RootsChat.Com

Ireland (Historical Counties) => Ireland => Cavan => Topic started by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 03:11 GMT (UK)

Title: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 03:11 GMT (UK)
Ok, so I've been having a difficult time finding civil records for a couple that I know married in 1868 in County Cavan, which is after civil registration began for marriages

Using RootsIreland.ie, I was able to find a church record for 12 June 1868 in Drumlane.  I could also find a microfilm on NLI as well.

However, if I use IrishGeneralogy.ie, I cannot find anything.

Here's the husband: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/KZZY-R4Y

I've also had limited success finding records for their children as well.

Any help appreciated.  Thanks!
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: athacliath62 on Wednesday 22 January 25 03:58 GMT (UK)
The marriage may not have been registered in civil records even though it should have been, there are gaps where the paperwork was never sent in.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Wednesday 22 January 25 04:19 GMT (UK)
What is the name of the church.  There are a couple:

St Columba
https://www.genuki.org.uk/big/IRL/CAV/Drumlane/St-Colomba-Killynaher-COI
 and
St Mary
https://www.genuki.org.uk/big/IRL/CAV/Drumlane/St-Mary-KILCONNY-STAGHALL-RC

Is the name of the wife Bridget Donohue?

Following the links you have given from William Maguire I have found this birth of a child
https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_returns/births_1869/03394/2244478.pdf



Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 04:27 GMT (UK)
Yes, wife's name is Bridget Donohue.  Born in Feugh Bishops, 19 April 1846

They were Roman Catholic.  Most of their children were baptized in St. Patrick's in Milltown. 

But I believe most (if not all) of the St Patrick's records aren't available on NLI, so I'm not actually sure which church they were married.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Wednesday 22 January 25 04:32 GMT (UK)
So where have you got the information with the marriage date in 1868 please? is it from Family Search?

So did William die in 1879 of phthisis?
https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_returns/deaths_1879/06496/4870050.pdf
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 04:37 GMT (UK)
Ok, so it looks like the NLI register says Staghall, which (I'm as I'm learning right now) is another town/church, near Belturbet.

Which wouldn't make sense, as her birth place was Feugh Bishops and his birthplace (Creeny) are by Milltown.

Unless, of course, her birth place was actually Feugh Maxwell, and at some point along the way, was confused with Feugh Bishops.  Feugh Maxwell is closer to Staghall than Milltown.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 04:40 GMT (UK)
So where have you got the information with the marriage date in 1868 please? is it from Family Search?
I couldn't find anything in FamilySearch about it.

I first located it on RootsIreland's index:
Date of Marriage: 12-Jun-1868       
Parish / District: Drumlane
County:   County Cavan

Husband      
Name: William Maguire   
Address: Creeny
Denomination: Roman Catholic
Occupation:   
Age:         
Status:

Wife
Name: Bridget Donohoe
Address: Feugh
Denomination: Roman Catholic
Occupation:         
Age:         
Status:         

Husband's Father      
Name:   John   Maguire
Address:         
Denomination:         
Occupation:
Wife's Father
   
Husband's Mother
Name:   Mary Maguire
Address:         
Denomination:         
Occupation:

Wife's Father
Name: Patrick Donohoe
Address:         
Denomination:         
Occupation:

Wife's Mother
Name: Bridget Donohoe
Address:         
Denomination:         
Occupation:
         
Witness 1      
Name: John McGannon
Witness 2
Name: Bridget Donohoe
Address:         
Notes:

Then I was able to find it on NLI parish registers, page 4: https://registers.nli.ie/registers/vtls000634855#page/4/mode/1up

12 June 1868 Marriage
Groom: William Maguire, Creeny
Groom's father: John Maguire
Groom's mother: Mary Maguire

Bride: Bridget Donohoe, Feugh
Bride's father: Patrick Donohue
Bride's mother: Bridget Donohue

Witness 1: John McGannon
Witness 2: Bridget Donohue
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Wednesday 22 January 25 04:44 GMT (UK)
Ok, so it looks like the NLI register says Staghall, which (I'm as I'm learning right now) is another town/church, near Belturbet.

Which wouldn't make sense, as her birth place was Feugh Bishops and his birthplace (Creeny) are by Milltown.

Unless, of course, her birth place was actually Feugh Maxwell, and at some point along the way, was confused with Feugh Bishops.  Feugh Maxwell is closer to Staghall than Milltown.

The church, St Mary's, at the link above is in Staghall.

Info on the town land of Drumlane
https://www.townlands.ie/cavan/loughtee-lower/drumlane/milltown/drumlane/

ETA Which the children are you missing Irish Genealogy links for? 
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 04:50 GMT (UK)
So did William die in 1879 of phthisis?
https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_returns/deaths_1879/06496/4870050.pdf
Yes, there might be a tiny bit of doubt left, but I couldn't find any children after Feb 1880, and I couldn't find any more dog registrations stopped in 1878.

I also suspect the odds of another William Maguire, of that same townland, of that same age, are very small.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 06:17 GMT (UK)
The church, St Mary's, at the link above is in Staghall.
I think I am more confused new.  Looking at Griffith's Valuation on RootsIreland.ie, there are Donohues in Feugh (Bishops), and none in Feugh Maxwell.  And Patrick's birth record says Feugh Bishop as well: https://registers.nli.ie/registers/vtls000634853#page/87/mode/1up

If they actually lived in Feugh Bishops, they would have gone right by St Patrick's in Milltown, and go another 4.4km to St Mary's in Staghall.

Info on the town land of Drumlane
https://www.townlands.ie/cavan/loughtee-lower/drumlane/milltown/drumlane/

ETA Which the children are you missing Irish Genealogy links for?
I've only had significant luck with 1 of the 8 children.  No 1901 census, marriage records, or obvious death records I could find.

John Maguire (https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/9DPQ-QCF) - have a 1869 birth records, and just a NY marriage record in 1896 and child in NY in 1898
Patt Maguire (https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/967J-Z1W) - 1870 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Mary Anne Maguire (https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/9VX4-Z3L) - 1873 birth record, possible (but I think unlikely) death record, but I think it's another townland, really illegible, so I haven't 100% ruled it out
Ellen Maguire (https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/KZRX-2CW) - 1874 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Thomas Maguire (https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/GBWL-CYH) - 1876 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Catherine Maguire (https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/9N6Z-XKS[/url) - 1880 record, but birth haven't found anything else
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Wednesday 22 January 25 20:38 GMT (UK)

If they actually lived in Feugh Bishops, they would have gone right by St Patrick's in Milltown, and go another 4.4km to St Mary's in Staghall.


There can be more than one church in a parish. While the records will be for all, the records will take the name of the parish church. Is that what is happening here?
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 22:08 GMT (UK)

If they actually lived in Feugh Bishops, they would have gone right by St Patrick's in Milltown, and go another 4.4km to St Mary's in Staghall.


There can be more than one church in a parish. While the records will be for all, the records will take the name of the parish church. Is that what is happening here?
I think this might be an exception to the rule here. 

I have not been able to find any other church records for the Maguire side of the family, except on the RootsIreland.ie index. The RootsIreland.ie index had links to the NLI parish registers, but I could never find an actual entry on them.

I asked RootsIreland about it and they said NLI only has the St Mary's Church for the Staghall area, but not the St Patrick's Church in Milltown.  I think they since removed the NLI links for St Patrick's church records, but I no longer have an active subscription there to confirm.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Wednesday 22 January 25 22:23 GMT (UK)

I think this might be an exception to the rule here. 


I don't think so.
According to the online guide for the parish of Drumlane, Co. Cavan, there are two churches within the parish, in Milltown and Staghall.
https://www.drumlane.ie/visitor-information/ (https://www.drumlane.ie/visitor-information/)
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Wednesday 22 January 25 22:38 GMT (UK)
At this point I have lost track of what the issue is - the parish register information for the 1868 marriage is in some ways better than a civil registration, as it has the names of both parents for both the bride and groom. Also has their addresses, the names of the witnesses, and the date of the marriage.

So there is little need for a civil registration version, which apparently doesn't exist. That being so, is there a remaining issue?
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 23:04 GMT (UK)
Well, I was hoping to find one, at least for collaborating evidence of the marriage.

If it was just that one particular civil marriage record is missing, so be it.

However, I haven't found much other information for the rest of that family, which makes me think I am doing something wrong when searching.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Wednesday 22 January 25 23:08 GMT (UK)
I really don't think that the 1868 parish record needs corroboration.

In addition, I see baptisms for at least 6 of their children in Drumlane. Have you not found those?
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Wednesday 22 January 25 23:43 GMT (UK)
Yes I did find those, but not much else afterward, except for James.

John Maguire - have a 1869 birth records, and just a NY marriage record in 1896 and child in NY in 1898
Patt Maguire - 1870 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Mary Anne Maguire - 1873 birth record, possible (but I think unlikely) death record, but I think it's another townland, really illegible, so I haven't 100% ruled it out
Ellen Maguire - 1874 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Thomas Maguire - 1876 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Catherine Maguire - 1880 record, but birth haven't found anything else

I did find a civil death record for Terence (1877-1880).

I suppose it's possible there's just not any records to be found... But I have more doubts about my ability to find them.  Wouldn't it be odd for the daughters to not get married?
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Wednesday 22 January 25 23:49 GMT (UK)
There are so many possibilities. This situation may or may not be unusual.

What was William Maguires occupation? It makes a huge difference if he was a farmer versus laborer, versus something else. Specifically, it tells us whether the family was likely to have stayed in one place, or have moved around.

What did the children/adults die of? If TB, then that could wipe out entire families - I have seen many instances. One possible record for William says he did die of TB.

As one family member emigrated, it is easy to suppose that others did also, and simply disappear from Irish records.

Oh, and lots of women (and men too) never married.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Wednesday 22 January 25 23:54 GMT (UK)
There are so many possibilities. This situation may or may not be unusual.

What was William Maguires occupation? It makes a huge difference if he was a farmer versus laborer, versus something else. Specifically, it tells us whether the family was likely to have stayed in one place, or have moved around.

What did the children/adults die of? If TB, then that could wipe out entire families - I have seen many instances.

As one family member emigrated, it is easy to suppose that others did also, and simply disappear from Irish records.

Oh, and lots of women never married.

Yes we have seen from earlier on (from your research) that the eldest son John Maguire migrated to NY. he may have set off what they call a chain migration of the rest of the family to the US, other parts of the UK and/or also Australia, Canada  or New Zealand.  Chain migrations can be close family based, wider family based or even village based. 
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Thursday 23 January 25 00:05 GMT (UK)
Re post nine and Mary Anne's birth registration, the name is Drummullagh from my reading  and is situated in the same locality .....you can see Creeny and Milltown slightly to the NE. The parents are William and Bridget formerly Donohoe


https://www.townlands.ie/cavan/loughtee-lower/drumlane/milltown/drummullagh/
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Thursday 23 January 25 00:12 GMT (UK)
First off, thank you all for your replies.

You are able to provide insights and ask questions that help greatly.

What was William Maguires occupation? It makes a huge difference if he was a farmer versus laborer, versus something else. Specifically, it tells us whether the family was likely to have stayed in one place, or have moved around.
Listed as a farmer on his children civil birth records and the death record I assume was for him.  I'm not well versed in the finer implications in the differences, but I assume a laborer would move around while a farmer would stay in one place?  Really good question to ask, thank you.

What did the children/adults die of? If TB, then that could wipe out entire families - I have seen many instances. One possible record for William says he did die of TB.
I'm 90% sure that was the same William that died of TB in 1879.  I found a death certificate for Terence, died age 2 in 1880 of enteritis.  But again, really haven't found any other civil records for the children
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 00:37 GMT (UK)

[William was] Listed as a farmer on his children civil birth records and the death record I assume was for him.  I'm not well versed in the finer implications in the differences, but I assume a laborer would move around while a farmer would stay in one place?  Really good question to ask, thank you.

Yes. A farmer is by definition attached to the land he holds. Not unknown for a farmer to move if he lost his holding or got a better one, but not an everyday occurrence. So, you can expect a farming family to pretty much stay put. By contrast, a landless laborer could move from farm to farm for work every year or so.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 00:41 GMT (UK)
I'm 90% sure that was the same William that died of TB in 1879.  I found a death certificate for Terence, died age 2 in 1880 of enteritis.  But again, really haven't found any other civil

I would say that William is 99% certain to be yours.  And that is very significant. The family lost their breadwinner when the children (6 or more of them) were all under 10 years of age. Might have lost the farm at that point and have to move. [I presume they were tenant farmers].
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 00:53 GMT (UK)

I have not been able to find any other church records for the Maguire side of the family, except on the RootsIreland.ie index. The RootsIreland.ie index had links to the NLI parish registers, but I could never find an actual entry on them.

I asked RootsIreland about it and they said NLI only has the St Mary's Church for the Staghall area, but not the St Patrick's Church in Milltown.  I think they since removed the NLI links for St Patrick's church records, but I no longer have an active subscription there to confirm.

OP - you may be misunderstanding what is going on.

Unfortunately, the NLI did not microfilm all extant Catholic parish records.  Anc*stry, DMP, etc source their transcriptions and indices from the NLI microfilm copies.

By contrast, RootsIreland transcriptions are typically or not necessarily sourced from the NLI microfilms. They had access to the original registers, including registers not copied by the NLI. Consequently you can find content on RootsIreland that is not available elsewhere.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 01:02 GMT (UK)
The eldest son, John Maguire, who emigrated to the US. Have you found him in US census returns, or naturalization records? They should give a year he emigrated to the US - which may be significant. Would also allow a search in passenger lists for around that time.

OP - which child do you descend from? I missed that along the way.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Thursday 23 January 25 01:20 GMT (UK)
I have not found census returns or naturalization returns in the US for John.  Common name makes things difficult, especially in a big city.

I descend from James (1871).  I have found his US/NY census returns from 1905-1950. As well as his 1900 marriage in NYC and his naturalization records.  There's a nearly 30 year gap between his birth and 1900 though - I can't find him in any US census, and his US immigration year was listed as between 1889 and 1898 over the years.  He applied for a certificate for arrival, but I don't think he ever got one and I haven't had much luck finding a passenger list record either.

My original plan was to get some more information on his siblings and other extended family in his home country might lend some clues to that 30 year gap.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 01:58 GMT (UK)
1855 record for Patrick Donohoe's holding in Feaugh.
You can see the size, condition and rating of his house, barn and byre.
http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf (http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf)
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 02:12 GMT (UK)
Patrick Donohoe's holding in the 1834 tythe valuation.
Note the areas are Irish, not English acres.
http://titheapplotmentbooks.nationalarchives.ie/reels/tab//004625690/004625690_00526.pdf (http://titheapplotmentbooks.nationalarchives.ie/reels/tab//004625690/004625690_00526.pdf)
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Thursday 23 January 25 02:27 GMT (UK)
What was John Maguires wife's name please?
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 02:28 GMT (UK)
In a tythe valuation of 1833, the civil parish of Drumlane is returned as part of the parish of Drumgood, so have to search the latter.
Quite a few Maguires, see this search. Note in particular James in Drummullagh.
http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tln/ (http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tln/)

Also one James Mcguire, in Feaugh (could be same person as above? - I don't know)
http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tlo/ (http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tlo/)
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 02:37 GMT (UK)
There is also Griffith's Valuation, of 1857, to search, but I have had enough for tonight!
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Thursday 23 January 25 03:16 GMT (UK)
What was John Maguires wife's name please?
Mary, was listed as Maguire in the baptism records I found

There is also Griffith's Valuation, of 1857, to search, but I have had enough for tonight!
Yes, you've certainly given me a lot go through!  Thank you!!
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Thursday 23 January 25 03:59 GMT (UK)
1855 record for Patrick Donohoe's holding in Feaugh.
You can see the size, condition and rating of his house, barn and byre.
http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf (http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf)
So first off, this was helpful, I didn't think to check these records.

However, looking at the details of the entry:
Surname   Forename   Event Year   Date of Valuation   Book   County   Barony   Parish   Townland
Donohoe   Patt   1855   Jan 1855   House book   Cavan   Loughtee Upper   Lavey & Larah   Feaugh

Feaugh is in the Loughtree Upper Barony would have been 30km away from Feugh Bishops, in the Loughtee Lower Barony/Drumlane parish.

So unless I'm mistaken, not likely to be a match.
 
Unfortunately, searching the Valuation office books (https://census.nationalarchives.ie/search/vob/index.jsp), I don't see any maguires or donohoe's in the Drumlane parish
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 04:07 GMT (UK)
1855 record for Patrick Donohoe's holding in Feaugh.
You can see the size, condition and rating of his house, barn and byre.
http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf (http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf)

Feaugh is in the Loughtree Upper Barony would have been 30km away from Feugh Bishops, in the Loughtee Lower Barony/Drumlane parish.

So unless I'm mistaken, not likely to be a match.


I am not personally familiar with Cavan and its social geography, so this is precisely the sort of double checking you need to do.  ;)

In my own family most marriages were with the "Girl next door", or at least from the same or adjacent parishes. That said, though, there were exceptions, some surprising exceptions, that I was only convinced of by DNA matches appearing.  Specifically a few marriages at 30 km distance in the 1830s by modest farming families. Another, more affluent pair married at a distance of over 50 km, also in the 1830s (didn't need DNA matching to know they were correct). So 30 km is not out of the question if they were two farming families that would meet at a common market town. Remember that farmers had to frequent a market.

As a check, I would look in detail at spelling variations for the townlands, which you can find on logainm.ie (http://logainm.ie) and townlands.ie (http://townlands.ie)
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Thursday 23 January 25 04:12 GMT (UK)
1855 record for Patrick Donohoe's holding in Feaugh.
You can see the size, condition and rating of his house, barn and byre.
http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf (http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf)
Unfortunately, searching the Valuation office books (https://census.nationalarchives.ie/search/vob/index.jsp), I don't see any maguires or donohoe's in the Drumlane parish

There is a reason for that. Different Valuation Office records survive for different parishes/electoral divisions. The records for Drumlane appear to be only "field books", not the "house books".  The field books only record the names of major householders, not everyone.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Thursday 23 January 25 04:39 GMT (UK)
Patrick Donohoe's holding in the 1834 tythe valuation.
Note the areas are Irish, not English acres.
http://titheapplotmentbooks.nationalarchives.ie/reels/tab//004625690/004625690_00526.pdf (http://titheapplotmentbooks.nationalarchives.ie/reels/tab//004625690/004625690_00526.pdf)
Same thing here, parish of Lavey, matches the feaugh of the first record.

1855 record for Patrick Donohoe's holding in Feaugh.
You can see the size, condition and rating of his house, barn and byre.
http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf (http://census.nationalarchives.ie/reels/vob/IRE_CENSUS_1821-51_007246925_00902.pdf)

Feaugh is in the Loughtree Upper Barony would have been 30km away from Feugh Bishops, in the Loughtee Lower Barony/Drumlane parish.

So unless I'm mistaken, not likely to be a match.


I am not personally familiar with Cavan and its social geography, so this is precisely the sort of double checking you need to do.  ;)

In my own family most marriages were with the "Girl next door", or at least from the same or adjacent parishes. That said, though, there were exceptions, some surprising exceptions, that I was only convinced of by DNA matches appearing.  Specifically a few marriages at 30 km distance in the 1830s by modest farming families. So 30 km is not out of the question if they were two farming families that would meet at a common market town. Remember that farmers had to frequent a market.

As a check, I would look in detail at spelling variations for the townlands, which you can find on logainm.ie (http://logainm.ie) and townlands.ie (http://townlands.ie)
Very fair questions to ask, and I certainly don't want to rule out anything prematurely.
All of the Donohoe children baptism record listed their residence as being Feugh, in the Drumlane parish.  They were baptized at (most likely) St Mary's Church in Staghall (and if not, St. Patrick's just a few kms away), which is also 23km away from that townland.  One child's baptism record was even listed as being from Feugh Maxwell.  So if they were in fact from Feaugh in Lavey, that would conflict with all their baptism records.

In a tythe valuation of 1833, the civil parish of Drumlane is returned as part of the parish of Drumgood, so have to search the latter.
Quite a few Maguires, see this search. Note in particular James in Drummullagh.
http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tln/ (http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tln/)
Good find.  Also a widow Maguire in Cruny (Creeny), same townland where William was born.  Possibly a grandma or aunt?

Also one James Mcguire, in Feaugh (could be same person as above? - I don't know)
http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tlo/ (http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tlo/)
Also a Pat Donohoe in Feaugh:
Donoho   Patt   Feaugh   Drumgoon   Cavan   1833, which is Feugh Bishop in the writing, which lines up with the Donohoe children records I found previously.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Thursday 23 January 25 21:31 GMT (UK)
I have not found census returns or naturalization returns in the US for John.  Common name makes things difficult, especially in a big city.

I descend from James (1871).  I have found his US/NY census returns from 1905-1950. As well as his 1900 marriage in NYC and his naturalization records.  There's a nearly 30 year gap between his birth and 1900 though - I can't find him in any US census, and his US immigration year was listed as between 1889 and 1898 over the years.  He applied for a certificate for arrival, but I don't think he ever got one and I haven't had much luck finding a passenger list record either.

My original plan was to get some more information on his siblings and other extended family in his home country might lend some clues to that 30 year gap.

But James does not appear on the list you provided a earlier? Is this not a complete list of the children?

I've only had significant luck with 1 of the 8 children.  No 1901 census, marriage records, or obvious death records I could find.

John Maguire - have a 1869 birth records, and just a NY marriage record in 1896 and child in NY in 1898
Patt Maguire - 1870 birth record, but haven't found anything else
James Maguire?????1871
Mary Anne Maguire - 1873 birth record, possible (but I think unlikely) death record, but I think it's another townland, really illegible, so I haven't 100% ruled it out
Ellen Maguire - 1874 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Thomas Maguire - 1876 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Catherine Maguire - 1880 record, but birth haven't found anything else

Then we have the same  list but with an addition of Terence


        I did find a civil death record for Terence (1877-1880).

So have you found 8 children?

John Maguire - have a 1869 birth records, and just a NY marriage record in 1896 and child in NY in 1898
Patt Maguire - 1870 birth record, but haven't found anything else
James Maguire?????1871
Mary Anne Maguire - 1873 birth record, possible (but I think unlikely) death record, but I think it's another townland, really illegible, so I haven't 100% ruled it out
Ellen Maguire - 1874 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Thomas Maguire - 1876 birth record, but haven't found anything else
Terence Maguire   - 1877 -1880 birth and death records found ???
Catherine Maguire - 1880 record, but birth haven't found anything else
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Thursday 23 January 25 22:44 GMT (UK)
Just looking at James.

There is an 18 year old James Maguire travelling to NY on the Furnessia???? in1889. There is a sheet with his name on but there is nothing on the sheet to show it was the Furnessia. The coversheet from FS says it is an extract from the Furnessia.

The Furnessia travelled from Glasgow to New York via Moville in Co Londonderry arriving on 15/10/1889.  Without further digging I cannot find out if this James embarked at Moville or at Glasgow. Moville often suited better than a trip to Glasgow. 
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Thursday 23 January 25 23:56 GMT (UK)
But James does not appear on the list you provided a earlier? Is this not a complete list of the children?
Yes, I had originally provided a list of children I would like to find more information on, as I did not much luck on them.  I have found a lot of information on James (at least in the US) and I did find Terence's death record indicating he died at an early age.

I've only had significant luck with 1 of the 8 children.  No 1901 census, marriage records, or obvious death records I could find.
Well, at least I wasn't doing something extremely wrong - that's been the results of my search efforts so far as well  :( EDIT: misattributed quote

So have you found 8 children?
Yes, that's correct!  Sorry about the confusion.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Friday 24 January 25 00:32 GMT (UK)
I've only had significant luck with 1 of the 8 children.  No 1901 census, marriage records, or obvious death records I could find.

NB this was a quote from you that I requoted. 

I have not yet started looking for these children as I wanted to make sure I had the complete list born to the couple. 
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Friday 24 January 25 02:07 GMT (UK)
What I see  on a transcript for James is
Born 10/11/1871, bapt, 21/11/1871, Drumlane, address Drumalough.
Sponsors James Maguire and Ann Donohoe

I have posted this partly in order to ask if OP has kept track of sponsors at baptisms, and informants/witnesses at civil BMDs?

I don't see a civil registration for James.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Friday 24 January 25 02:16 GMT (UK)
Sorry about the misquote - edited my post.

Yes, I copied the sponsors/witness info when I remembered to.  But I've never had much luck linking them to other people.

That's a good idea to take another look to see if they had consistent sponsors.

Sponsor James Maguire, could have been William's older brother, born 1842.
Sponsor Ann Donohoe, maybe Mary Anne, Bridget's little sister, born 1852
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Friday 24 January 25 03:54 GMT (UK)
Sponsors:
* William b 1845 in Creeny (father), Mathew Reilly and Rose Fitzpatrick
* Bridget b 1846 in Feugh (mother), Lawrence Reilly and Bridget Reilly

* John Maguire, b 1869, I don't church a church record, not known
* Patt Maguire, b 1870, I don't have a church record, not known
* James Maguire, b 1871, James Maguire and Ann Donohoe
* Mary Anne Maguire, b 1873 James Maguire and Ann Donohoe
* Ellen Maguire, b 1874, Patrick Donohoe and Ellenor Donohoe
* Thomas Maguire, b 1876, John Reilly and Mary Donohoe
* Terence Maguire, b 1877, Laurence Reilly and Margaret Gormly
* Catherine Maguire, b 1880, James Maguire and Mary Donohoe

I also found an 1876 petty court session where William Maguire, Terence Donohoe and Peter Donohoe and two others got into a scuffle with some Monaghans: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/memories/KZZY-R4Y

If it the sponsor was in fact William's brother James, I don't see any neices/nephews with him in 1901: https://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Cavan/Milltown/Creeney/1064330/
The brother James did stay in Creeny until his death in 1927.

I can find a Patrick and Mary Donohue in Feughbishop, but both are children in 1901: https://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Cavan/Milltown/Feughbishop_or_Drumalla/1064423/

Found a Mary Donohoe listed as a niece to Heugh Brown in Creeny, but age isn't very close: https://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Cavan/Milltown/Creeney/1064338/
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Friday 24 January 25 04:10 GMT (UK)
Strange, no church records for John (1869) and Patrick (1870).

Civil registration for John, 1869
https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_returns/births_1869/03394/2244478.pdf (https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_returns/births_1869/03394/2244478.pdf)

And for Patrick (Patt), 1870
https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_returns/births_1870/03333/2221631.pdf (https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_returns/births_1870/03333/2221631.pdf)

Is it the case that there are some children for whom there is civil registration but no baptism, but also the reverse, some for whom there is a baptism, but no civil registration?
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Friday 24 January 25 04:33 GMT (UK)
Yes, I must not have found any church records on RootsIreland when I had my subscription there.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Friday 24 January 25 04:35 GMT (UK)
Yes, I must not have found any church records on RootsIreland when I had my subscription there.

Sorry for the ambiguous comment. I don't see any for John and Patrick either.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Friday 24 January 25 05:19 GMT (UK)

Mary Anne Maguire - 1873 birth record, possible (but I think unlikely) death record, but I think it's another townland, really illegible, so I haven't 100% ruled it out


This death, on 2/8/1878?
https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_returns/deaths_1878/020501/7194092.pdf (https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_returns/deaths_1878/020501/7194092.pdf)

Daughter of a laborer, registered by a Bridget Maguire, present at death. Address Lagan
Lagan is in the civil parish of Drumlane
https://www.townlands.ie/cavan/loughtee-lower/drumlane/ardue/lagan/ (https://www.townlands.ie/cavan/loughtee-lower/drumlane/ardue/lagan/)

Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Friday 24 January 25 05:25 GMT (UK)
Birth of Terence Maguire 14/12/1878, informant William Maguire, father
https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_returns/births_1878/02975/2089836.pdf (https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_returns/births_1878/02975/2089836.pdf)

Death of Terence Maguire 17/10/1880, informant Bridget Maguire.
https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_returns/deaths_1880/06458/4856525.pdf (https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_returns/deaths_1880/06458/4856525.pdf)

This 1880 death shows that the family were still in the one spot 10 months after William died. However, how practical would it have been for Bridget to raise 7 children under the age of 11, and simultaneously run the farm?
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Friday 24 January 25 19:25 GMT (UK)
This death, on 2/8/1878?
https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_returns/deaths_1878/020501/7194092.pdf (https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_returns/deaths_1878/020501/7194092.pdf)

Daughter of a laborer, registered by a Bridget Maguire, present at death. Address Lagan
Lagan is in the civil parish of Drumlane
https://www.townlands.ie/cavan/loughtee-lower/drumlane/ardue/lagan/ (https://www.townlands.ie/cavan/loughtee-lower/drumlane/ardue/lagan/)
Yes, that was the one.  I'm now thinking that's not probably not a match as they were still in Drummullagh at the time (at least until Oct 1880).  Also the father was a farmer, and now I know there was a distinction between farmer and laborer.

Lagan looks to be about 10-13km away from Drummullagh.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Friday 24 January 25 20:31 GMT (UK)
Yes, that was the one.  I'm now thinking that's not probably not a match as they were still in Drummullagh at the time (at least until Oct 1880).  Also the father was a farmer, and now I know there was a distinction between farmer and laborer.

Lagan looks to be about 10-13km away from Drummullagh.

I would tend to agree. Posted the link for reference, and also because there was a comment that the handwriting was difficult to read.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Friday 24 January 25 20:40 GMT (UK)
One fly in the ointment in this whole picture of William Maguire being a farmer in Drummullagh is that there is no Maguire or Donohoe there in Griffith's Valuation of 1857.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Friday 24 January 25 20:53 GMT (UK)
One fly in the ointment in this whole picture of William Maguire being a farmer in Drummullagh is that there is no Maguire or Donohoe there in Griffith's Valuation of 1857.
I think that's expected.  William was born in Creeny in 1845, and was listed as a resident of Creeny during his April 1868 marriage.  I suspect they moved to Drummullagh after their marriage and before their first son was born in 1869.

On a side note, I discovered that the St Patrick's Church in Milltown was built in 1868, that would explain why many of the earlier records were at the St Mary's Staghall church, which was built circa 1850.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Saturday 25 January 25 20:39 GMT (UK)
Unfortunately, I haven't yet figured out how to find primary Griffith's valuation records by townland.  I'd be interested to see who is listed for Creeny and Feugh Bishops.  I will need to try next time I'm in a family search center.

On another note.  I have two potential leads for John and Thomas, both in the US.

For Thomas, I found a marriage record (https://www.familysearch.org/memories/memory/214915558) for a Thomas F McGuire, born ~1881 in County Cavan, parents William and Bridget Donohoe.  Searching the Irish civil birth registers, I can't find any other Thomas with those parents except the one born 1876 in Drummullagh. Of course, this marriage was much later in life, so I'm not 100% sure on accuracy and I can't find any information on his first marriage yet.

I also found Thomas's Veteran's Master Index card (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CS1T-B3DF-H?view=index&personArk=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3AW9LM-QVPZ&action=view&cc=2968245). He enlisted on the same date as James did (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CS1T-B3MD-Q?view=index&personArk=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3AW92P-636Z&action=view&cc=2968245).  I'm not sure if there's any significance of enlisting on the same date or not.

As for John.  I've never been able to find James in the 1900 US Census (which occurred in June), despite knowing he listed his address as 241 E 28th when was married in April 1900.  I found 241 E 28th in the 1900 Census and found a John MacGurie, wife and child (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:S3HT-67JH-PD?view=index&personArk=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3AMSVB-SHX&action=view&cc=1325221).  They were listed as being married for 2 years, so the timing would be tight, but he could have remarried after the death of his first wife in April 1898 and had a child by Dec 1899.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Saturday 25 January 25 20:41 GMT (UK)
Unfortunately, I haven't yet figured out how to find primary Griffith's valuation records by townland. 

Simple. Go to following site and search by place.
https://www.askaboutireland.ie/griffith-valuation/ (https://www.askaboutireland.ie/griffith-valuation/)
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Saturday 25 January 25 21:15 GMT (UK)
Thank you very much!

Found Patrick Donohoe, row 30 in Feugh Bishops: https://griffiths.askaboutireland.ie/gv4/z/zoomifyDynamicViewer.php?file=028195&path=./pix/028/&rs=25&showpage=1&mysession=2957801067430&width=&height=

As well as several other Donohoes- Philip, with house and land, Thomas with house and land, and Laurence with just land and an unoccupied house?  Possibly siblings or cousins?  I think Laurence lines up with a name on a petty court session I found (https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/memories/KZZY-R4Y)with William.

And found John Maguire, row 18 in Creeny: https://griffiths.askaboutireland.ie/gv4/z/zoomifyDynamicViewer.php?file=028184&path=./pix/028/&rs=&showpage=1&mysession=2957802857934&width=&height=
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Sunday 26 January 25 04:34 GMT (UK)
Found two very good hints:

* Patrick Donohue, Feugh Bishops, age 88, death record, 25 Jan 1900.  Informant Bridget Maguire, daughter, residing in Feugh Bishops!!  https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_returns/deaths_1900/05769/4630424.pdf
* Also, Family search found a weak hint for a Calendar of wills.  Estate of Patrick Donohue left to Bridge Maguire, Widow.   https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33S7-9TM8-1QH?i=342

ETA, ofc I can't find her in 1901 census yet..
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: Wexflyer on Sunday 26 January 25 04:36 GMT (UK)
If OP is interested, the maps to be found on the Griffith's valuation site show the exact locations of farms and houses.
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Sunday 26 January 25 07:47 GMT (UK)
Unfortunately, I haven't yet figured out how to find primary Griffith's valuation records by townland. 

Simple. Go to following site and search by place.
https://www.askaboutireland.ie/griffith-valuation/ (https://www.askaboutireland.ie/griffith-valuation/)

Also the brilliant options to search on GV is by Griffiths names when you can search at county level right down to townland with a surname or surname plus forename plus County plus townland or whatever you have.

Next to the names search is one called Griffiths Places. This is where magic happens.  (I think!) You can often see where /how  the girl/boy next door marriages that Wexflyer has referred to could happen - they lived in the same townland, went to the same market towns and worshipped at the same churches.

It shows the inhabitants.

So putting in Drummallagh and Cavan in the search field returns this list of inhabitants

http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tlz/

then

Creeny

http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tm0/

You can do similar on the National census......

https://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/

 if you look under the Browse button.  Ordinary searches will also do this but I sometimes use the browse funcion. Don't forget that Co Cavan has pieces of early Censuses such as 1821, 1841 & 1851. (many other counties have very sparse early census records)
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Sunday 26 January 25 07:59 GMT (UK)
Yes, that would be cool to see, unfortunately, I cannot seem to get the map links to load properly.  The website just hangs for me.  Tried on a few different computers and browsers too.

I cannot find a death records for Bridget Maguire in 1900 or 1901.

I also cannot find Bridget Maguire (or anyone remotely close) in 1901 census in Feugh Bishops.

Found two Donohoe families still in Feugh Bishop in 1901 (and 1911, for that matter):

* Peter Donohue, age 50 in 1901, father Daniel
https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/PMJQ-7FX
* Michael Donohoe, age 60 in 1901, father Thomas.  Think I found his 1839 baptism record in the NLI registers - parents Thomas and Mary.  Also siblings Thomas b 1836, Patrick b 1841 and Mary Anne b 1845.

Cousins maybe? (Bridget's father Patrick, 1812-1900)

Circling back to the Griffith's valuation:
* Philip Donohoe, position 14, map reference 12, 13
* Thomas Donohoe, position 15, map reference 14, 15 (Father of Michael?)
* Patrick Donohoe, position 25, map reference 31, 32  (Father of Bridget?)
* Laurence Donohoe, position ?, map reference 38

and the 1833 Tithe books:
* Patt Donohoe
* Terence (or Possible Laurence) Donohoe
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: jamesm113 on Sunday 26 January 25 20:20 GMT (UK)
Unfortunately, I haven't yet figured out how to find primary Griffith's valuation records by townland. 

Simple. Go to following site and search by place.
https://www.askaboutireland.ie/griffith-valuation/ (https://www.askaboutireland.ie/griffith-valuation/)

Also the brilliant options to search on GV is by Griffiths names when you can search at county level right down to townland with a surname or surname plus forename plus County plus townland or whatever you have.

Next to the names search is one called Griffiths Places. This is where magic happens.  (I think!) You can often see where /how  the girl/boy next door marriages that Wexflyer has referred to could happen - they lived in the same townland, went to the same market towns and worshipped at the same churches.

It shows the inhabitants.

So putting in Drummallagh and Cavan in the search field returns this list of inhabitants

http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tlz/

then

Creeny

http://www.rootschat.com/links/01tm0/

You can do similar on the National census......

https://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/

 if you look under the Browse button.  Ordinary searches will also do this but I sometimes use the browse funcion. Don't forget that Co Cavan has pieces of early Censuses such as 1821, 1841 & 1851. (many other counties have very sparse early census records)
Yes helpful tip, I've been searching by townland/place to "audit" who is living where!
Title: Re: Help finding civil marriage records
Post by: shanreagh on Sunday 26 January 25 20:42 GMT (UK)
Yes, that would be cool to see, unfortunately, I cannot seem to get the map links to load properly.  The website just hangs for me.  Tried on a few different computers and browsers too.

....

This may be a case of 'expectations' I feel.

The primary set of maps are drawn from those used by Griffiths.  They will look different to modern type maps and to our eyes..  They also rely on you searching for the plot. So it won't do a Google Streetview and hurtle you straight into the area.  It will take you to the location and then you magnify and search around.  There are also little letters like a, b and these can refer to tiny plots.
You can toggle between mid 1800s maps and more modern ones. 

I've been using these maps ever since I discovered them and they were instrumental in me locating the Shanreagh townland in the north by just driving out the road, making the turns and there it was.  Rural landscapes don't change as fast as those in cities. 

This is the screen that you get and you then move/toggle.  Just a note the waiting for the map to load does take seconds longer than we have become accustomed to.  This is Shanreagh TL in the north.