First Isobel thank you for the time you have taken to help with my search:
At first your reply didn’t appear to have any link, but now I think that it does. My great Grandmother was called Margaret (nee Chambers) and was I believe born in Norwich. (Still searching for proof).
The 1911 English census has a Margaret Scougal 27 year old widow and daughter Winifred 8 years old visiting the Pigford family in Dudley. Winifred is said to have been born in Edinburgh Barracks. One of the Pigford children was born in Turfontein Transvaal, which brings the Army and Boer wars into the equation.
I appreciate the ages of Margaret are different, but I have found many such differences in censuses so do tend to pay less importance to them.
My GM always told us that she was born in Edinburgh Castle, I think she meant the Garrison to the castle. I did a search through the Edinburgh records office for my GM using both Scougal, Cutter and Cutler, but nothing showed up.
There are many Scougals in the North East and I do believe that is where Archie came from. I also know that is where my GM & GGM returned to after Archie’s death because my GM grew up in Shiremoor. I have been through the Scougalls on the North East but can’t find one will ALL of my GGF names!!! Again not that important as often not all names were added to the census forms by those who compiled them.
I think that my GGM married again in 1912, to a Mr. Thomas Cutter, but what happened there I do not know as Mother and daughter moved to West Cumberland to live. My GGM lived with a Robert Millward in Workington, I can find no proof that they ever married. My Gm married my GF the result of which is this enquiry!!!
What I am trying to do is find regiments garrisoned in Edinburgh at the time of MY GM’s birth. If my GGM was born in Norwich then that is where she would meet up with Archie. If he was a serving soldier then his Regiment would likely have been in the Norwich area 1895- 1899 say. If the same regiment is in Norwich and later Edinburgh in the correct periods then I can begin searching those regiments’ records.
It would be rather fitting if it turned out to be the Royal Scotts as my father served with them in WWII.
I hope all of this makes sense to you, again thank you for your time.
Best wishes,
David t