RootsChat.Com

General => The Common Room => Topic started by: Romilly on Thursday 21 November 13 18:25 GMT (UK)

Title: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: Romilly on Thursday 21 November 13 18:25 GMT (UK)

I've been puzzling over this one, - and wondered if anyone on here could help please?

If someone Married in 1846, - and then disappeared(!) How long would they have to be missing before they could be assumed to be dead? (Thus allowing the presumed Widow to remarry).

Hope that makes sense!

Cheers, Romilly.
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: avm228 on Thursday 21 November 13 18:26 GMT (UK)
Seven years.
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: Romilly on Thursday 21 November 13 18:29 GMT (UK)
Seven years.

Hmmm, - thats an interesting figure.

Was it the legal time allowed?

Romilly.
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: Greensleeves on Thursday 21 November 13 18:35 GMT (UK)
Quite often though the remaining spouse would remarry before that time elapsed,  although usually it meant moving to another parish to get away with it.
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: Romilly on Thursday 21 November 13 18:44 GMT (UK)

My reason for asking is that despite extensive searching, - I have been completely unable to find a Death Entry for the

William Dyer who Married Mary Kenward, (Widow) in Lingfield, Surrey in 1846.

They had a child, another William Dyer, - in Lingfield in July 1847, - but then William Dyer (senior) seems to completely disappear...

Mary Dyer, (Widow) Marries George Holman in East Grinstead in 1855, - but not before they have an illegitimate child in 1852.

I'm guessing that William Dyer (Senior) must have just taken off, - & that she had to wait until he could be assumed to be dead.

And so the 7yr rule could be the reason why the Marriage didn't take place until 1855?

Romilly.
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: majm on Thursday 21 November 13 20:23 GMT (UK)
Hi there,

An interesting question  ;D

May I share one aspect of the "Seven Years" .......

In the Antipodean colonies in the penal era, there were quite a number of marriages where at least one of the parties was apparently entering into a marriage, with the permission of the Governor, yet they seem to have had a living spouse back in their home county, and were telling the authorities of that earlier marriage.    One of the NSW Governors (Lachlan Macquarie, a Scotsman  :) ) encouraged these colonial marriages, afterall, if you were transported under a sentence of seven years or more, the marriage was effectively ended by that civil court sentence.   There were attempts to fund the transporting of families of those convicted persons at various times.   

Here's a paper that may help with details of the various English laws and the "beyond the seas" aspect towards the "seven years" issues.   I think "Death in absentia" may be the legal expression.   

http://www.aifs.gov.au/institute/seminars/finlay.html



Cheers,  JM

Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: AngelaR on Thursday 21 November 13 20:30 GMT (UK)
Sorry about butting in, but I just wanted to say 'thank you' to majm for that post.

I have wondered for some time about the transportation situation. If someone just disappears and isn't seen for 7 years, that makes a lot of sense. However, if the spouse is known to exist, but be out of reach for an inordinate length of time because of something like transportation, allowing a remarriage would be a de facto divorce, surely?

In English law, wouldn't this be comparable with someone committed to an asylum for 20plus years? The marriage was still held to exist in that case....

This may be a situation where colonial law was a lot more pragmatic than English law!
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: Romilly on Thursday 21 November 13 20:36 GMT (UK)

A very interesting paper majm, - many thanks for posting it.

I've just downloaded & printed it so that I can read it through in more detail...

Cheers, Romilly.
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: Jebber on Thursday 21 November 13 21:00 GMT (UK)
Romilly it is still seven years in the UK, it differs in other countries, you may find the following interesting.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declared_death_in_absentia

Jebber
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: Romilly on Thursday 21 November 13 22:01 GMT (UK)

Many thanks Jebber, - that is exactly what I was looking for!

Best Wishes, Romilly.
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: lordb on Friday 22 November 13 19:14 GMT (UK)
A further question please, If the spouse remarried would there be a comment on the MC other than 'widow' ?
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: Romilly on Friday 22 November 13 19:23 GMT (UK)

No, - I have the Marriage Cert for Mary Dyer and George Holman in East Grinstead in 1855, - and it just says 'Widow' for her.

Bearing in mind that she married William Dyer in 1846, their son was born in 1847, and she didn't marry George Holman until 1855... I'm guessing that she had to wait for 7yrs.

HTH, Romilly.
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: lordb on Friday 22 November 13 19:31 GMT (UK)
Thanks Romilly
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: Romilly on Friday 22 November 13 21:59 GMT (UK)

I'll post it here, - just to clarify.

Romilly.
Title: Re: How long before Death could be assumed?
Post by: jbml on Sunday 08 December 13 13:25 GMT (UK)
I have wondered for some time about the transportation situation. If someone just disappears and isn't seen for 7 years, that makes a lot of sense. However, if the spouse is known to exist, but be out of reach for an inordinate length of time because of something like transportation, allowing a remarriage would be a de facto divorce, surely?

I suspect the reasoning will have been along the lines that "By the time you have been here 7 years, your spouse back home will have been entitled to obtain a judicial declaration that you are presumed dead. They will probably do that. So let's assume it ... and let you get on with creating a new life for yourself right away.

Pragmatic? Certainly! Reduces the number of children whose parents die before they are of full age ...