Comparing two photos: same Vorberg girl?

[hickoryhardscrabble]

It was addressed to Anna Carrie Vorberg on S. 12th street, St. Louis but not sent with a stamp. I know Anna lived on S. 12th street in the 1910 census and she was married in 1917, so that gives me a clue that it was sent around that time--and it is clearly marked with Hazel, Helen, and Howard.

I really believe the first communion girl is a Vorberg just based on her features, and the family is small. She has two other girl cousins b 1890 and 1892. Is the general consensus that the first communion picture is older or younger?

Thanks for your help!

[Scribble1952]

A communion dress is sometimes handed down in Famlies From one generation to another.
I would say looking at both pictures the girl in the middle on the first photo and the girl in the communion
dress are the same person.

[hickoryhardscrabble]

Thanks~I thought their faces looked so similar, and my family was sort of betting on it being the same girl, just out of proximity of the photos and so forth. She had two much older half sisters (her mother was married twice), in addition to mother and aunts. And I know they were Catholic (and not everyone in that box of photos was). Thanks to everyone for their thoughts on the topic!