RootsChat.Com

Ireland (Historical Counties) => Ireland => Donegal => Topic started by: annypanny on Tuesday 11 November 14 14:01 GMT (UK)

Title: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: annypanny on Tuesday 11 November 14 14:01 GMT (UK)
Just logged onto RootsIreland and found a marriage that I would like to purchase only to find out that I have to pay a minimal £20!!!!!  I only use that site once or twice a month and it's just not economical to pay this for one or two records....

Anyone else cheesed off?

Annie
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: gaffy on Tuesday 11 November 14 17:28 GMT (UK)
There's a thread on the new subscription system:

http://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=700259.0

If you access many records, it's a bargain, if you only access a couple, it's exorbitant.

Even though I'm someone who routinely fits into the former category, I feel it wrong that you and others will either be put off by the cost or pay the dosh and effectively subsidise me, it's simply not fair.
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: hallmark on Tuesday 11 November 14 19:44 GMT (UK)
http://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=670189.0 is worth reading about who put them together etc, you can then make your own mind up on how reliable the records are!!
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: annypanny on Tuesday 11 November 14 19:56 GMT (UK)
I think with all sites using transcriptions there is alway room for error.  The process is very boring for someone with no interest in genealogy and mistakes will be made, you just need to look at the market leader's transcription of the Scottish census, it's ridiculous......I did pay the £20 but suspect some of the records are wrong but apart from going to Dublin  for the originals or the local church it's the only option but you'll never know if your research is sound.  I don't like the fact that they never cite their sources either!!!
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: hallmark on Tuesday 11 November 14 20:28 GMT (UK)
there are a lot of records on familysearch BUT you have to keep your searches "loose".. for example, someone couldn't find their kin in Monaghan, insisted they weren't there, but they were, under Carrickmacross, Ireland which is in Monaghan!!

So, searching for someone in Donegal it's better just to put in Ireland, Name(s) and Date range, then look at results.
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: Elwyn Soutter on Tuesday 11 November 14 21:53 GMT (UK)
Just logged onto RootsIreland and found a marriage that I would like to purchase only to find out that I have to pay a minimal £20!!!!!  I only use that site once or twice a month and it's just not economical to pay this for one or two records....



If you have the details of the marriage, then you would probably be better off simply buying a photocopy of the full cert from GRO Roscommon for €4.
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: annypanny on Tuesday 11 November 14 22:21 GMT (UK)
It's from 1874 and they said they didn't have it as it wasn't in their date range..
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: aghadowey on Tuesday 11 November 14 22:23 GMT (UK)
All marriages from 1864 onwards should be registered.
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: annypanny on Wednesday 12 November 14 13:25 GMT (UK)
Hi, yes they're registered but just not on their computer system, I thnk I will have to write to them.....
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: hallmark on Wednesday 12 November 14 13:32 GMT (UK)
well since you won't say who you're looking for there's not much one can do to help!
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: annypanny on Wednesday 12 November 14 13:59 GMT (UK)
???? Just wanted a moan, paid the subs and found the info thanks...
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: Sonas on Wednesday 12 November 14 19:26 GMT (UK)
I know this query is sorted but I wondered if anyone knows if it's possible to contact the genealogy centres and buy a single or a few records from them, and how much they would charge?
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: annypanny on Wednesday 12 November 14 20:47 GMT (UK)
You can apply via GRO Ireland, they charge 4 or 5 Euros for a research copy.
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: Sonas on Wednesday 12 November 14 21:10 GMT (UK)
You can apply via GRO Ireland, they charge 4 or 5 Euros for a research copy.

Yes, but it's genealogy centre practices I was asking about ie if you only want one record and paying the sub isn't economic, as in your case, will the genealogy centre sell a single record.
Title: Re: RootsIreland - very disappointed!
Post by: Elwyn Soutter on Thursday 13 November 14 00:24 GMT (UK)
You can apply via GRO Ireland, they charge 4 or 5 Euros for a research copy.

Yes, but it's genealogy centre practices I was asking about ie if you only want one record and paying the sub isn't economic, as in your case, will the genealogy centre sell a single record.

No I don’t think they will. They used to, but they now have a different charging regime. As has been said earlier, if you want a single statutory record, you are better off getting a photocopy from GRO Roscommon for €4 or, in the case of records in Northern Ireland, from GRONI where you can view them for £2 each. That’s probably cheaper than the genealogy centres old fees anyway.