Goodalls of yorkshire

[Ladyhawk]

I wonder if it was a second marriage for Margaret as there are no Goodall/Murrow births that I can see.

Sorry just noticed they were both single.

According to latest census NO children for this couple 

[Ladyhawk]

Im wondering the same BumbleB but looking at the marriage cert it is definately Young as father

What was Arthur Goodall's father's occupation?

[groom]

Very odd. Could the children be "adopted" ? Parents are quite old in the 1901 census.

[lyp24]

Thanks Ladyhawk in 1901 arthur  appears to be a servant in Newburgh yorkshire as state by smalltown girl. But still trying to find him in the 1891 census

[Ladyhawk]

Thanks Ladyhawk in 1901 arthur  appears to be a servant in Newburgh yorkshire as state by smalltown girl. But still trying to find him in the 1891 census

Arthur Goodall b 1885/6 york. married Beatrice Cooper 14/12/10.

I have the marriage cert in sutton on the forest York which states his father is either Jimmy (James) or Johnny and that Arthur was residing at that time in York.
 

I was actually asking about 'his father's occupation
What was written on the marriage certificate?

Edited
I can see from 1910  m/c that his father Young's occ  Tradesman & Arthur's occ Labourer

[Ladyhawk]

Have just come across this entry on F M P

Arthur GOODALL age 19 occ Labourer
Birth year   1886 St Crooks York
Service number   4678
Regiment   East Yorkshire Regiment - 15th Foot
Attestation date   16 Nov 1905
Attestation service number   4678
Attestation corps   East Yorkshire Regiment
details from British Army Service Records 1760-1915 Transcription

Some further details from this record
C of E
Grey eyes, light brown hair complexion fair
Height 5ft 3 ¾
Small scar below upper ear
Scar left breast
Q)  What is the Name & Residence  of present (or former) Master?
A)  Mr. Leetham & Co near the Town of York in the County of Yorkshire


Name & address of next of kin
Father Young Crossfields Yard Hungate
Mother Maggie     ditto

[groom]

I'm still finding it strange that there are no children registered with father Goodall and mother Murrow - by that time not to register a child could result in a fine. The fact that Maggie says she has had no children also makes me think they may not actually be theirs by birth.

[rosie99]

GRO index only has 2 birth registrations in York RD around 1885

GOODALL, ARTHUR  no mothers maiden name given on index     
December Quarter 1885 in YORK  Volume 09D  Page 38

GOODALL, ARTHUR       mmn BRITTON     
June qtr Quarter in YORK  Volume 09D  Page 29
Albert Goodall married Mary Britton Sept qtr 1883

The 1885 fits for date, does Young Goodall have a sister who could have given birth to this Arthur 

[rosie99]

It looks as though the 1887 Arthur died in infancy

from freebmd
Death Mar qtr1888   
GOODALL    Arthur    age 0   
York    9d   19