation of the RAMC in 1898.

The ASC, RASC and RLC always provided the drivers for Ambys. Only in WW1 with things like the Friends Ambulance Service and individuals like Elsie and Mairi was it different.

I could get out all the WW2 regulations and photocopy them, but theres a reason why John Mills and Harry Andrews were badged RASC in Ice Cold In Alex.

11
Although this was true of WW1 records, it sadly no longer is. They were sold off.
And importantly ALL records post 1921 are STILL with the MOD only. They are migrating to the National Archives and ultimately digitisation, but you still have to go through Kentigern House atm.

Forces War Records is sadly a waste of time and money. They have nothing which is not either free and in the public domain, or on ancestry or FindMyPast....Avoid

https://www.gov.uk/guidance/request-records-of-deceased-service-personnel
Scrimnet, My comment about the Coldstream was based on this section contained in the TNA research Guide:
Quote
Service records of Guards regiments

The Coldstream Guards and Scots Guards regiments retain their own records. To access them write to or call the appropriate regimental headquarters.

For Grenadier, Irish and Welsh Guards service records visit the GOV.UK website.

Some of these records were destroyed by enemy bombing of the Guards chapel during the Second World War.
My understanding is that although the service records are with the MOD, the Guards hold quite a lot of unit level nominal rolls and other documentation which may be of help in identifying if Zoe's grandad was in the Coldstream Guards.

On your second point, I was not suggesting that she looks at FWR. The links are to WW2Talk with which I'm sure you are familiar and will acknowledge is an excellent forum.

As for FWR, its a general warning to the OP

12
Although this was true of WW1 records, it sadly no longer is. They were sold off.
And importantly ALL records post 1921 are STILL with the MOD only. They are migrating to the National Archives and ultimately digitisation, but you still have to go through Kentigern House atm.

Forces War Records is sadly a waste of time and money. They have nothing which is not either free and in the public domain, or on ancestry or FindMyPast....Avoid

https://www.gov.uk/guidance/request-records-of-deceased-service-personnel
Scrimnet, My comment about the Coldstream was based on this section contained in the TNA research Guide:
Quote
Service records of Guards regiments

The Coldstream Guards and Scots Guards regiments retain their own records. To access them write to or call the appropriate regimental headquarters.

For Grenadier, Irish and Welsh Guards service records visit the GOV.UK website.

Some of these records were destroyed by enemy bombing of the Guards chapel during the Second World War.
My understanding is that although the service records are with the MOD, the Guards hold quite a lot of unit level nominal rolls and other documentation which may be of help in identifying if Zoe's grandad was in the Coldstream Guards.

On your second point, I was not suggesting that she looks at FWR. The links are to WW2Talk with which I'm sure you are familiar and will acknowledge is an excellent forum.

I have a chum who is a big noise in the Guards museum. He told me at the end of last year that its all gone. All enquiries are now passed on, as I have mentioned it on a FB page.

13
Hi Zoe

Welcome to the forum.

The Grenadiers and Coldstream both had shoulder titles with white lettering on a red background so it's not clear from the photo which he might have been. The only difference is that the Coldstream used sanserif lettering, whereas the Grenadiers used letters with serifs. Unfortunately the photo isn't clear enough to show that sort of detail. If you have the original photo rather than the scan, try checking it with a magnifying glass.

I'm not sure what your dad meant about the buttons as there aren't any that I can see in this photo. I assume he was talking about the spacing of the No1 Tunic (the scarlett ones the Guards wear on ceremonial duties). If so then that doesn't really help here since your grandad is in battle dress.

Almost uniquely the Scots Guards and the Coldstream retained their own records for the period after 1920 so if your grandad was Coldstream you may be in luck tracking down his details. You need to contact their Regimental Headquarters with as much detail as you can supply. Sadly the same does not apply to the Grenadier Guards and the only place you will find their records is with the MOD. As you say it's difficult to apply for any service records without a death certificate but presumably you can get that fairly easily.

If you haven't already done so, I suggest you try putting his name into a search on the National Archives website along with the word Guards and limit the date range to 1939 - 1946. Something may just crop up, such as a medal award or casualty list entry.

You could also try searching for your grandad's name on the WW2Talk forum. They are assembling a list of known regimental numbers for the two regiments and you might just get lucky providing that his was a not too common surname.
http://WW2talk.com/index.php?threads/coldstream-guards-reference-thread.80210/
http://ww2talk.com/index.php?threads/grenadier-guards-reference-thread.80209/

If you post his name here, I'm sure some of our talented sleuths will find some more details for you.

Although this was true of WW1 records, it sadly no longer is. They were sold off.
And importantly ALL records post 1921 are STILL with the MOD only. They are migrating to the National Archives and ultimately digitisation, but you still have to go through Kentigern House atm.

Forces War Records is sadly a waste of time and money. They have nothing which is not either free and in the public domain, or on ancestry or FindMyPast....Avoid

https://www.gov.uk/guidance/request-records-of-deceased-service-personnel



14
Armed Forces / Re: 1877 - Gibraltar
« on: Saturday 29 April 23 13:15 BST (UK)  »
Kings or Queens Regulations for the Army give a list of varying categories for discharge.

This is the main health one, from flat footedness to loss of a limb or anything between, including mental health issues.

This category and exact wording is still in use today...I used it myself to discharge the injured Toms from Afghan!

15
Armed Forces / Re: 3rd Royal Lancs Regt Militai Pre 1851
« on: Saturday 29 April 23 13:09 BST (UK)  »
The files from WO97 ie the pre 1913 discharges of the British Army can be found on Find My Past...

16
Armed Forces / Re: 58th Regiment of Foot
« on: Saturday 29 April 23 13:02 BST (UK)  »
Hello again thanks for your interest in my questions - I am not sure how to find which ships my ancestor who was in the 58th would have sailed on - from what I've seen as he was only a private, it seems those at that rank aren't always listed by name. I have found all of his pension records on Ancestry from the National Archives UK but if you know of a source for looking into which ships he might have been on that would be great. Many thanks again.

the above book lists the ships and even in a worse case scenario you will narrow it down to one or two....The book is ONLY  for between 45 and 58...

17
Armed Forces / Re: Second Anglo-Afghan War 1878-80
« on: Saturday 29 April 23 12:58 BST (UK)  »
This is from the Times of India, Saturday 14 November 1874.

Points to note...One can ascertain the rank of the husbands when women with the army are mentioned...

Officers and their Ladies
Sergeants and their Wives
Soldiers and their Women

This was still the norm in the British army until the ....1990s!!

Any soldiers wife was just listed as "Wife of ...." in the records.
Many wives adopted the rank of their husbands so completely that they tried to run the lives of other women in the unit

18
Ancestral Family Tree DNA Testing / Re: How Welsh am I?
« on: Saturday 29 April 23 12:52 BST (UK)  »
Interestingly, the Welsh are actually the remains of the Ancient British tribes that once populated these Isles, often referred to as "Celts''.

They were driven into Wales, whilst the remainder were subject to the Romans, Jutes, Angles, Saxons, and Scandinavians.

They are probably actually more "British" than the rest of us in "Angle-Land"

 ;D

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 ... 688