RootsChat.Com

Research in Other Countries => South Africa => Topic started by: terrorbull on Thursday 25 May 17 10:57 BST (UK)

Title: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: terrorbull on Thursday 25 May 17 10:57 BST (UK)
I just cannot find a birth ir baptism record for my GGrandmother. Her and her older brother are not to be found but the other siblings are recorded. Would there be a reason why the 2 older children were not recorded?
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: goldie61 on Thursday 25 May 17 10:58 BST (UK)
If you give a little more information, like names, dates and places, we can try and work it out.  :)
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: PaulineJ on Thursday 25 May 17 10:59 BST (UK)
Pre-civil registration?
Recorded under another surname?
Not registered where you expect registrations to be?

Detail the marriage, events that are found, and census/other details for those that are errant
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: Cas (stallc) on Thursday 25 May 17 11:02 BST (UK)
Hi, Welcome to Rootschat

Name and year of birth and area would help...

Have you checked the GRO index, what is the mothers maiden name? If other siblings found, should be post reg. Register free to search https://www.gro.gov.uk/gro/content/certificates/indexes_search.asp

Sorry to ask so many Q but without info...a non starter  ???

Civil reg only became compulsory from around 1874, after that there was a fine/penalty

Cas
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: Milliepede on Thursday 25 May 17 11:17 BST (UK)
Born before the marriage or to a different father ie half siblings/under mothers surname?

Pop the names/places down as you see there are many willing helpers here  :)
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: aghadowey on Thursday 25 May 17 11:22 BST (UK)
I just cannot find a birth ir baptism record for my GGrandmother. Her and her older brother are not to be found but the other siblings are recorded. Would there be a reason why the 2 older children were not recorded?

You haven't mentioned dates or even a country  :-\ Is it South Africa by any chance?
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: Bookbox on Thursday 25 May 17 11:33 BST (UK)
Civil reg only became compulsory from around 1874, after that there was a fine/penalty

Civil registration was compulsory from 1 July 1837. Until 1875, the responsibility for registration lay with the registrar, so some births were missed.
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: terrorbull on Thursday 25 May 17 11:46 BST (UK)
Name: Elizabeth Magdalena Ann Gilowey born Luyt.
Born: 15/7/1872. Cape Town?
Died: 12/6/1952. Cape Town
Parents: Daniel Coenraad Adriaan Luyt & Ann Luyt (Caffery)
Maried: Frederick Lodewyk Charles Gilowey

Cannot find his birth or baptism either

He was born: 1869
Died: 1949
Parents: Fredrik Johan Giloway & Beatrix Jacoba Maria Giloway (Villet)
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: Cas (stallc) on Thursday 25 May 17 11:48 BST (UK)
Civil reg only became compulsory from around 1874, after that there was a fine/penalty

Civil registration was compulsory from 1 July 1837. Until 1875, the responsibility for registration lay with the registrar, so some births were missed.

With all respect, I do know the date of when civil reg began, was trying to point out when the law enforced or a penalty or fine was issued for non registration. Do not want a debate on legalities, or nit picking.

Cas
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: lizdb on Thursday 25 May 17 11:51 BST (UK)
It may not even be relevant, depending on what country terrorbull's ancestors came from! 
1837/1875 applies to England and Wales.

So many people "on hold" here waiting to help you, terrorbull! 
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: Cas (stallc) on Thursday 25 May 17 11:53 BST (UK)
It may not even be relevant, depending on what country terrorbull's ancestors came from! 
1837/1875 applies to England and Wales.

So many people "on hold" here waiting to help you, terrorbull! 

How very true!
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: terrorbull on Thursday 25 May 17 12:04 BST (UK)
Name: Elizabeth Magdalena Ann Gilowey born Luyt.
Born: 15/7/1872. Cape Town?
Died: 12/6/1952. Cape Town
Parents: Daniel Coenraad Adriaan Luyt & Ann Luyt (Caffery)
Born in Western Cape, Sth Africa


Siblings
/edmund-michiel-bernardus-vos-luyt, /johan-hendrik-vos-luyt, /hendrik-vos-luyt, /frederick-michiel-vos-luyt, /gabriel-vos-luyt, /hendrik-vos-luyt,/petrus-vos-luyt, /jacobus-johannes-vos-luyt,/elizabeth-jacoba-vos-

Married: Frederick Lodewyk Charles Gilowey
Cannot find his birth or baptism either

He was born: 1869 Sth Africa
Died: 1949
Parents: Fredrik Johan Giloway & Beatrix Jacoba Maria Giloway (Villet)
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: terrorbull on Thursday 25 May 17 12:05 BST (UK)
Name: Elizabeth Magdalena Ann Gilowey born Luyt.
Born: 15/7/1872. Cape Town?
Died: 12/6/1952. Cape Town
Parents: Daniel Coenraad Adriaan Luyt & Ann Luyt (Caffery)
Born in Western Cape, Sth Africa

Siblings
/edmund-michiel-bernardus-vos-luyt, /johan-hendrik-vos-luyt, /hendrik-vos-luyt, /frederick-michiel-vos-luyt, /gabriel-vos-luyt, /hendrik-vos-luyt,/petrus-vos-luyt, /jacobus-johannes-vos-luyt,/elizabeth-jacoba-vos-

Married: Frederick Lodewyk Charles Gilowey
Cannot find his birth or baptism either

He was born: 1869
Died: 1949
Parents: Fredrik Johan Giloway & Beatrix Jacoba Maria Giloway (Villet)
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: terrorbull on Thursday 25 May 17 12:08 BST (UK)
It may not even be relevant, depending on what country terrorbull's ancestors came from! 
1837/1875 applies to England and Wales.

So many people "on hold" here waiting to help you, terrorbull! 

How very true!


Thanks so much all born in Sth Africa and ancestors from Germany, Deutchland
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: aghadowey on Thursday 25 May 17 12:22 BST (UK)
Since you posted in The Common Room (a general board) and didn't give any clue as to location you've gotten some replies which have nothing to do with South African records. However, if you click on 'report to moderator' and ask for this topic to be moved to the South Africa board it's possible someone there will be able to help further.
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: PaulineJ on Thursday 25 May 17 12:46 BST (UK)
So this is one of the kids

https://familysearch.org/search/record/results?count=20&query=%2Bsurname%3Aluyt~%20%2Bfather_givenname%3Adaniel~


forget that, too early

Edmond Michael Bernadus Vos Luyt / Baptism  / 04 Apr 1869

https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:KFN9-3ZT
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: stanmapstone on Thursday 25 May 17 13:44 BST (UK)
Deleted
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: Lisa Jo on Saturday 27 May 17 01:30 BST (UK)
My great grandfather was born in Johannesburg in 1897. He later signed a British civil service proof of age stating that his birth was not recorded due to there not being a registrar there at the time.  If I'm not mistaken the first registrar in Johannesburg started up in 1903.  I didn't read through all the comments but I thought I would share my similar research situation anyways incase it helps. Good luck :)
Title: Re: Why birth not ecorded
Post by: 3sillydogs on Saturday 27 May 17 13:40 BST (UK)
On the archives site, probably an ancestor:

Wits University Library                                               
TYPE      Manuscript                                                           
REFERENCE A1593f                                                               
DESCRIPTION          Cape of Good Hope                                                     
STARTING  18630116                                                             
ENDING    18630116                                                             
REMARKS   1p; Printed form completed in Ms.                                     
SUMMARY   +    Copy  of an entry in Dutch in the Baptismal Register of         
               the Reformed Church, Cape Town, recording  the  baptism         
               on 6 March 1842 of Daniel Coenraad Adriaan Vos, born on         
               18420114,  the  parents  being Fredrik Michiel Luyt Vos         
               and Magdalena Sophia Nieuwenhuysen.  Certified  a  true         
               copy by A Faure.                             

It is likely that all the children would have been baptised in the Reformed Church. A lot of those records are online at Family Search.