Stories of lost estates and crooked solicitors always have a certain charm. I refer of course to the Samuel Alleyne family of Waterford. Here are such facts as I have been able to discover.
The story begins with the lease of 500 acres Irish Plantation Measure at Coolprevane by Walter Atkins to John Alleyne. The lease was dated 14 April 1779 and was for a period of three lives of Samuel and William AlleyneAlleyne, John Alleyne. The estate passed to John's son Samuel. He was the last of the 3 lives when he died in 1841. His widow Ellen (Scully) Alleyne renewed the lease with Gertrude Atkins in 1842 and Ellen in 1846 assigned the estate to her nephew Samuel William who in 1860 was married to Honoria Cowan. Now the plot thickens. In 1864 a Marriage Settlement was drawn up, Apparently at the insistence of Joseph Henry Cowen Hoichnoria's father, by whch Samuel was to get £2000 Fortune (i.e. Dowry) from the Cowen family and the lands of Coolprevane were to be handed over to trustees to guarantee Honoria's future. The trustees were Walter Richard Butler of Clondalkin and Edward Michael Duffy of Hardwick St. Dublin, Solicitor.
In Feb. 1865 Cowen Sen. sued Samuel in the Court of Common Pleas for -noncompliance with the terms of the settlement. Samuel lost and headed for the U.S. as we know.
In April1872 the lands of Coolprevane in the Barony of Iffa and Offa were offered for sale in the Encumbered Estates Court, the vendor being, not Samuel as you might expect, but Edward Michael Duffy, one of the trustees of the Marriage Settlement, and William Henry Alleyne, a minor (eldest son of Samuel's first marriage). The purchasers were the Russells, former tenants.
Well, that's the story. Whether Duffy was really a crook or simply acting in the best interests of his client (Cowen) must be for Samuel's descendants to decide
.