A sad Monica - my computer has just crashed and on husband's laptop which is no use to me at all
I also think I had a complete mental crash with my reference to surname Shakespeare, this was to do with a search I was doing earlier
I think we should hold off on guessing on Josiah's likely family until we get some confirmation from his marriage cert. There are potentially at least three sets of parents who it could be.
Do you have access to Ancestry.com. I only have the UK version. I did see a Bakewell family tree for Josiah and Mary Ann. Seems fairly comprehensive and includes details on sons Samuel and Josiah (Jesse) and descendents. It also includes images for censuses for the family from 1850 - 1930. Two things to note though:
1. It has no additional info on Josiah and Mary Ann's parents and siblings and their origins.
2. There seems to be a bit of a mix up on the data with the other Josiah and Mary that we have found on the English censuses.
In the main though, there is a lot of information which I am not sure if you have and would be worthwhile you checking.
You could also try contacting the tree owner, if not known to you, to try to compare notes
I'm going to go off now and scream in a dark room until I figure out my current computer crisis
Monica