RootsChat.Com

Old Photographs, Recognition, Handwriting Deciphering => Handwriting Deciphering & Recognition => Topic started by: brianz on Tuesday 26 January 16 20:33 GMT (UK)

Title: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: brianz on Tuesday 26 January 16 20:33 GMT (UK)
The attached photo has recently come into my possession and I wondered if anyone could shed any light on who they are and what is happening. I know very little about the photo except,

The man on the left is Bernard Lee Collins who died aged 67 in Dec 1956 and worked at Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield as a Metallurgist.

I wondered if it could be some sort of retirement do in 1954, the clothes look about right other than that I am stuck.

Does anyone recognise any of the other two men or have any suggestions at all please

Thanks
Title: Re: A real puzzle
Post by: groom on Tuesday 26 January 16 20:46 GMT (UK)
 I would think that the chair has some significance, not really the sort of thing you would give someone as a retirement present though. I wonder of that plaque/ notice on the wall gives any clues as to where it was, can you scan that any clearer?
Title: Re: A real puzzle
Post by: josey on Tuesday 26 January 16 20:50 GMT (UK)
Timing wise [age 65] it does seem like a retirement - perhaps Bernard was handing over whatever role used the chair to a younger man? Seems to be trying it for comfort & size  ??? Or perhaps Bernard had been appointed to a particular role now that HE was retired? And was being shown the chair of office...

Yes, groom, the writing might help.
Title: Re: A real puzzle
Post by: brianz on Tuesday 26 January 16 20:55 GMT (UK)
Thanks for the suggestion. It is an old photo, I have scanned it in at 600dpi already, any more and it just goes blurred, sorry.
Title: Re: A real puzzle
Post by: DavidG02 on Tuesday 26 January 16 20:57 GMT (UK)
Not sure if the man on the right is the '' younger man'' ???  I would suggest they are all in their 60s.

On the chair as a retirement gift.. I have seen it , but more the recliner type.

The National Archives has some info http://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/rd/441f7cea-1503-4ad0-a7b3-dc70398a564f

Couple of old fellas you may want to chase up from this forum for more info

http://www.sheffieldforum.co.uk/archive/index.php/t-459517.html
Title: Re: A real puzzle
Post by: mazi on Tuesday 26 January 16 21:02 GMT (UK)
They held a centenary banquet in 1951, maybe rehearsing for the speeches.

Not suggesting the table behind was the entire banquet  ;D ;D
Title: Re: A real puzzle
Post by: Geoff-E on Tuesday 26 January 16 21:09 GMT (UK)
I think the chair is a retirement gift.  It appears to be brand new and it looks to be a staged photo with great attention being paid to the chair.

BLC was a metallurgist in 1911, perhaps at the same works.
Title: Re: A real puzzle
Post by: Treetotal on Tuesday 26 January 16 22:43 GMT (UK)
I agree with Geoff.
Carol
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: brianz on Wednesday 27 January 16 15:21 GMT (UK)
While I was trying to improve the sign behind BLC's right shoulder I found that the top rail carried the Corporate logo of Samuel Osborn Steels. It is looking more like a presentation of some sort.

Thanks for all the suggestions
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: Treetotal on Wednesday 27 January 16 15:28 GMT (UK)
I think there might be something else being presented too, on the table behind one of the men but you would need to ask the guy on the right to move over  ;D
Have you thought of looking at newspapers for the year 1854?
Carol
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: bugbear on Friday 29 January 16 18:17 GMT (UK)
The chair doesn't look made for comfort, but is clearly considered very important, given the body language.

I wonder if it's not so much "a chair", as "a seat" (as in "a seat on the board").

Has he been elected to some club, committee or board?

 BugBear
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: brianz on Friday 29 January 16 20:02 GMT (UK)
It could have been a seat on the board, but I have never heard it mentioned in the family, it is worth asking some of them though.

Thanks for the suggestion
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: DavidG02 on Friday 29 January 16 23:54 GMT (UK)
It looks to be a Dining Room chair.

My Grandmother had chairs similar to these in her dining room which were used once a week ( Sunday Dinners ) or for important days - Birthdays etc. They were uncomfortable but only just. I think they were made that way to impart formality. ( or maybe we have gotten too lazy and slouch too much)
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: bugbear on Saturday 30 January 16 09:14 GMT (UK)
It looks to be a Dining Room chair.

My Grandmother had chairs similar to these in her dining room which were used once a week ( Sunday Dinners ) or for important days - Birthdays etc. They were uncomfortable but only just. I think they were made that way to impart formality. ( or maybe we have gotten too lazy and slouch too much)

I'm not sure it's a (single) dining room chair - surely they come in sets of at least four?

 BugBar
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: DavidG02 on Saturday 30 January 16 09:34 GMT (UK)

I'm not sure it's a (single) dining room chair - surely they come in sets of at least four?

 BugBar
Agreed. But , and once again relying on memory. My grandfathers chair was similar and was bigger than the others . Though they were of a similar style , just smaller.

This is what I recall.. note the arms on the ''head '' chair.

(http://api.ning.com/files/6R82p*QE8nKY6Wd-hcLJ9G-5BWSpbTmJHeyrqEfKZdqoHXbjv0ilkJ-3FAyQ7sI-kNQEPfGmrCym8avCs0TuBdjAeHtqfNjJ/DiningSet028_small.jpg)
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: groom on Saturday 30 January 16 09:39 GMT (UK)
Could it be the other way round - ie not Bernard Lee Collins  receiving the chair, but him presenting it? Rather a strange thing to give someone on retirement, one large chair.
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: J.J. on Thursday 04 February 16 20:25 GMT (UK)
It looks to be symbolizing the passing on of company chairmanship, ( I'd thought the fellow on the right to the one on the left. )  However I suppose it could also symbolize the passing of a job to another person...even though both are older men...The job likely one that  not many may be qualified to simply jump into the role.
Title: Re: A real puzzle Samuel Osborn Steels in Sheffield
Post by: venelow on Friday 05 February 16 17:12 GMT (UK)
Have you contacted the place that holds their archives?

Or is that where you obtained the photo?

Title: Records of Samuel Osborn and Company Ltd, Rutland Works, Holbrook Steel Works, Clyde Steel Works, Sheffield, files and steel manufacturer.
Reference:    MNSO
Date:    1900-1960
Held by:    Sheffield Industrial Museums Trust
Language: English
Extent:    131 items
Subjects:    Metal industry
Creator Names:    Samuel Osborn and Company Ltd of Sheffield

Venelow