3
« on: Thursday 19 May 22 18:29 BST (UK) »
Hi all, so sorry for going quiet! This is all really interesting/useful stuff, so thanks to you all.
I've actually done a lot more research myself, and have been able to confirm that William Harrison was born William Dodd. The big breakthrough came when my cousin remembered meeting his sister, who died when she was almost 100. She had a first name and married name for her - Sarah Donkin, and estimated she'd died in 1986. I found one death record for the right area that matched everything exactly, and when I traced her back through all the records I found a confusing picture that paralleled William's in some ways.
The woman who died as Sarah Donkin was previously married to a man called John Thomas Grindle. The marriage record there was for a 'Sarah Ann Miller' - William Dodd's mother's maiden name was Isabella Miller, and when I found the birth record for 'Sarah Ann Miller' (1886, Lanchester) there was the clear indication that Sarah was born outside of marriage (Isabella Miller married Luke Dodd in 1887).
Sarah appears in the 1891 census as 'Sarah Ann Dodd', with the same birthplace (Stanley, Durham) as in the 1911 census when she was married to Thomas Grindle. And even beyond that, 'Mary Dodd' (b. 1894, and a full sister of William Dodd/Harrison) was living with Sarah in the 1911 census as a servant. There's not a single smoking gun due to all of the name changes, etc., but as far as I'm concerned I now have convincing evidence that Sarah was the child of Isabella Miller and thus the sister of William Dodd who later changed his name to William Harrison.
Helping the case is that William Dodd's birthplace in the 1901 census is Eighton Banks, matching the birthplace of William Dodd in the 1940 document that Tickettyboo found.
The picture of Luke Dodd's life is also really messy - I've found four wives for him so far and 14 children, some of whom may or may not have been his. There are also two mysterious illegitimate Miller children with Harrison as their middle name (as Galium found), born in the right area, who may or may not be connected (one of them, John Harrison Miller, is listed as a 'visitor' in the Dodd family home in the 1891 census). In short, it's a right mess and I'm still trying to figure things out! Happy to provide more detailed info on the children/marriages if anyone else is intrigued by all this.