I have read the existing threads but it is clear as mud.
John Montgomery of Naas married Anne Faulkner in 1770 at the age of 23 which means that he was born in 1747.
There seems to be no record of a marraige to a Bell girl
The John Montgomery son of Hercules and Jane born 1693 would have been 44 at the time John of Naas was born
There are other conflicting statements
My grandfather came over from Scotland in company with two of his brothers, who settled in the north of Ireland where they carried on large manufactories.
My grandfather settled in the county of Meath, where he built the mills of Naas.
He had three daughters, who at his death opened a boarding school in St. Steven's Green.
Among the Faulkner family papers at Castledown, Co Carlow, is a certificate of marriage between Anne Nancy Faulkner and John Montgomery of Crumlin, Co Antrim, a gentleman aged 23.
They were married on the 23 November 1770.
John had a flour mill at Oldtown Naas, Co Kildare.
Also The only John Montgomery born to John of Naas died at a young age
Is there a record of the linnage traced by William Bethan from Hugh Montgomery and Livinia Jane Hunckle
There is!
That was his first Marriage. Her father was Hercules, Governer of Derry
Their son Hercules Montgomery married Jane McNeil, dau of Archibald, Chancellor of Down Cathedral. Their son John b.1693 seems to have been ostracized from family.
John b.1693 had son Wm b.1717 who married Sarah Hardy, and their son John, b.1744 married Anne Faulkner, he died 1803, 10 children, Andrew* (married Rebecca Aiken) , John (1) , Colville, John (2), Samuel, Wm (d.1796) , Hugh (d.1804), Robert (d.1803) Ann, and Catherine.
Andrew* who married Rebecca Aiken had John, Samuel, Wm, Robert and Cath