Hi JK! Not sure if you're still on this thread, but I stumbled upon it while I was looking into some family history and couldn't resist filling you in! In your information, I believe that you'd identified Edith Grimshaw up until the 1911 census, at which time she was living with her great-aunt while her father and brother were in Ohio. The American census also has Sidney listed as a widower, which is untrue as far as I know it. There is a census out there somewhere (I can't say which, but, if I had to guess, it would be 1920 American census) that has both Ediths, mother and daughter, living together in Chicago. More than that, in our family, Edith Oakwell is fondly referred to as Meddie (Grandma Eddie), which proves she was not in fact dead in 1911. The family tale is that she tried her hand at Broadway and made it as a chorus member using the stage name Edith Aster. This could explain why she was absent in the 1911 census or listed under another name somewhere. I've never been able to find her during that time period, however. Edith Grimshaw married William Hume on June 27, 1933 in Cumberland, Maryland, not in Canada, which might explain why you had trouble locating them. They had three daughters, one of which is my grandmother. They lived in the Chicago area until both of their deaths (1987 for William and 2000 for Edith). Cecil died around 1970 I believe, but I know far less about that side of the family. I'm sorry I don't have any documents to back this up, only my family's word of mouth! There are undoubtedly documents out there if you wished to find them! I hope you receive this message! I would hate to have you wondering for eternity on what happened to our Edith!