James Kneebone, chr 1797 Redruth

[philipsearching]

The John chr 1798 in Gwennap  was the s/o Thomas and Mary NOEL. He married Elizabeth Phillips in 1819. Some of their children emigrated to Victoria Australia, John died pre 1851 as Elizabeth was a miners widow with 2 of her daughters in the 1851 census.
Thomas parents were Thomas and Honor Trewartha,  and all of the Trewartha researchers (including me) do not have a James.

I'm confused   
What other evidence is there that James existed?

(TREWARTHA - oooh, does this line link to Robert TREWARTHA married 10 Feb 1661 Gwennap Thomasin JAKE - my multiple-great grandparents?)

Philip

[diabak]

Hi Cousin
Yes, Robert and Thomsin/Thamsin Jake were my 6th g. grandparents.
James and Elizabeth Kneebone and children were in Redruth in 1841 and 1851.

[diabak]

This James is being a bit of a headache, his ancestors insist he is a son of Thomas and Mary Noel, with no confirmation except a note from someone in the Truro Family History Society some years ago. If there was any way to find the true parents of the James Kneebone who married Elizabeth Rabey Hosking in 1821 in Stithians it would be a miracle.
This Kneebone family (Thomas and Mary Noel) are part of the wider Trewartha clan, who have been well researched by better heads than mine.
How can I convince the descendants of James that he is not in the correct family?
Cheers