RootsChat.Com

Research in Other Countries => Australia => Topic started by: cumbria nige on Friday 03 May 19 19:41 BST (UK)

Title: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: cumbria nige on Friday 03 May 19 19:41 BST (UK)
Hi
Can SKS help, please?
Trying to make a trace on James Butterfield, who migrated to Perth, Australia in the early 1900's. He sailed there with his wife, Martha and daughter, Alice. I am of the opinion that they emigrated in order for James to take up a position of establishing a police force there. He had retired from the Metropolitan Police. Thereafter, I have no trace on this family.
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Friday 03 May 19 23:38 BST (UK)
Hi cumbria nige,

    Here is W.A. BDM https://www.bdm.justice.wa.gov.au/_apps/pioneersindex/default.aspx and there is no record of James or Martha dying there.

    Here is a history of the Western Australian police force and their commissioners
https://www.police.wa.gov.au/About-Us/Our-History/WA-Police-Commissioners   and there is no mention of a Butterfield.

    I think they must have travelled to another state ... will keep looking.

Ros
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Friday 03 May 19 23:54 BST (UK)
Could you give us a few more details - date of birth and parents' names please.

Ros
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: cumbria nige on Saturday 04 May 19 01:10 BST (UK)
James was born abt 1852 in the St Geo Hanover district. Martha in abt 1825 in Lambeth and Alice (could be Alice Belissa) in 1863 in Rotherhithe
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: majm on Saturday 04 May 19 01:21 BST (UK)
James was born abt 1852 in the St Geo Hanover district. Martha in abt 1825 in Lambeth and Alice (could be Alice Belissa) in 1863 in Rotherhithe

Something is not quite right.   James born about 1852 is unlikely to be the father of Alice born in 1863.

Please check  :D

JM
Title: Re: Mellish in Perth, Australia
Post by: cumbria nige on Saturday 04 May 19 01:38 BST (UK)
Apologises. I wrote down the incorrect details when copying and realised before you posted. The family name was Mellish. George (b.1849 in Shoreditch). Harriet (b.1867 in Lewisham) and Edith (b.1883, not known where)
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: sparrett on Saturday 04 May 19 02:06 BST (UK)
Apologises. I wrote down the incorrect details when copying and realised before you posted. The family name was Mellish. George (b.1849 in Shoreditch). Harriet (b.1867 in Lewisham) and Edith (b.1883, not known where)

Hi You have possibly still confused some dates above.

 
Marriages Sep 1867 
 
BRIGHTMAN    Harriot        
MELLISH    George
Lewisham 1d   1142
   
 
Birth
MELLISH, EDITH
MMS   BRIGHTMAN   
1882  S Quarter
WEST HAM
Volume 04A  Page 147

Edith was one of a number of children to the couple.
 
  Sue

Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: majm on Saturday 04 May 19 02:13 BST (UK)
Now I am confuddled ...  was the surname MELLISH or BUTTERFIELD for the migrating family?

JM
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: majm on Saturday 04 May 19 02:20 BST (UK)
http://soda.naa.gov.au/record/8181647/1
Passenger list with details of a MELLISH family to WA, arriving Fremantle 2 Oct 1902 per the Omrah, a voyage from London to Sydney.
Mr Mellish aged 50
Mrs Mellish aged 49
Miss Mellish aged 24
Miss M Mellish aged 16

JM
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: sparrett on Saturday 04 May 19 02:57 BST (UK)
Yes, I think the correct MELLISH family did arrive.
Here are a few snips of interest.

Supporting item from London as he retires from one position and moves on to Aust
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/32668263


His retirement in WA
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/80964101

The marriage of Edith
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/24859651


A baby ;D

SAVAGE   Arthur Charles
Father Arthur William
Mother MELLISH Edith    
Perth 4484
1904


Sue
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: MaureeninNY on Saturday 04 May 19 03:00 BST (UK)
And (from TROVE):
The West Australian (Perth, WA : 1879 - 1954)  Tuesday 23 February 1904  p 5 Article... * /PERSOIAL.L. Inspector Mellish, latehead of the Crtf. minal Invesigation bepartment, left by: the ... R.M.S. Orotava for London, yesterday. He is adcompanied by Mia. aid Miss Mellish.

Maureen
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: majm on Saturday 04 May 19 03:06 BST (UK)
And (from TROVE):
The West Australian (Perth, WA : 1879 - 1954)  Tuesday 23 February 1904  p 5 Article... * /PERSOIAL.L. Inspector Mellish, latehead of the Crtf. minal Invesigation bepartment, left by: the ... R.M.S. Orotava for London, yesterday. He is adcompanied by Mia. aid Miss Mellish.

Maureen

Here is the arrival in Oct 1902
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/37545123 Western Mail 11 Oct 1902

JM
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: majm on Saturday 04 May 19 03:12 BST (UK)
Here in the 1901 UK census some of the MELLISH household
https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:X9NQ-4BX - Police Inspector
https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:X9NQ-4BF - Harriett, wife

JM
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Saturday 04 May 19 05:52 BST (UK)
Here is an obit to an Arthur William SAVAGE who died in South Australia in 1952
http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article78665335  with a lot of family info

Here is the death notice http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article47370979 which mentions wife Edith and the children

Ros
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Saturday 04 May 19 06:03 BST (UK)
Edith SAVAGE died in 1956 in Adelaide, South Australia   https://www.genealogysa.org.au/

Death 1956 SAVAGE Edith [deceased husband Arthur William SAVAGE]

Her burial at Robe

Ros
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Saturday 04 May 19 06:23 BST (UK)
Some snippets about Arthur and Edith's children.

Alistair William selected for Royal Naval College http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article36462833

Wedding of Nora to SUTHERLAND http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article78607640

Wedding of Alicia to PALTRIDGE http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article77903314

Wedding of Annie to MICHELMORE http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article147066927

Ros
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Saturday 04 May 19 06:32 BST (UK)
More on Arthur and Edith's children ...

WW2 service summary for Horace Mellish SAVAGE http://www.ww2roll.gov.au/Veteran.aspx?serviceId=A&veteranId=673565

WW2 service summary for Robert Cecil SAVAGE http://www.ww2roll.gov.au/Veteran.aspx?serviceId=N&veteranId=1195682

Mariage of Edith to CONCANNON http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article43756799  and a birth
http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article74646337

Ros

adding :
WW2 service for Norman Henry SAVAGE http://www.ww2roll.gov.au/Veteran.aspx?serviceId=A&veteranId=411282
WW2 service for Alister William SAVAGE http://www.ww2roll.gov.au/Veteran.aspx?ServiceId=N&VeteranId=1195679
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Saturday 04 May 19 06:41 BST (UK)
Engagement of Horace http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article30500097

Ros
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Saturday 04 May 19 07:17 BST (UK)
You can find the births of the children born in South Australia here https://www.genealogysa.org.au/

Children born with parents Arthur William SAVAGE and Edith MELLISH

1908 Annie Georgina SAVAGE , at Adelaide
1909 Jack Reginald SAVAGE , at Adelaide
1910 Dorothy Florence SAVAGE , at Adelaide
1912 Norman Henry SAVAGE at Adelaide
1914 George Walter SAVAGE, at Adelaide
1918 N* E* SAVAGE at Adelaide
1921 R* C* SAVAGE at Adelaide
1920 A* W* SAVAGE at Adelaide
1924 E* Y*  SAVAGE at Robe

Have I missed any?

Ros

adding : you can find their marriages and deaths there too
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Saturday 04 May 19 07:37 BST (UK)
Dorothy's marriage http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article77990226
and a birth http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article49794769

Ros
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: sparrett on Saturday 04 May 19 07:40 BST (UK)
And (from TROVE):
The West Australian (Perth, WA : 1879 - 1954)  Tuesday 23 February 1904  p 5 Article... * /PERSOIAL.L. Inspector Mellish, latehead of the Crtf. minal Invesigation bepartment, left by: the ... R.M.S. Orotava for London, yesterday. He is adcompanied by Mia. aid Miss Mellish.

Maureen


It actually says...... accompanied by Mrs and Miss Mellish....

I think Edith took a trip to England perhaps to visit family.
Edith Savage
Age 53
Birth Date abt 1882
Port of Departure Brisbane, Australia
Arrival Date 7 Nov 1935
Port of Arrival London, England
Ship Baradine

Intended address 53 Grosvenor Rd. Ilford Essex. 

There was an Amy MELLISH who married in 1904.  Possibly Edith's sister born 1879.

Marriage

Marriages Sep 1905 

MELLISH  Amy   
SUMNER  Chauncey Hugh
W. Ham  4a 538   

This couple appear on the following census without children.
Ilford, Essex was the area where the SUMNER couple lived and Amy remained in that area it seems though I am not sure the couple remained together.

Information around late 1930's has them living at different addresses and the National Probate Calendar shows Chauncy's estate favoured someone other than Amy. 8)

Edith's brother Ernest MELLISH (b. 1878) is also recorded in the late 1930's with a family.

Sue

 
 


Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: sparrett on Saturday 04 May 19 08:03 BST (UK)
http://soda.naa.gov.au/record/8181647/1
Passenger list with details of a MELLISH family to WA, arriving Fremantle 2 Oct 1902 per the Omrah, a voyage from London to Sydney.
Mr Mellish aged 50
Mrs Mellish aged 49
Miss Mellish aged 24
Miss M Mellish aged 16

JM

The M MELLISH aged 16 is a bit confusing.

A newspaper clip  listing the passengers arriving per OMRAH 1902 shows

Mr and Mrs G. Mellish, Miss F MELLISH and Miss E MELLISH.

Ages are not mentioned .

The listing for the return voyage to England in 1904 per Orotava shows
Mr Geo MELLISH
Mrs MELLISH
Miss MELLISH aged 29

Aged 29 would make her Flora MELLISH born 1874/5

Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Saturday 04 May 19 08:15 BST (UK)
Still on Edith and Arthur's children.

Death 1925 Robe, South Australia
George Wallis SAVAGE [father Arthur William SAVAGE] at Robe

How very sad - he was only 10 - horse riding accident http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article200992607
 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article54913957
 http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article165866244

Ros
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: sparrett on Saturday 04 May 19 08:33 BST (UK)
As you will know, I'm sure, George and Harriett had a son named Rowland.
MELLISH, ROWLAND MMS    BRIGHTMAN 
1875.  D Quarter in POPLAR
Volume 01C  Page 699


They also had a daughter Beatrice.


The National Probate Calendar shows


MELLISH, George of 26 Betchworth Road Ilford Essex died 20 th July 1936. Probate London 30 Sept to Rowland MELLISH shop assistant and Beatrice Moorcroft, wife of Albert Thomas Moorcroft . Effects 776 pounds

ADDING

Deaths Sep 1936   

MELLISH  George
Aged  87
Romford  4a 406


Sue

Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: cumbria nige on Saturday 04 May 19 15:50 BST (UK)
Thanks and again, apologises. I really messed up with this posting for help. Indeed, the family group that I am interested is searching for is the MELLISH one. I had thought that George and Harriet had travelled with one of their daughters but it looks as though 2 of them went with them, namely Amy and Edith. I would appeal for further help in making any trace of them after they emigrated. Thankyou
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: cumbria nige on Saturday 04 May 19 15:56 BST (UK)
The reference of their return voyage is likely to be making reference to their daughter Florence, b. Croydon 1874  (Mar 1874 Croydon 2a 239)
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: cumbria nige on Saturday 04 May 19 20:39 BST (UK)
I found other messages on this site which gave me details of the deaths of Edith's children. It looks as though most of them died in infancy
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: cumbria nige on Saturday 04 May 19 20:55 BST (UK)
In scrolling through newspaper articles and other material available online, there is reference to 'George Mellish, appointed by Hare (A police commissionar) to head the local (meaning in Perth) C.I.B.' and that he retired ahead of completing his 5 year appointment before returning to England in 1904
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: sparrett on Saturday 04 May 19 23:55 BST (UK)
Thanks and again, apologises. I really messed up with this posting for help. Indeed, the family group that I am interested is searching for is the MELLISH one. I had thought that George and Harriet had travelled with one of their daughters but it looks as though 2 of them went with them, namely Amy and Edith. I would appeal for further help in making any trace of them after they emigrated. Thankyou

Don't worry about the mess up with dates etc.. It often happens and is sorted now ;D

If you think it is AMY and EDITH who travelled to Australia with them, Why is it F MELLISH arriving.

Edith married here and the other returned with her parents.

See reply #21

Sue
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Saturday 04 May 19 23:57 BST (UK)
I found other messages on this site which gave me details of the deaths of Edith's children. It looks as though most of them died in infancy

The obit for William Arthur SAVAGE says that he leaves a widow and 11 children in 1952.  It lists most of them.   I posted details of some of their weddings and world war 2 service etc.    They did NOT die in infancy.   Have a read through the posts and click on the links.   Just take it slowly ... :)

Ros
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: sparrett on Saturday 04 May 19 23:57 BST (UK)
Amy married in England, I believe.
I have given some details of her likely whereabouts as Mrs SUMNER.

Sue
Title: Re: Butterfield in Perth, Australia
Post by: rosball on Sunday 05 May 19 00:26 BST (UK)
Here is an excerpt from the obit for Edith's husband. (which I posted in reply #13)

He leaves a widow and eleven children.
They are Dr. Charles Savage,Adelaide; Mr. Horace Savage,Gawler; Mrs. Alicia Paltridge, Brisbane, Mrs  Annie Michelmore, Adelaide; Lieutenant Commander William Savage. Flinders Naval Base;
Lieutenant Commander Robert Savage, H.M.A.S. Anzac; Mrs. Norah Sutherland, Penola,
; Mrs. Edith Concannon, Naracoorte; and Mr. J. R. (Reg) Savage, Mt. Gambier.


They omitted Mrs Dorothy HURN.

These are all adult children and did NOT die in infancy.

Ros