William Shackleton

[Gibby1968]

That's them

[heywood]

That's them

That's right but I would say that he is not your William. The child Ann marries as Ann Waterhouse - she was born before the 1841 marriage.

Why do you and your friend think that the 1851 death is him?
Would you not consider this death?
March quarter 1849   William Shackleton     Keighley volume 23   page 287
Burial Keighley March 17th 1849 abode Branch House, Newsholme.

The death ties in with Rose being a widow. It might not be him but it is a better fit.

[Gibby1968]

My friend is correct.

Ann Waterhouse was born out of wedlock and Elizabeth was a legitimate child.

She has checked the information before passing it to me.

[Gibby1968]

Ann Waterhouse baptism;

http://search.ancestry.co.uk/cgi-bin/sse.dll?db=WYorkCoEBaptism&h=8700770&ti=5538&indiv=try&gss=pt&ssrc=pt_t71256687_p44342952751_kpidz0q3d44342952751z0q26pgz0q3d32768z0q26pgplz0q3dpid

Elizabeth Shackleton baptism;

http://search.ancestry.co.uk/cgi-bin/sse.dll?db=WYorkCoEBaptism&h=8702957&ti=5538&indiv=try&gss=pt&ssrc=pt_t71256687_p44342952752_kpidz0q3d44342952752z0q26pgz0q3d32768z0q26pgplz0q3dpid

[heywood]

Your  friend is correct with the baptisms - that's what I base the information re William Shackleton and Sarah Waterhouse and who is with Sarah in 1851 and very probably the one who dies in Bingley in 1851. That information is correct for a different William.

The death you have in 1851 certainly offers no proof that he is the one who married Rose in fact the other chap fits much better.

What does your friend think of the one who dies in Keighley in 1849?

Unless the earlier death is checked you can't be certain. I am sure your friend would agree.
Best wishes
Heywood
 

[valendale]

Rose Hindle married William Shackleton the son of Joseph Feb 1848 William must have died to enable Rose to marry James Stell 29 Sep 1852 in a church, and on the PR she is shown as a widow.

[Gibby1968]

I agree Valendale.

I am still working through this query.

It seems a little odd that Rose and William are not together on the 1851 census.

Rose is with James Stell whom she married in 1851 and William is with a Sarah Shackleton.  Both Rose and Sarah seem to have illegitimate children.

[heywood]

I apologise for repeating myself but the William who is with Sarah is a different person.

[valendale]

William Shackleton died in 1849 so he would not show on the 1851 census