RootsChat.Com

Scotland (Counties as in 1851-1901) => Scotland => Topic started by: Cramond Brig on Friday 10 June 11 15:42 BST (UK)

Title: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Friday 10 June 11 15:42 BST (UK)
I have just started work on this. I hope to combine the information from the
databases of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission, Soldiers/Officers Died in the Great War, and the Scottish National War Memorial. I know from experience that they all have deficiencies, and I have already found eight men whose deaths are not recorded in any of the above.

I am including any biographical material I can find or have been given.

If anyone has any stories or family information they would care to share with me I would be very pleased to receive them.

At the age of 71, I hope I live long enough to complete this task!!

Regards to all.   
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: IMBER on Saturday 11 June 11 10:34 BST (UK)
Well done for taking this on. I trust you will be advising the CWGC of any they do not appear to have commemorated, although sometimes they are there but under different spellings etc.
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Saturday 11 June 11 12:02 BST (UK)
Well done for taking this on. I trust you will be advising the CWGC of any they do not appear to have commemorated, although sometimes they are there but under different spellings etc.

Done that already.
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: sancti on Saturday 11 June 11 15:00 BST (UK)
Have you seen this site?

http://scottishwargraves.phpbbweb.com/scottishwargraves.html
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Saturday 11 June 11 15:10 BST (UK)
Have you seen this site?

http://scottishwargraves.phpbbweb.com/scottishwargraves.html

Yes, thank you.
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: stuartroxy on Wednesday 25 July 12 17:16 BST (UK)
How's it going, wrt the Roll of Honour?

stuartroxy
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Wednesday 25 July 12 18:24 BST (UK)
How's it going, with the Roll of Honour?

I have finished the Argylls (208 pages) and the Black Watch (279 pages) and just starting the Royal Scots. Any biographical info or stories gratefully received!!

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: MonicaL on Wednesday 25 July 12 18:54 BST (UK)
Hi Alistair

 :o You only started all of this over a year ago! You have done a huge amount so far...

As always, best of luck with it all  :)

Monica
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Wednesday 25 July 12 19:56 BST (UK)
You only started all of this over a year ago! You have done a huge amount so far...

As always, best of luck with it all  :)

Monica

Thank you. This work has certainly opened my eyes to the huge effect the Great War had on Scotland and the people.

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: stuartroxy on Wednesday 25 July 12 20:06 BST (UK)
Alistair,

Pte 19095 William Roxburgh, 16th Bn Royal Scots was killed in action on 1 Jul 1916 on the first day of the Battle on the Somme.

William was one of 12 children of James and Jane (MS Slora) Roxburgh.  He was born at 16 Charlotte Street, Port Dundas, Glasgow - the family had moved to Edinburgh by the time of the Great War.

Pte 19711 Ernest Thomas Becker, 16th Bn Royal Scots was also killed on 1 Jul 1916.  He was born in St Andrews, Edinburgh and was one of 8 children of Ernest Peter Becker, from Prussia, and Kate Aitchison.  His older brother. Charles Stewart Becker also served with the Royal Scots during the Great War.

After the war, Williams sister, Jessie Ina Roxburgh, married Ernest's brother, Frank Becker.

stuartroxy
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Wednesday 25 July 12 23:21 BST (UK)
Stuart

Thank you. That kind of information prevents the casualties from remaining just statistics.

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: teakwood on Sunday 18 November 12 20:19 GMT (UK)
14440 McIntosh, Robert Lindsay, Cpl 13th Bn Royal Scots. KiA 1 August 1917.

Son of James McIntosh and Annie Lindsay. Born on the 12 January 1892 at 7 Henrietta Place, Glasgow, Scotland.

Husband of Ellen McIntosh ms Sartin of 194 Gallowgate, Carlton, Glasgow, Scotland. Married 20 May 1916 at 194 Gallowgate, Calton, Glasgow

Awarded The Military Medal. Date of Gazette 9 July 1917.
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Sunday 18 November 12 23:20 GMT (UK)
14440 McIntosh, Robert Lindsay, Cpl 13th Bn Royal Scots. KiA 1 August 1917.

Son of James McIntosh and Annie Lindsay. Born on the 12 January 1892 at 7 Henrietta Place, Glasgow, Scotland.

Husband of Ellen McIntosh ms Sartin of 194 Gallowgate, Carlton, Glasgow, Scotland. Married 20 May 1916 at 194 Gallowgate, Calton, Glasgow

Awarded The Military Medal. Date of Gazette 9 July 1917.

Thank you.
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: terianne on Monday 19 November 12 13:20 GMT (UK)
Re the Royal Scots just get in touch with the archivist at Edinburgh Castle  Royal Scots Museum (very helpful in the past) if you know the soldiers number it makes it easier, If they can't get the exact info you require they can give you regimental leads.

Also at the Edinburgh Castle the Rolls of Honour for WW1 (Scotland) are on view to the public - I can't remember but I think its by regiments.

The people at the museum were very helpful.  Not sure if the service is still free - so there may be a small charge or donation

I enquired about a g/uncle of mine in the Seaforth Highlander (who died but body wasn't found) and there sent me info on the battle he died in etc. also I go info/leads on ggg/uncle who died in the Crimea (just from the medal info there gave me a regiment lead which resulted in getting a copy of his papers.

so, it is worth trying them


Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Monday 19 November 12 14:16 GMT (UK)
Re the Royal Scots just get in touch with the archivist at Edinburgh Castle  Royal Scots Museum (very helpful in the past) if you know the soldiers number it makes it easier, If they can't get the exact info you require they can give you regimental leads.

Also at the Edinburgh Castle the Rolls of Honour for WW1 (Scotland) are on view to the public - I can't remember but I think its by regiments.

The people at the museum were very helpful.  Not sure if the service is still free - so there may be a small charge or donation

I enquired about a g/uncle of mine in the Seaforth Highlander (who died but body wasn't found) and there sent me info on the battle he died in etc. also I go info/leads on ggg/uncle who died in the Crimea (just from the medal info there gave me a regiment lead which resulted in getting a copy of his papers.

so, it is worth trying them

Unfortunately all the common databases are deficient in one aspect or another (CWGC, SDGW and SNWM) and this is what I an trying to deal with in the Rolls I am researching. I have actually found a significant number of men whose deaths were not included in these databases despite being caused by their war service. And, of course, the databases do not have any real biographical information.

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: cavvytri on Monday 19 November 12 14:42 GMT (UK)
Pte Samuel Cowan SKELDON, 9th Battalion, Royal Scots.
Died aged 29 on Sunday 24/3/1918., born at Kings Stables Road in Edinburgh.
Sam was the brother of Elizabeth Bell KEDDIE (nee Skeldon), and after he was killed his two sons were raised by her in Glasgow.
He has no grave but is remembered on a memorial wall in Pozieres, Somme, France, and in the National War Memorial in Edinburgh Castle
He was my Great Uncle.
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: osprey28 on Sunday 30 December 12 11:22 GMT (UK)
Alistair

Good on you for your efforts on this - I think it means so much more if some personal information is available for the fallen.  Here is one of mine:-

Private 39312 Robert Alexander
"A" Coy. 16th Bn. Royal Scots
Taken prisoner on 12 April 1918
Died of wounds in Lagensalza POW Camp 13 May 1918
Buried in Niederzwhren Cemetery, grave reference X.B.6.
Born 31 Dec 1892 at Bo’ness, West Lothian
Son of Thomas and Mary Alexander.
Also remembered on Bo'ness War Memorial and on his parents’ grave in Bo'ness Cemetery.

Robert married Joan Adamson in Glasgow on 6 Nov 1917 when he was home on leave.  Robert married Joan in secret and his family never knew of the marriage until after the war.  He returned to his unit in France a few days later and never saw her again.  He wrote to his family in April/May 1918 to tell them that he was a POW – but no mention that he had been wounded.  It is unknown if the wounds he died of were sustained at the front or in the POW camp.  He was a stretcher bearer in his unit and the youngest son in his family, in civilian life he worked for his father as a haulage contractor.

Osprey
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Sunday 30 December 12 12:49 GMT (UK)
Good on you for your efforts on this - I think it means so much more if some personal information is available for the fallen.  Here is one of mine:-

Osprey

Thank you for that one. I will ensure that his full details are inserted in the RoH.

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: osprey28 on Sunday 30 December 12 12:52 GMT (UK)
Thanks Alistair - good luck with the project.

Regards

Osprey
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: jds1949 on Sunday 30 December 12 19:08 GMT (UK)
Here's one from my Swarbrick database:

Thomas Swarbrick was born in Newbridge Midlothian in 1893 and at some point lived in Linlithgow. In January 1914 he joined the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders. He was killed in action on 21st January 1917. He was the second of five children born to Thomas Henry and Jane [Ritchie] Swarbrick. In 1901 he was living with his parents at Kirknewton and East Calder, Midlothian, where his father was working as a plasterer’s labourer.

Thomas is also remembered on the Linlithgow War Memorial as:
Swarbrick Thomas Pte 1914-1918

“Soldiers Who Died in the Great War” gives the additional information that Thomas Swarbrick was born in Newbridge, Midlothian, lived at Linlithgow and enlisted at Stirling and that he was killed in action.

In 1914 the 2nd Battalion of the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders was stationed at Fort George. Fort George was and is a massive military base, some 11 miles from Inverness and situated on the Moray Firth.  On 14th August 1914 the Battalion landed at Boulogne; Thomas has a date of entry of 11th September, so he may well have been in a subsequent draft.

jds1949
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Sunday 30 December 12 23:45 GMT (UK)
Here's one from my Swarbrick database:

jds1949

Thank you

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: osprey28 on Wednesday 09 July 14 22:44 BST (UK)
Hello Alistair

Any news on how you are getting on with the ROH - been a while since you posted anything.

Regards

Osprey
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Thursday 10 July 14 17:19 BST (UK)
Hello Alistair

Any news on how you are getting on with the ROH - been a while since you posted anything.

Regards

Osprey

At the moment, it's a bit like juggling. Let me explain.

Since 2008, the University of Edinburgh's Centre for the Study of Modern Conflict has been working with Edinburgh, Leith and the Lothians' libraries, schools and community groups to ensure that the story of Scotland's contribution to the Great War is not forgotten. Furthermore, the partnership was strengthened when The Scottish Military Research Group became a partner in 2010, History Fest in 2011, and the National Library of Scotland in 2013. Scotland's War was launched on 28 June 2013. On 7 July 2013, the Commonwealth War Graves Commission (CWGC) joined as a partner. A number of other organisations have made initial contact indicating a wish to work with us and The Scotsman has recently become a partner. From our joint efforts over the past few years, it has become all too obvious that the history of this nation at war remains largely untold, particularly the civilian efforts on the Home Front.

From the earliest days of the project, public engagement has been central to its success. We now have a very active programme working with libraries, carrying out WW1 archival and document searches, and the public and institutions have submitted family or institutional papers for inclusion in the WW1 public engagement initiative. Many of them can now be found on the new website (www.edinburghs-war.ed.ac.uk). We have strict guidelines and an ethical policy on the submission and use of documents, photographs, artefacts and memorabilia.

In October 2012, in collaboration with our partners, Edinburgh City Libraries, we launched The WW1 History Hub which is supporting people to tell family stories about their contribution to the Great War. The WW1 History Hub initiative is a first in the UK and is a product of years of work between Edinburgh City Libraries and the University of Edinburgh.

We have a unique opportunity to allow the present generation of Scots to trace the footsteps of their ancestors in order to tell the whole story of Scotland's people, their service, and their sacrifice in the Great War and to reflect on the consequences of a conflict that arguably changed our nation forever.

At the moment Edinburgh's War can be found at www.edinburghs-war.ed.ac.uk. Scotland's war will evolve using the same template.

I am the Project Manager, and, as you can imagine, there is no shortage of things to do, and, of course, we welcome contributors from all over the world.

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: osprey28 on Thursday 10 July 14 17:31 BST (UK)
Alistair

Thanks for the very comprehensive reply.  What a superb project you are leading - the information you are gathering will be a truly valuable resource to genealogists for generations to come.  Also a worthy tribute to everyone involved in WW1.

I looked over the Edinburgh's War site - excellent stuff.

Osprey
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Forfarian on Thursday 17 July 14 13:04 BST (UK)
Charles Ogilvy Anderson, Lieutenant Royal Scots 3rd Bn attd 2nd Bn,  was born in Bombay in 1896 and killed at Loos on 2 October 1915, aged 19. He was the elder son of Charles Anderson (1854-1939), engineer, Mechanical Superintendent in the Bombay Port Trust, and his wife Helena Caroline Ingle (1866-1942). The Anderson family lived in Brechin, Angus but their roots were in Elgin, Moray.

Private John Barclay, 12 Bn, Royal Scots, was born at 10 Back Street, Dufftown, parish of Mortlach, Banffshire on 17 April 1895, and was killed at Arras on 6 June 1917. He was the second son and fourth child of John Barclay (1860-1935), farmer and dairyman, and his wife Margaret Burgess (1859-1928)

Corporal Stephen Carrie, 9th Bn, Royal Scots, was born at 55 West Grimsby, Arbroath, on 30 September 1892 and killed in action on 8 September 1917. He was the 6th son and 8th child of James Carrie (1852/3-1926), iron moulder, tanner, stoker, and flaxmill fireman, and his wife Mary Ann Robertson (1853/4-1940), and he married Clara Low in Arbroath on 25 February 1914. He was working as a barman at that time.

Captain Charles John Alexander Cowan, 3rd Bn Royal Scots, was born at 30 Moray Place, Edinburgh on 8 December 1893 and killed in action in France on 25 March 1918 aged 25. He was the eldest of three sons of Alexander Cowan (1863-1943), paper manufacturer and proprietor of Valleyfield Paper Mill, Penicuik, and his wife Alice Buchanan Comrie Thomson (1867-1912).

George Gordon Findlater, 15th Bn Royal Scots, was born on 9 February 1888 at Butchart's Croft, Montrose, and killed in action on 28 April 1917 aged 29. He was the 7th son and 10th of 11 children of John Findlater (1837/8-1931), farmer and labourer, and his wife Helen Rettie (1846-1923).

Captain Edward John Farquharson Johnston, 1st Bn Royal Scots, was born on 17 May 1882 in Seville, Spain, where his father was British Vice-Consul, and was killed in Belgium on 12 April 1915, aged 32. He was the elder son of Edward Farquharson Johnston (1854-1924) and his wife Mary Crombie (1855-1927), and he married Viola Mignon Hope Bayley in London in 1907. The Johnston family were the proprietors of Johnston's Woollen Mills at Newmill, Elgin, and the Crombie family were the proprietors of Cothal Mills in the parish of Fintray, Aberdeenshire and later Grandholm Mills, Aberdeen, manufacturers of the famous Crombie cloth. (Mary Crombie's uncle James Crombie was the great-great-great-grandfather of the late Diana, Princess of Wales.) Viola Bayley was the daughter of Edward Eric William Bayley, Captain, Royal Engineers, and his wife Mary Maud (surname unknown).

Is this sort of thing what you are looking for?
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Thursday 17 July 14 13:38 BST (UK)
Charles Ogilvy Anderson, Lieutenant Royal Scots 3rd Bn attd 2nd Bn,  was born in Bombay in 1896 and killed at Loos on 2 October 1915, aged 19. He was the elder son of Charles Anderson (1854-1939), engineer, Mechanical Superintendent in the Bombay Port Trust, and his wife Helena Caroline Ingle (1866-1942). The Anderson family lived in Brechin, Angus but their roots were in Elgin, Moray.

Private John Barclay, 12 Bn, Royal Scots, was born at 10 Back Street, Dufftown, parish of Mortlach, Banffshire on 17 April 1895, and was killed at Arras on 6 June 1917. He was the second son and fourth child of John Barclay (1860-1935), farmer and dairyman, and his wife Margaret Burgess (1859-1928)

Corporal Stephen Carrie, 9th Bn, Royal Scots, was born at 55 West Grimsby, Arbroath, on 30 September 1892 and killed in action on 8 September 1917. He was the 6th son and 8th child of James Carrie (1852/3-1926), iron moulder, tanner, stoker, and flaxmill fireman, and his wife Mary Ann Robertson (1853/4-1940), and he married Clara Low in Arbroath on 25 February 1914. He was working as a barman at that time.

Captain Charles John Alexander Cowan, 3rd Bn Royal Scots, was born at 30 Moray Place, Edinburgh on 8 December 1893 and killed in action in France on 25 March 1918 aged 25. He was the eldest of three sons of Alexander Cowan (1863-1943), paper manufacturer and proprietor of Valleyfield Paper Mill, Penicuik, and his wife Alice Buchanan Comrie Thomson (1867-1912).

George Gordon Findlater, 15th Bn Royal Scots, was born on 9 February 1888 at Butchart's Croft, Montrose, and killed in action on 28 April 1917 aged 29. He was the 7th son and 10th of 11 children of John Findlater (1837/8-1931), farmer and labourer, and his wife Helen Rettie (1846-1923).

Captain Edward John Farquharson Johnston, 1st Bn Royal Scots, was born on 17 May 1882 in Seville, Spain, where his father was British Vice-Consul, and was killed in Belgium on 12 April 1915, aged 32. He was the elder son of Edward Farquharson Johnston (1854-1924) and his wife Mary Crombie (1855-1927), and he married Viola Mignon Hope Bayley in London in 1907. The Johnston family were the proprietors of Johnston's Woollen Mills at Newmill, Elgin, and the Crombie family were the proprietors of Cothal Mills in the parish of Fintray, Aberdeenshire and later Grandholm Mills, Aberdeen, manufacturers of the famous Crombie cloth. (Mary Crombie's uncle James Crombie was the great-great-great-grandfather of the late Diana, Princess of Wales.) Viola Bayley was the daughter of Edward Eric William Bayley, Captain, Royal Engineers, and his wife Mary Maud (surname unknown).

Is this sort of thing what you are looking for?

Thank you very much. Are these off a War Memorial or from newspaper obituaries?

There is quite convincing evidence that Edward Farquharson Johnston was the founder of Seville FC, the well known Spanish football club, although they are not too keen on accepting that the club was founded by a Scot!
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Forfarian on Thursday 17 July 14 13:58 BST (UK)
Quote
Are these off a War Memorial or from newspaper obituaries?

No. They are compendia of information from a variety of sources collated by me in the course of researching my family. All of them are related to me. Sources include the CWGC web site, Scotland's People and newspapers, though I don't think I have actually seen a newspaper obituary of any of them, and none of the information is taken from a war memorial.

Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Thursday 17 July 14 15:37 BST (UK)
Quote
Are these off a War Memorial or from newspaper obituaries?

No. They are compendia of information from a variety of sources collated by me in the course of researching my family. All of them are related to me. Sources include the CWGC web site, Scotland's People and newspapers, though I don't think I have actually seen a newspaper obituary of any of them, and none of the information is taken from a war memorial.

Maybe asking too much, but it would be great if you could weave them into a story of relationships at the time and what you know about their earlier lives and how they fell. It would be excellent to put online as a family story, if you agreed.

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Forfarian on Thursday 17 July 14 15:55 BST (UK)
I don't really have any more detail of the six individuals listed, though I could provide large trees of their relatives. I don't for instance (yet) know where any of them went to school or how they died, other than the general descriptions of various battles on the CWGC web site.

Although they are all related to me, not one of them is related to any of the others.
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Thursday 17 July 14 16:01 BST (UK)
I don't really have any more detail of the six individuals listed, though I could provide large trees of their relatives. I don't for instance (yet) know where any of them went to school or how they died, other than the general descriptions of various battles on the CWGC web site.

Although they are all related to me, not one of them is related to any of the others.

OK. If you are interested I can send you the file I have about Seville FC (in Spanish!!).
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Forfarian on Thursday 17 July 14 16:42 BST (UK)
That's fine, thank you. I can read Spanish adequately.
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Thursday 17 July 14 17:06 BST (UK)
That's fine, thank you. I can read Spanish adequately.

PM me your email address and I will send the file.
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: MonicaL on Thursday 17 July 14 19:24 BST (UK)
Alistair. you know how much we endorse your work and project.

Forfarian, I never cease to be amazed about your connections and wealth of knowledge.

I am bilingual with Spanish. If I can help, let me me know  :)

Monica
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Thursday 17 July 14 22:59 BST (UK)
Alistair. you know how much we endorse your work and project.

Forfarian, I never cease to be amazed about your connections and wealth of knowledge.

I am bilingual with Spanish. If I can help, let me me know  :)

Monica

Hi Monica,

I Had forgotten. I think you mentioned once that your mother was Spanish. If you care to PM your email address, I will send the file to you. I have never been able to get a good translation.

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Forfarian on Friday 18 July 14 10:18 BST (UK)
Thank you for the file, Alistair. I am working my way through it, and it makes interesting reading. I like the idea of  Los agentes de difusión británicos !

Monica, you are too kind.

Incidentally, the obituary quoted in translation, originally published in the Elgin Courant and Courier, is in error when it says that Mary Crombie (1855-1927) was the daughter of James Crombie of Grandholm Mills. She was in fact the daughter of his brother John Crombie (1819-1894) of Grandholm Mills. 

My connection to the Crombie family is through Mary Crombie's mother Jane Sang (1825-1900). I am not related to James Crombie, or to his famous great-great-great-granddaughter.

Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Friday 18 July 14 12:19 BST (UK)
Thank you for the file, Alistair. I am working my way through it, and it makes interesting reading. I like the idea of  Los agentes de difusión británicos !

Monica, you are too kind.

Incidentally, the obituary quoted in translation, originally published in the Elgin Courant and Courier, is in error when it says that Mary Crombie (1855-1927) was the daughter of James Crombie of Grandholm Mills. She was in fact the daughter of his brother John Crombie (1819-1894) of Grandholm Mills. 

My connection to the Crombie family is through Mary Crombie's mother Jane Sang (1825-1900). I am not related to James Crombie, or to his famous great-great-great-granddaughter.

Glad you are enjoying it. I hope you will be able to let me have a translation in due course, if that is not asking too much.

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Forfarian on Friday 18 July 14 13:24 BST (UK)
I hope you will be able to let me have a translation in due course, if that is not asking too much.

It was Monica who offered a translation, I think.

Here, however, is my transcription of the original obituary

We regret to announce the death of Mr Edward Farquharson Johnston, younger son of the late Major James Johnston of Newmill, and brother of Colonel Charles J Johnston, DL, VD, The Camp, Lossiemouth. Mr Johnston had a serious illness two years ago, but he seemed to make a good recovery, and he was looking forward to spending part of this summer at The Camp, Lossiemouth, to which, as once his father's residence, he was very much attached, and which he had been prevented from visiting last year. A week ago, however, somewhat disappointing symptoms were observed, but at first nothing serious was anticipated. He gradually became weaker, and passed away early on Saturday morning at his residence, 11 The Boltons, London SW. The news of Mr Johnston's death was received with deep regret by all his old friends in Morayshire, to whom it came somewhat as a shock, as few if any were aware that he was ill. Mr Johnston was born at Newmill in October 1854. He was educated first at Weston House - once a noted seminary in Elgin - and afterwards at Mill Hill, the famous English Public School near London of which Sir John McClure was formerly headmaster. On completion of his education, Mr Johnston entered the business house of Messrs Robert McAndrew and Co, London, who were connected with his mother's family, and who have extensive business connections with Spain and Asia Minor. After some years in the London office, Mr Johnston went out to Seville as the manager of the firm's Spanish business. For about 30 years he remained there engaged in the oversight of an extensive commercial undertaking, which he managed with conspicuous success, and whose already large operations he was the means of materially increasing. About five or six years ago, Mr Johnston was able to retire from the active work of business and took up residence in London. Whenever he found the opportunity, he was wont to come north to his native country; and nothing delighted him more than to spend a few weeks at Lossiemouth, with all its happy associations with the holidays of boyhood and youth. Mr Johnston married a daughter of the late Mr James (sic) Crombie, woollen manufacturer, Grandholm Works, near Aberdeen. Mrs Johnston is a sister of the late Mr John W Crombie, MP for Kincardineshire, and of Dr James E Crombie, Parkhill, who is a prominent figure in the public life of Aberdeenshire, as well as in the University Court at Aberdeen, where he sits as Lord Rector's Assessor. Of the marriage there were two sons - Mr Edward Johnston, who, on the outbreak of hostilities in 1914, obtained a commission as a Captain in the Royal Scots, and who was killed in the trenches in France early in the war, leaving a widow, who resides in London. The other son is Mr James Johnston, who joined his father in business, and who is at present in such poor health that he was not able to attend the funeral in Elgin yesterday. The body of Mr Johnston was cremated at Golder's Green on Wednesday afternoon and the ashes placed in an urn enclosed in an oak coffin, were taken north by the night train from King's Cross, Elgin being reached, via Aberdeen, at 10.35 yesterday morning. Morayshire relatives and friends assembled at the LNE station and joined the funeral procession to Elgin Cemetery, where the burial service was said by Rev Canon L M Hay-Dinwoody MA, rector of Holy Trinity Church. The pall-bearers were Colonel C J Johnston, The Craig, Lossiemouth (brother); Mr J H Hair, Skerrycliff, Lossiemouth (brother-in-law); Mr J E Crombie LL D, Parkill (brother-in-law); Mrs Edward Johnston (daughter-in-law); Colonel W J Johnston, Lesmurdie (nephew); Mr W H Rose (nephew); Mr G A MacLean, Westfield; Mr Cosmo Gordon, of Buchromb. The general company of mourners, which was unusually large, included Mr J F Cumming, Convener of the County; Mr R B Gordon, Procurator-Fiscal; Mr E D Jameson, County Clerk; Captain J Brander Dunbar of Pitgaveny; Dr T H W Alexander, Woodpark, Lhanbryd; Mr Allan S Gregory, Maryhill; Mr J Denoon, Lossiemouth; and others. [Elgin Courant and Courier, 20 June 1924, page 5, column 3]


I've been looking at the MacAndrew and Co connection. It is not on EFJ's mother's side, as stated in the obituary. His mother was Margaret Miller Farquharson. It was his paternal grandmother who was a M(a)cAndrew. She was Mary M(a)cAndrew, daughter of James M(a)cAndrew and Mary, who I think was possibly née Maria Shirley. Mary M(a)cAndrew's sister Eliza M(a)cAndrew married in 1829 Robert M(a)cAndrew, born in Wandsworth, Surrey in 1802, son of William M(a)cAndrew and Antonia, surname unknown. It was this Robert M(a)cAndrew who seems to have founded the company that sent EFJ to Seville.

Sorry, this is off-topic!
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Friday 18 July 14 13:52 BST (UK)
Thank you.

Alistair
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: ALGARIVO on Monday 18 August 14 12:14 BST (UK)
Greetings.

This is my first post and my English is poor, so I use the translator with all its mistakes and successes. Apologies.

The figure of Mr. Edward Farquharson Johnston is especially important to us, the Sevilla Football Club (Seville, Spain), because our Team founded on January 25, 1890 From Mr. Johnston, born in Newmill, Elgin-Moray), we have extensive dossier. I leave a sample of one of our jobs. I reiterate my apologies for my poor English.

Take care.

http://algarivo.blogspot.com.es/2011/04/san-jorge-los-libros-y-el-cementerio.html
Title: Re: Royal Scots WW1 Roll of Honour
Post by: Cramond Brig on Monday 18 August 14 13:41 BST (UK)
Greetings.

This is my first post and my English is poor, so I use the translator with all its mistakes and successes. Apologies.

The figure of Mr. Edward Farquharson Johnston is especially important to us, the Sevilla Football Club (Seville, Spain), because our Team founded on January 25, 1890 From Mr. Johnston, born in Newmill, Elgin-Moray), we have extensive dossier. I leave a sample of one of our jobs. I reiterate my apologies for my poor English.

Take care.

http://algarivo.blogspot.com.es/2011/04/san-jorge-los-libros-y-el-cementerio.html

Hola

gracias por este mensaje. Yo era consciente de la parte que el señor Johnston había desempeñado en la formación de Sevilla FC y trató de establecer contacto con el club de la historia. No he recibido respuesta.

YO estaría muy interesada en tener el expediente completo con el fin de conseguir que se traduzca.

Mejores deseos