I can see what you mean about the Silver Street register! However in the pre-formatted register there is a column which reads “In what parish and on what day born” so the information provided in that column does not indicate where a child was baptised.
I do think you could be right though. In 1837 the register was sent to ‘The Commissioners for enquiring into the State, Custody and Authenticity of Non-parochial Registers’. In the accompanying questionnaire it is stated that there were two ministers of Silver Street but there are many more names in the column showing the person who did the baptism. I’m thinking that these extra names could be itinerant or travelling ministers, attached to Silver Street, who went about the countryside baptising children as they went. This would account for the haphazard dating in the register - records only being entered when details were provided, often some time after the event. I’m not certain of this but it would make sense. It would also mean that Wilkinson could have been baptised somewhere near his home.
I looked at the other Methodist records relating to the Hexham Circuit and found a baptism for Mary Ann
Hexham Bethania Primitive Methodist, Bull Bank. Born Muggleswick 31st October 1833, baptised 9th November 1833, parents Thomas and Mary. I didn’t spot any of the others though.
Finally I went looking in Shotley burials to see whether Wilkinson was there. He wasn’t but I did find – Jacob Pattinson of Hole Row, buried 2nd October 1836 aged 5 years. No further details are provided on standard burial records but I think he has a good chance of being connected. Also, in the margin next to his name was ‘N’. It appeared against a few names and I suspect that it stands for non-conformist.
Christine