RootsChat.Com

Research in Other Countries => Australia => Topic started by: WoodElf on Wednesday 06 June 07 10:07 BST (UK)

Title: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Wednesday 06 June 07 10:07 BST (UK)
Hiya,   ;)

My stepfather is having trouble finding information on his paternal grandfather, Arthur Pannell (seeing as he is computer illiterate :P). All we know is his death on the 8th Sep. 1968 in Naracoorte, South Australia and his wife, Florence Bridget (maiden name unknown). The insurmountable difficulty is that we do not know his birth date and his parents name. 

I think that there may be an added factor to not being able to find information. When Florence died in 1941 after childbirth, she was Catholic and her husband, Arthur was not. In her will she expressly stated that her children be put in an orphanage and become wards of the state because Arthur was not Catholic and "could not look after the children". I don't know if that stops you from finding information, because with the whole adoption privacy thing.

Ciao!!

Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Wednesday 06 June 07 10:34 BST (UK)
Hi

This could be Arthur's birth reg

PANNELL  Arthur  31.12.1891 
Father  Arthur James PANNELL
Mother  Bridget Mary WHITE
at Mt Gambier   Ref:  Gre 492/142

Cheers
cando

edit- This could be your step gt grandfather's birth - too many Arthur PANNELL's  ;)

What was Arthur's age at in 1968 when he died?
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Wednesday 06 June 07 10:50 BST (UK)
Nope... I don't reckon that's helpful!
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Wednesday 06 June 07 10:51 BST (UK)
Hi

Here is another birth of another Arthur

PANNELL  Arthur William  30 July 1916
Father   Arthur James
Mother Mary Florence NOOLAN
at Mt Gambier  Ref  Gre  983/366


cheers
cando

Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Wednesday 06 June 07 10:54 BST (UK)
That would not fit the time frame
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Wednesday 06 June 07 10:59 BST (UK)
Deleted - posted before completion of data ???

Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Wednesday 06 June 07 11:00 BST (UK)
Hope its successful!!
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Wednesday 06 June 07 11:02 BST (UK)
I have checked the death in 1968 and he was 70 - and this is the only birth that fits the time frame.

PANNELL Arthur  22.3.1898
Father  George
Mother Annie HAASE
as Penola   Ref  Gre 619/322

It would have been helpful if you had provided the age at the date of death in 1968 - it was slightly misleading mentioning a wife's death in 1941 with chn;D

cando
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Wednesday 06 June 07 11:04 BST (UK)
Thank you very much. Sorry for being misleading.. I makes sense now!
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Wednesday 06 June 07 11:09 BST (UK)
Now if that is the correct one I have found a lot more chn born to this couple - including Annie's full name Annie Caroline Bertha HAASSE - the other spellings are HAASE.

Would you like the other chn's details.

cando
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Wednesday 06 June 07 11:11 BST (UK)
Thank you.. Yes I would love to know the other children's name
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Wednesday 06 June 07 11:52 BST (UK)
Well we got there eventually ;D

Chn of George PANNELL and Annie Caroline Bertha HAASSE - all at Penola  also HAASE

PANNELL  George Frederick  29 Aug 1886  Gre 382/179
PANNELL  Garnet Wolsley   25 Feb 1890    Gre454/244
PANNELL  Florence  17 Nov 1892   Gre 512/42
PANNELL  Frank Edward  26 Jun 1895   Gre 567/276
PANNELL  Johanna May  19 May 1901  Gre677/261

Here is their marriage - entered in the index as CANNELL - bit of a search  :(

PANNELL  George 26 yrs  Single  Father James  30 Dec 1885
=
HAASE Annie  21 yrs Single  Father  Frederick
at Residence of A J  Pannell, Mt Gambier
Gre 145/354

Cheers
cando
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Wednesday 06 June 07 11:55 BST (UK)
Thank you for your time and efforts..  ;D
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: tropicalj on Thursday 07 June 07 00:55 BST (UK)
Well done finding this marriage Cando, ;D

It does take a fair bit of time and effort especially  if you have to troll through the indexs. Folks don't often realize whats involved in helping them find the relo's

regards jenn

Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: tropicalj on Thursday 07 June 07 00:57 BST (UK)
Nope... I don't reckon that's helpful!

Oh and meant to say thats this sort of comment  often  turns people off helping search for relationship

Regards Jenn
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Friday 08 June 07 08:38 BST (UK)
Sorry, it wasn't intended that way.. ???
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Tuesday 26 June 07 05:52 BST (UK)
How would you be able to get hold of South Australian birth, deaths and marriages indexes?
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: tropicalj on Tuesday 26 June 07 06:40 BST (UK)
hello  there

they are not on line but a number of us have them also some local library depending on where you are
regards jenn
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: deeiluka on Tuesday 26 June 07 07:00 BST (UK)
How would you be able to get hold of South Australian birth, deaths and marriages indexes?

If you are interested in buying any of them, you can do so through the South Australian Genealogy and Heraldy Society. You can find more information on their website .... www.saghs.org.au/

.......dee
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Tuesday 26 June 07 08:22 BST (UK)
Can you access it through LDS centres?
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: deeiluka on Wednesday 27 June 07 01:55 BST (UK)
Sorry - no. Only through SAGHS at their library in Unley, South Australia, other libraries that have the Indexes in Australia, and from the published indexes on CDs, books or microfiche.

.....dee
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Wednesday 27 June 07 06:53 BST (UK)
Oh well... Thanks
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: sparrett on Wednesday 27 June 07 07:49 BST (UK)
Annie Caroline Bertha Pannell buried at Penola in 1956 aged 91
Garnett also. 1961
Arthur appears to be at Naracoorte
Florence Bridget Pannell 1941 at Murray Bricge aged 38
Sue
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: tropicalj on Wednesday 27 June 07 08:26 BST (UK)
Quote
think that there may be an added factor to not being able to find information. When Florence died in 1941 after childbirth, she was Catholic and her husband, Arthur was not. In her will she expressly stated that her children be put in an orphanage and become wards of the state because Arthur was not Catholic and "could not look after the children". I don't know if that stops you from finding information, because with the whole adoption privacy thing]

were the children put into homes? didn't arthur have any rights as the father?

regards jenn
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Wednesday 27 June 07 10:31 BST (UK)
Hi

I have re-read the post and wondering what info you are looking for -

I think you may want details of Arthur's and Florence Bridget's marriage as you aren't aware of her surname.

MARRIAGE

PANNELL Arthur 33 S  7 Jul 1937  Father George PANNELL
=
McCABE Florence Bridget  28 S   Father John Joseph McCABE 
at Catholic Presbytery, Murray Bridge  Ref: Pin 328/54

Now this is a bit interesting

PANNELL  Frank Edward 32 S 12 Dec 1927 Father George PANNELL
=
McCABE  Elizabeth May 26 S  Father John Joseph McCABE
at St Pauls Presbytery, Mount Gambier   Ref  Gre 313/874

Two brothers married two sisters.

Arthur's sisters' marriages

PANNELL
  Florence 27 S 10 Feb 1920  Father George PANNELL
=
CAIN William Anthony 25 S Father Alfred John CAIN
at St Pauls Church, Mount Gambier   Ref  Gre 282/420


PANNELL Johanna May 24 S 2 Jan 1926  Father George PANNELL
=
PATTERSON Charles Stewart 29 S  Father James PATTERSON
at St Andrews Presbyterian Church, Penola  Ref Gre 304/19

Are you aware that births are only available to 1928, marriages to 1937 and deaths to 1972.  Now bearing that in mind what other lookups can we do for you?

We can often track deaths through burial records that are available online on various sites.

Hope this info is of some help.

Cheers for now
Cando




Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Wednesday 27 June 07 10:41 BST (UK)
Hi

Heres a bit more from

http://www.saghs.org.au

Surname: PANNELL, Frank Edward. Personal Notice in Advertiser 1982.

There are a number of Pannell's on the death and burial indexes on this site.  Your step father may recognise some of the names.

Cheers
Cando
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Friday 29 June 07 04:24 BST (UK)
Golly gosh, thanks!  ;D

Arthur had no rights to looking after the children. He would often go to the orphanage trying to catch a glimpse of them but was denied access. After many years of searching he found two sons, George and Brian. Recently another sister was found, Claire, she lives in England with her husband and son. Another daughter died in 1964 of a car accident, I cannot remember the name. Florence, gave birth to a boy called Denis before she died but he was adopted as a baby. The other children grew up in the orphanage, Denis was the only child adopted out. If I remember rightly there was also another sister.

I appreciate your offer Cando. I was wondering if you could access any records relating to the father of George, James and his mother. For example: Births, marriages, deaths or if he immigrated to Australia and when. Also if there is more information on Annie's parents, Frederick etc.

All of you in this forum have really helped to fill in a blank in my stepfather's side of the family. My stepfather is extremely happy with the information. Thanks for all your generous help! :)







Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Friday 29 June 07 05:52 BST (UK)
Hi -

From  http://www.familysearch.org/

PANNELL   James Grier
Birth:  18 Nov 1830
Baptism :  12 Dec 1830  Mint Lane-Wesleyan Methodist, Exeter, Devon, ENG
Parents:  William PANNELL    Ann GRIER


From BISA [Not always 100% accurate]

PANNELL Jas Grier  b: 1831   d: 1.3.1863 Mt Gambier SA
occ:  Joiner   res: Mt Gambier
m: Unknown  ch: Florence Louisa [1861-1864]

MARRIAGE
PANNELL  James Grier  FL  S  [Parents unrecorded]
=
TAYLOR Mary  FL  S  [Parents unrecorded]
at Wesleyan Chapel, Adelaide   Ref Ade 16/234

BIRTHS to James Grier PANNELL  and Mary Louisa TAYLOR

PANNELL Frank  2.1.1856 at North Adelaide Ref Ade 5/269
PANNELL Arthur James  20.9.1857 at North Adelaide  Ref Ade11/148
PANNELL  George  11.10.1859 at North Adelaide Ref Ade 15/214
PANNELL  Florence Louisa  6.11.1861 at North Adelaide  Ref  Ade 20/224

You have details of George's marriage to Annie HAASE

From BISA

HAASE  Frederick b: c1839 Prussia? d:after 1870 Penola SA  arr: 1859 HELENE   occ: Tinsmith, Coppersmith  res: Angaston, Penola
m: Joannah Helene nee SAUER Par: J. Fried and Anna Elis nee STEIN   b.1836 arr: 1858 SOPHIE
ch: Agnes Bertha Ja HEMMINGS [1860-1944]


BIRTHS to Frederick HAASE and Johanne SAUER

HAASE Agnes Bertha Johanna  9.7.1860 at Adelaide  Ref Ade 15/401
HAASE Gustev Theodore 26.3.1862  at Adelaide  Ref Ade 20/329
HAASE Caroline Bertha Anna  9.8.1864 at Mt Gambier  Ref Gre 45/277
HAASE Johanne Charlotte 20.9.1868  at Mt Gambier  Ref Gre 67/486

That should keep you going for a while. ;D

Cheers
Cando





               
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Friday 29 June 07 06:24 BST (UK)
Here is James with parents on the 1841 census

Residing  at St Paul Street, Exeter, Devon

PANNELL  William  50   Carpenter
PANNELL, Ann  50
PANNELL  William 15
PANNELL  Sarah   15
PANNELL  James 10

All born in county.

Ref:  HO107/267/10 Folio 6/Pge 25

Cheers
Cando
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Friday 29 June 07 06:53 BST (UK)
That's great! Yes, this is gonna keep me going!!
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: sparrett on Friday 29 June 07 07:37 BST (UK)
http://worldconnect.rootsweb.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi

Looking here you will see more information from another researcher about James Grier [senior & junior] and further marriage and sibling information.
It is only as reliable as the contributor and his/her sources, but may build on what Cando & others have found.
You may be able to make contact with the submitters.
Sue
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Friday 29 June 07 07:51 BST (UK)
Hey Sparrett,

Thanks for the site. There are a lot of Pannell's in the Mount Gambier region. I guess my stepfather may be related to all of them!
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: Joyce lovell on Tuesday 17 October 17 07:31 BST (UK)
Hello I have just registered to this side looking for information on my mums side and stumbled on this. Your stepfather would be my uncle and born late September 1941; he was the youngest of 6 children. His siblings would have been George my father. Born January 1932. Brian. Joyce. Kathryn or Kathleen and Claire.  His mother is buried at Murray Bridge and I have her lease.
I maybe too late with this information but would like to know more.
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Tuesday 17 October 17 09:18 BST (UK)
Hi Joyce  :)

Welcome to rootschat :)

WoodElf has been logged in since your post so hopefully she will respond.

Cheers
Cando
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: Joyce lovell on Tuesday 17 October 17 09:22 BST (UK)
Thanks. Sorry thought it was about the adopted bother but you may be able to help. The jolly family are having a huge family book written next year and needed some dates the date I needed was when terry married his first wife.
Would be interested to know more about the pannell though.
Cheers
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Tuesday 17 October 17 09:56 BST (UK)
Joyce I am not a family member but a forum member who tries to help others with their research.    We are not permitted to name or post any research about a living or possibly living person.  Is Terry living? 

Cheers
Cando
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: WoodElf on Tuesday 17 October 17 10:21 BST (UK)
Hi Cando,

I've PM'ed Joyce.

Thanks,

Sarah
Title: Re: Pannell dilemma
Post by: cando on Tuesday 17 October 17 11:26 BST (UK)
 :) :)