RootsChat.Com

Beginners => Family History Beginners Board => Topic started by: Kathy Dean on Wednesday 09 January 19 20:20 GMT (UK)

Title: Birth certificate
Post by: Kathy Dean on Wednesday 09 January 19 20:20 GMT (UK)
Hi I applied for my father's birth certificate in November 2017,the last call to Home Affairs being in Dec 2018, I was informed that there is a query on his place of birth, Durban South Africa. Where can I find assistance in this matter, trying to apply for ancestral visa. Thanks
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: KGarrad on Wednesday 09 January 19 20:43 GMT (UK)
Birth Certificate in which country?
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: Girl Guide on Wednesday 09 January 19 21:39 GMT (UK)
Hi Kathy

Welcome to Rootschat  :)

One wonders why the Home Affairs dept. are querying his place of birth.  Did you provide that piece of information yourself when applying for his birth cert?

The dept. presumably has to make sure they are sending you the correct certificate.  Is his name a common one?

Are you positive about where he was born?

Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: Kathy Dean on Thursday 10 January 19 04:46 GMT (UK)
Hi Thanks for the welcome. Yes I did supply Home Affairs here in South Africa with the info. My 3 siblings and I were all under the impression that he was born in Durban South Africa. This is what we remember. It appears this is not the case. Have already received a copy of his father's birth certificate. Both his father and mother and oldest brother were born in Scotland! His name is common, John William Gordon. Have enlisted the help of a genealogist in Scotland. She has done an extensive search, including USA, Canada and of course the UK. He had another brother, few years older, appears his birthplace is also unknown!! Have found the passenger list of the ship my grandparents and oldest uncle were on. They left London in 1912 and disembarked in Durban, South Africa!
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: Girl Guide on Thursday 10 January 19 06:55 GMT (UK)
Hhmm, so they left London in 1912.  In theory it should be possible to locate the family in the 1901 census and earlier.  The 1911 census information is for England and Wales only so if they weren't there in 1911 won't be able to locate them.

Could you provide the names of his parents and sibling(s), their birth places if known and birth years?What was his father's occupation?  What information was on the passenger list?

I am assuming that your father has died?  If so do you have his death certificate and what does it say?
 
Did your genealogist look for any wills?
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: Kathy Dean on Thursday 10 January 19 08:31 GMT (UK)
Genealogist has been most helpful thus far, as I recall she did all the necessary checks, census etc, but not sure about wills. I do have my father's death certificate but it only states date of birth and death. Thinking, perhaps year of birth is incorrect. I have a copy of his ID card, it has 9 digits unlike our current ID docs. Tried to find what the digits represent this a.m, can't seem to find anything. On enquiring at the local office late last year the consultant said the numbers do not relate to dates???? As you see ID 490383016, has 16 at the end, could this be year of birth? Death certificate states 1917. Father Born Thomas Monteith Samuel (to add to the confusion they changed surname to Gordon?????) Coachman(not domestic) Born 14 Aug 1884, Glasgow. Mother Maud Ellen(Hayden) Samuel. Brother Alexander Thomas Samuel 28 Sept 1911, South West Hackney London. Don't have info for other brother Hayden, will check in correspondence received from my sister. Passenger list has them listed as Gordon, grandparents and Alexander embarked London 1912 and arrived in Durban South Africa. Don't seem to think they traveled much after arriving here. I contacted the hospital where my father passed this morning, no joy.
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: Ruskie on Thursday 10 January 19 09:05 GMT (UK)
Hhmm, so they left London in 1912.  In theory it should be possible to locate the family in the 1901 census and earlier.  The 1911 census information is for England and Wales only so if they weren't there in 1911 won't be able to locate them.

The Scottish census is available on Scotlands People. You need to sign up and purchase credits to view that plus many other records:
https://www.nrscotland.gov.uk/research/guides/census-records/1911-census

If you have Scottish ancestry you need to use Scotlands People to purchase birth, death and marriage certificates. Cost is very reasonable. Census transcriptions only are available on the pay sites apart from the 1911.

Familysearch has decent coverage for some areas of Scotland so worth checking there too.
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: mckha489 on Thursday 10 January 19 09:55 GMT (UK)
deleted

Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: whiteout7 on Thursday 10 January 19 10:09 GMT (UK)
Who filled in his death certificate? If it was not his wife it is entirely possible that the birth date you have is completely wrong?

Is this him JOHN WILLIAM   GORDON   1921/11/20 (Is you mother deceased? wifes name is M**** S*****)   

20th November 1921

https://www.identitynumber.org/death-records.php
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: whiteout7 on Thursday 10 January 19 10:13 GMT (UK)
Is this his mothers birth date

MAUD MARY   GORDON   18941229

29 December 1894

https://www.identitynumber.org/death-records.php

amended I see she was Maud Ellen Gordon
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: whiteout7 on Thursday 10 January 19 10:21 GMT (UK)
This is interesting

ELLEN MAUD ARY   SAMUEL   19130425

Ellen Maud (Mary?) Samuel born 25 April 1913

https://www.identitynumber.org/death-records.php

Was their a sister too, maybe died young? Not sure, name is a co-incidence

How much do you really know about your fathers family?
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 10:22 GMT (UK)
Thomas Monteith Samuel is easy to trace on 1891/1901 on census in Scotland, 1911 in London in the city as a fireman.

He certainly liked to move around, Alexander Thomas birth registered dec qtr 1911 Hackney, then baptised as Thomas Alexander Samuel born 28/9/1911 bapt 19/11/1911 Jesus Chapel Enfield, but gives his address as 25 High Street Peckham.

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 10:32 GMT (UK)
25 high street Peckham is on google maps, it is a shop with accommodation above.

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: whiteout7 on Thursday 10 January 19 10:38 GMT (UK)
Is this his death on Familysearch?

Thomas Monteith Gordon
South Africa, Pietermaritzburg Estate Files 1846-1950
Thomas Monteith Gordon
Probate
1948
Natal, South Africa
62
Birth Year (Estimated)   1886
Birthplace   Scotland
died 19 Feb 1948
at Durban

Lists the sons names
Alexander Thomas Gordon (Major)
John William Gordon (Major)

Maud Gordon died Feb 1920, they married in London on this document

((Could Army records in South Africa provide more detail?))
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 10:58 GMT (UK)
Can trace Thomas mother Mary (nee Monteith) Samuel through Scottish census, except 1881 where a Mary Gordon pops up matching ?

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: whiteout7 on Thursday 10 January 19 11:00 GMT (UK)
Maude Ellen Gordons Civil death Registration is on Family search to


South Africa, Natal Province, Civil Deaths
Maud Ellen Gordon
Death
27 Feb 1920
Escombe, Pinetown, Natal, South Africa
Age   31
Birth Year (Estimated)   1889
Birthplace   England

So she died or TB 3 years after John William Gordon was born? Could he have been born around Escombe, Pinetown, Natal?
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 11:02 GMT (UK)
They married sept qtr 1910 West Ham

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 11:05 GMT (UK)
Looks like Maud Ellen Hayden was born dec qtr 1889 West Ham

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: whiteout7 on Thursday 10 January 19 11:11 GMT (UK)
Looks like Maud Ellen Hayden was born dec qtr 1889 West Ham

Jennifer

Marriage on freebdm
Marriages Sep 1910   
Hayden    Maud E        W Ham    4a   184
Samuel    Thomas M        W. Ham    4a   184
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 11:16 GMT (UK)
The Hayden family look to be well researched on line even a picture of maud’s father George. No information on Maud though.

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 11:24 GMT (UK)
Maud is living in Dalston in 1911.

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: whiteout7 on Thursday 10 January 19 11:28 GMT (UK)
Just putting this here to
Is this Hayden Gordon?

HAYDEN ROBERT   GORDON   19430509

Born 09th May 1943

https://www.identitynumber.org/death-records.php

Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 11:30 GMT (UK)
Just found a tree with Hayden born 1914 Natal and John William 1917 Cape Town

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: whiteout7 on Thursday 10 January 19 11:32 GMT (UK)
Just found a tree with Hayden Samuel born 1914 Natal and John William 1917 Cape Town

Jennifer

That is good!
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 11:33 GMT (UK)
Ive removed Samuel as not sure if they are under a Samuel or Gordon

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: whiteout7 on Thursday 10 January 19 11:41 GMT (UK)
Familysearch again

Hayden Edward (Edmund?) Gordon
Marriage
23 Dec 1939
Durban, Natal, South Africa
24 years
Birth Year (Estimated)   1915
Stoffelina Andrisa Venter (Staffelina Sandrina?)
Female
18 years
Spouse's Birth Year (Estimated)   1921
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: Kathy Dean on Thursday 10 January 19 11:58 GMT (UK)
Yes this is the info I have. I have a copy of an entry of MARRIAGES which has the district as Westham dated 8 Dec 1975? Was wondering about the date and why and where were they living when requesting the. Marriage solemnized parish church of Seyton? County Essex? 1910 Looks like August 17. And yes, cause of death is correct. When I filled in the application for my father's birth certificate, I put his place of birth as, Durban Natal known as Kwa Zulu Natal. Surely this is sufficient? Maybe not. Will apply again stating Escombe Pinetown Natal. Thanks to all. Holding thumbs.
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 12:02 GMT (UK)
District is West Ham and parish Leyton both were in Essex then .

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: Girl Guide on Thursday 10 January 19 12:16 GMT (UK)
Oh my, the Rootschatters have certainly provided you with plenty of information now Kathy.  You should be able to move further on with all this.   :)
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: Kathy Dean on Thursday 10 January 19 12:21 GMT (UK)
Yes, indeed!
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: jennifer c on Thursday 10 January 19 12:23 GMT (UK)
Not sure where the person who’s tree I saw got the information  John William born Cape Town ?

Jennifer
Title: Re: Birth certificate
Post by: Kathy Dean on Thursday 10 January 19 13:03 GMT (UK)
Will  check with my contact who did the family tree.