Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Nick_Ips

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 ... 72
1
The Common Room / Re: Newspaper reports of marriages.
« on: Saturday 22 March 25 19:28 GMT (UK)  »
Was this some sort of code that everyone at the time would have understood or is my imagingation running away with me?

You mean something like "Arranged in a great hurry so not enough time to invite a more extensive guest list" ?

2
The Common Room / Re: Poor transcriptions
« on: Sunday 16 March 25 21:11 GMT (UK)  »
...Where a suggestion is definitely the better solution they could help by changing the main transcription and leave the original interpretation under suggestions as a "previous transcription" or similar....

But that would make no difference to finding a record, provided both (all) versions are indexed.

Deciding which record was definitely the better solution would take resources (=cost).  I'd rather Ancestry use the resources they have to give us access to more record sets, or else keep the subscription costs down.

Achieving greater accuracy in the transcriptions of records that have already been described doesn't really gain us much, so long as there are tools to find the records in the first place.

3
The Common Room / Re: Poor transcriptions
« on: Saturday 08 March 25 14:28 GMT (UK)  »
...
Given that that was not done, corrections submitted by relatives should be accepted.
Ancestry's handling of the 1921 census is a disgrace.

as far as I know user submitted 'corrections' are accepted and become searchable, albeit as alternates rather than replacing the original entry.

I don't see this being a particular problem, provided the search algorithm does pick up on user generated alternatives.  If we treat the transcriptions as a finding aid (and having spent days and days at the FRC winding forward and back through microfims I'm delighted to have whatever help we can get) then it isn't critical what the transcription says, so long as the right record can be found.

I have to say, rather than finding it a 'disgrace', I think Ancestry's approach to the 1921 census has been pretty good. Yes, it would be nice if they had retranscribed the whole lot, but just having an alternative means of searching the same data has been valuable to me.

I've found many 1921 households since the Ancestry launch that I'd spent hours looking for on FindMyPast with no joy - in particular by searching Ancestry for a different recordset for an individual (e.g. 1901 or 1911 census) and then seeing what gets listed in the 'suggested' records for the 1921 census.

Ancestry's approach to fuzzy searching - in my view - is delivering better results than FindMyPast.  If that is a byproduct of Ancestry having an awareness of inaccuracies in their data and developing a search algorithm to compensate then I'd say that was more than fine with me.  :)  Getting a result from a finding aid is as important (more so IMV) than every record being transcribed with 100% accuracy... because, let's face it, the original data captured in 1921 was far from perfect.

4
The Lighter Side / Re: Senior moment
« on: Saturday 16 November 24 15:56 GMT (UK)  »
Thank very much for all you replies, it looks as though I can get the information I need from the library copy, which will save me subscribing. I’ve just got to make a list of exactly what I need.
Thanks again for everyone's help
Jo

Just to confirm the version you can access via a library has exactly the same information for the 1921 census as the regular online version.

The only thing you (probably) can't do is to access the site while logged in to your own personal account, unless you are using your own device.

5
This free weekend - including the 1921 census records - appears to have started already.

6
The Common Room / Re: FindMyPast - partial free access for Remembrance Day
« on: Friday 01 November 24 09:20 GMT (UK)  »

The 1939 register free access period has now started.

7
The Common Room / Re: FindMyPast - partial free access for Remembrance Day
« on: Sunday 20 October 24 09:56 BST (UK)  »
Just a caution: I can't see a closing time stated, but last year it was 10am rather than 1 minute to midnight as other sites tend to be, so don't have a lie in on Monday assuming you have all day.

I agree Chris, the last time there was a FindMyPast free period the access was cut at 10am Monday morning while I was in the middle of doing something, even though the marketing implied the access was free Friday through Monday.

Treat anything after 10am Monday as a bonus, but aim to be finished before then.

8
The Common Room / FindMyPast - partial free access for Remembrance Day
« on: Saturday 19 October 24 13:11 BST (UK)  »

Can't see it mentioned yet, but FindMyPast have started free access to certain records in the lead up to 11th November.

Currently -
-All civil birth, marriage and death records
-All First World War military records and medal rolls and honours
-The 1911 Census of England and Wales


Not entirely clear what, but the email suggests there may be free access on multiple weekends, not just this one -
"More wartime resources will be free to access every weekend in the lead-up to Remembrance Day"

9

I often don't see your posts until it is too late, or sometimes the free ofer isn't relevant to me, but can I just say 'thanks' for regularly flagging up these freebies Chris - it is much appreciated.

Nick

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 ... 72