RootsChat.Com

England (Counties as in 1851-1901) => England => Nottinghamshire => Topic started by: Westy11 on Sunday 10 June 18 05:59 BST (UK)

Title: Your opinion please
Post by: Westy11 on Sunday 10 June 18 05:59 BST (UK)
William Edward FISHER was one child of two of William Samuel FISHER & Ann Mary GIBSON. William E's sibling was Mary Audrey FISHER.

The piece on which i am seeking an opinion is if this is the person who married Kate E STENTON IN 1921.  The issue is that if this is the correct William E he would have been 17 at the time of marriage which is rather unusual.

The facts:
William Edward FISHER was born 16 Sep 1904 Warren, Yorkshire.  Evidence that contributes is the 1939 register, 1911 census; Baptism copy
1939 Register has William Edward as the right birth date, married and a Tailors Cutter
Father's administration notes William Edward was a Tailors Cutter
Sisters administration notes William Edward was a Tailors Cutter

So in looking for a FREEbdm marriage in Nottinghamshire before 1939 the only such marriage was for William E FISHER Sep 1921 reg Newark to STENTON. 

in the 1939 register William E is living alone.  I am unable to locate a Kate STENTON in the 1939 register.

This is the challenge as if this is the William E I am researching then he would have been only 17.

Thoughts??

Westy

Title: Re: Your opinion please
Post by: Kay99 on Sunday 10 June 18 06:43 BST (UK)
Maybe unrelated but there is the death of a Kate Eleanor Fisher 09/1983 Newark Nottinghamshire (born 21 Sept 1894)    and William Edward Fisher b 16 Sept  1904 also died in Newark 03/1978   :-\

Kay
Title: Re: Your opinion please
Post by: Westy11 on Sunday 10 June 18 06:45 BST (UK)
Hello Kay,

Definitely not unrelated to my overall research and thanks so much.

Westy
Title: Re: Your opinion please
Post by: Kay99 on Sunday 10 June 18 06:51 BST (UK)
There is the birth of a Kate Eleanor Smalley in Newark Dec Qtr Newark 7b    433  and a marriage in 1915 Newark - Kate E Smalley to Leonard Stanton

Kay
Title: Re: Your opinion please
Post by: medpat on Sunday 10 June 18 06:53 BST (UK)
Kate E Fisher married and living in Newark 1939 born 1895, husband William E born 1883.
Title: Re: Your opinion please
Post by: Westy11 on Sunday 10 June 18 06:58 BST (UK)
Well Kay & medpat collectively you have solved a part of the conundrum - do you agree William E must have be 17 years of age at marriage??
Title: Re: Your opinion please
Post by: Kay99 on Sunday 10 June 18 07:03 BST (UK)
To me it looks your William (born 1904) must have married a different person as Kate's husband in 1939 was 10 years older  :-[

Kay
Title: Re: Your opinion please
Post by: medpat on Sunday 10 June 18 07:12 BST (UK)
I agree with Kay, the William I found was 20/21 when the other William E arrived in the world in 1904, my William E was much older than his wife.
Title: Re: Your opinion please
Post by: Westy11 on Sunday 10 June 18 07:19 BST (UK)
Back to the drawing board perhaps.   ;D ::)