Hi there
Some more food for thought...
I must admit that I’m a little perplexed.
I can see Frederick in the censuses of 1891 and 1901. He consistently stated that he was born in Hartpury, Glos, and that he was aged 29 and 39 respectively. This means his birth should have been registered in Newent sometime in the early 1860s.
I cannot find an entry for him in the GRO births index.
I cannot find him in earlier censuses.
I cannot see a birth, marriage or death registration for his father, William Dent Haines.
There was a slightly older Frederick John Haines who was baptised 3 August 1858 in Hartpury and who was the illegitimate son of Elizabeth Haines. (See his entry on the IGI.) And I can see this chap in the 1871 and 1881 censuses. By 1881 he was living in Colwall, Herefordshire, with his wife Harriet (born c1856 in Hartpury). Curiously – significantly, perhaps – I can’t find this Frederick (or Harriet) in 1891 or 1901.
It crosses my mind that your Frederick and this Frederick John may have been the same man, that he was previously married and that he understated his age in 1891 and 1901 (for reasons unknown). As a matter of interest, how old was he supposed to be when he died?
Checking earlier censuses I see that there were one or two families called Haines living in Hartpury. Intriguingly, the 1871 census reveals a farmer called William Dent (not William Dent Haines) living on Gloster Road. His immediate neighbours were William and Eliza Haines. Details as follows:
1871 Hartpury, Gloucestershire
RG 10/2609 folio 79 page 9
Address: Woodhams
William HAINES, head, m, 45, ag lab
Eliza, wife, m, 49, ag lab
Henry, son, 10, scholar
William, son, 7, scholar
All recorded as born in Hartpury
Next household on sheet –
Address: Gloster Rd
William DENT, head, 71, farmer of 40 acres employing 1 man, Cloton Staffordshire
Sophia, wife, 70, farmer’s wife, Hartpury Gloucestershire
Mary A., granddaur, 11, scholar, Hartpury Gloucestershire
John MANS, serv, 20, farm lab, Hartpury Gloucestershire
I suppose that William and Eliza Haines might have been your Frederick’s parents. Or perhaps William Dent was his father.
Further input from other RootsChatters would help!
Dave