Phoebe 40, is in the 1841 census with husband Thomas Weir 40. Charlotte McKee 10 Phoebe McKee 9. For both Thomas and Phoebe it says not born in County but there is nothing in the last column headed 'Whether born in Ireland, Scotland or Foreign Parts."
There are others marked as being born in Ireland (I) so did Phoebe not tell them she was born in America or was it Thomas who gave the information and didn't know she was or is the 1851 census a lie.
HO107 piece 688 book 14 folio 32 page 2
There are so many accidental errors in the census. My grandfather is recorded as being born somewhere he wasn’t in the 1911 census - he moved when he was 1 so his father probably forgot.
I have wondered if the “America” is a red herring and she is from London
or somewhere in the UK.
She must have just married Thomas in the 1841 census as Scott died in 1840. Maybe they hadn’t discussed where she was born and he assumed.
I hadn’t found the 1841 census so thanks for that. If she was 40, then she wasn’t born in 1795 (possibly). However, I know ages aren’t often accurate either. Hard to remember how old I am sometimes
Phoebe doesn’t seem an overall common name and so I figured her mother of her grandmother could be a Phoebe but I haven’t had any luck with that either.
Really appreciate everyone’s input.