Goodalls of yorkshire

[groom]

From another source, Arthur's birth (confirmed by lyp24) was  06 Oct 1886, so doesn't look as if that is him.

[Ladyhawk]

I've been looking for possible GOODALL birth/baptism entries for

Arthur 1886
George 1893
edit Herbert 
Harold 1894

but not much luck 

Can't find Arthur on 1891 census and not having much luck with George & Herbert on later census
although there is a George of the right age with Y & M but he has a different surname 

1939 register has an
Arthur GOODALL 1886 & Beatrice 1891
Wetherby R.D. Yorkshire

[Ladyhawk]

From another source, Arthur's birth (confirmed by lyp24) was  06 Oct 1886,
 so doesn't look as if that is him.

1901 census has Arthur GOODALL pob Yearsley

can't find a Dec qtr. entry with surname GOODALL

Yearsley is in the reg. district for Easingwold - there's this entry

Dec 1886 Easingwold 9d 412
Arthur PALLISER

EDIT

possible death for this Arthur age 14 Easingwold Mar 1901

[rosie99]

Young had a sister Lucy who is in Sunderland in 1881 age 24 & single  RG11/5002 f4 page 2

possible marriage
March qtr 1887 
Diamond    Michael       
Goodall    Lucy       
Hanley    Dorothy       
Johnson    Thomas       
Sunderland    10a   740

Worth bearing in mind she could have returned to York to give birth 

1891 RG12/4132 folio 5 page 4  - she has nephew James Goodall age 3 born York staying with her

GOODALL, JAMES   no mothers maiden name
Sept Quarter 1887 in YORK  Volume 09D  Page 33

[rosie99]

It looks like James (1887) was the son of Young's sister Mary who married Henry Francis Morrell in March qtr 1891 - he is a stepson in 1901 RG13/4143 f104 p35

Maybe Arthur was also Mary's 

[rosie99]

I've been looking for possible GOODALL birth/baptism entries for

Arthur 1886
George 1893
Herbert 1894

but not much luck 

Do you think that the 'boarder' who is with Young on the next census is one of those 

EDIT  It is Harold not Herbert 
Could it be 
Birth June qtr 1893   
Harold Paley (no mothers maiden name)
York    9d   62

[rosie99]

Harold Paley
Christening 13 May 1893
St. Crux's Church, York
Mother Mary Letha Paley

Ignore that one he died in infancy

[lyp24]

Thankyou Rosie99  Ladyhawk and groom for your replies. Im finding it a bit of a puzzle .....what do they say? When one door opens another one nails itself shut!!

[rosie99]

From another source, Arthur's birth (confirmed by lyp24) was  06 Oct 1886, so doesn't look as if that is him.

Was this source the 1939 register.  I understand that there are a few entries others have found that the year has been slightly wrong.