RootsChat.Com

England (Counties as in 1851-1901) => England => Lincolnshire => Topic started by: meathead on Saturday 27 January 18 15:27 GMT (UK)

Title: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: meathead on Saturday 27 January 18 15:27 GMT (UK)
Hi, I'm on ancestry.com but I've seem somethings on findmy past which aren't on ancestry not sure if its worthwhile subscribing to both.

At moment I'm researching an Annie whiting Wilson who married James Edward gosling. I can see something about her funeral on findmy past but not sure what else, does anyone have access to it?

Thanks

Tracey
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: groom on Saturday 27 January 18 15:41 GMT (UK)
Is this her death?

ANNIE W GOSLING
Birth    1881
Age   52
Death quarter   2
Death year   1933
Boston Lincolnshire
Volume   7A  Page   420

That's all I can see. Where did you see the bit about her funeral?
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: meathead on Saturday 27 January 18 15:42 GMT (UK)
On find my past, was a newspaper article
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: groom on Saturday 27 January 18 15:53 GMT (UK)
It is a funeral announcement from the Boston Guardian 17th June 1933.

She died on the Monday and was buried on the Wednesday. Died at 11 Caroline St, Boston. Mourners were Mr James Edward Gosling (Widower) and daughters Alice and Florrie plus a friend Mrs J Baxter. Then there is a list of people who sent wreaths. Buried at Boson Cemetery.
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: meathead on Saturday 27 January 18 16:10 GMT (UK)
Do you think its worthwhile subscribing to find my past as well as ancestry? I thought they would have had similar information on, twice recently things have been found in newspaper articles.
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: macwil on Saturday 27 January 18 16:26 GMT (UK)
It depends what records you're looking for and where.
From personal experience, Ancestry are good with Lancashire Parish Records, whereas FindMyPast are good with Shropshire.
 Best advice I can give is to view and explore their Record Collections, you should be able to access these without joining, and decide which one has the records you are looking for. Be prepared to spend some time at it, both lists are extensive. :D
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: meathead on Saturday 27 January 18 16:29 GMT (UK)
Thanks I didn't think of that.
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: macwil on Saturday 27 January 18 16:40 GMT (UK)
Also don't forget local Family History Societies, they obviously have local knowledge and often produce cracking publications full of useful titbits.
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: meathead on Saturday 27 January 18 16:51 GMT (UK)
Think I've just got lazy thinking everything was on ancestry, I have people disappear on records, maybe find my past can fill the gaps.

Thanks for your help
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: macwil on Saturday 27 January 18 17:07 GMT (UK)
Easy to do and just what the commercial sites hope will happen.

There are plenty of free sites about, check out the county board resources here on RC.
And don't forget many libraries have subscriptions to one or other of the big commercial sites that you can access for free just by being a library member or a small fee if not.
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: Floss on Wednesday 31 January 18 17:25 GMT (UK)
I've used both and personally I prefer Ancestry but I will swap to FindMyPast if it has a good offer on the subscription.
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: glenclare on Wednesday 31 January 18 17:36 GMT (UK)
I buy one main subscription when it is on offer and then pay for a month on the other site may be a couple of times a year, or keep my fingers crossed that there is a free weekend .
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: Tom Piper on Wednesday 07 March 18 16:15 GMT (UK)
Hi, Just wonder if your James Edward GOSLING that you are researching was a lorry driver, because if so I have found some articles about him in some newspapers.

I have used Ancestry for some time now, that is Ancestry co.uk, at first when I started my Family History research in 1995 I would ask someone who had an account with the organisation to do some cook ups for me but in 2005 I decided to open my own account with them and found it very successful, mainly because I could load several family trees on the site as public trees. A friend of mine has Find my past account but some things aren't always successful on look ups.

Tom
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: cristeen on Wednesday 07 March 18 18:22 GMT (UK)
I use both. I like the Lancashire parish records on Ancestry in particular, great backup to Lancs OPC, and original images. I also find it easier to search and being able to hover over the record description can give a good idea if it's worth opening. I like FindMyPast for the newspaper archives, many a time I have found details of an ancestor's death which has saved ordering the DC. I also like the Yorkshire parish records and Merchant Navy records on there. I'm not keen on their search parameters though, having to open every record to determine it's pertinence can be time consuming. I suppose it all depends on your geographical/occupational/ otherwise areas of interest. I pay for both monthly so can cancel at any time.
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: dawnsh on Wednesday 07 March 18 18:34 GMT (UK)
If you still haven't decided, check your local library to see if they offer free access in-house to either or both.
Title: Re: Ancestry.com or find mypast?
Post by: matthewj64 on Wednesday 07 March 18 18:36 GMT (UK)
... twice recently things have been found in newspaper articles.

The British Newspaper Archive is free in some libraries and has a range of paying options inc. pay as you go - and a few free pages when you join

https://www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk/