Yes, have already seen the 1851 census which Edward is Apprentice Blacksmith, it looks quite good, and Shrewsbury in not far from Madeley? But I think for sure our Edward would not have got his place of birth wrong, as when he marries, and Mary is pregnant in 1864 they return to Madeley I think to have their Edward born there as well. His son Edward was the only child born in Madeley. There were others born before and after this Edward and they did not make this journey again from Barrow. As far as I know. Just another thought too, perhaps there could be a baptism some where in Madeley as they were Catholics and I guess they would not have passed up this chance. And perhaps this will be where Edward Senior would also have been baptised, and we also have a clue of the infamous ANN JONES at his wedding
The Benjamin and Martha, I don't really think is our Mary, as the names are not in our family, and I really think that she would have passed Benjamin or Martha onto their children as names, don't you?
The names in our family of Jones is, John, Joseph, Mary, Rebecca, James, Thomas, George and Edward.
Frustrating isn't it.................I have had this problem from 1996! I just thought some fresh eyes may have helped.
Many thanks for your help and thoughts, Best wishes, Shirley.