Hi Silvery, I've been away & only just found your replies. I thought they let you know when someone had replied, but obviously not!? Yes I've got all censuses but she never appears living at home with her parents. I have her birth cert & yes her parents were Charles Edward Roberts & Elizabeth Beattie m in W Derby 1874. By the 1891 census she's working on a farm as assistant housekeeper & I have since found & obtained the birth cert for her illegitimate daughter, it turns out, not son. Her daughter was named Sarah Maria Roberts, no father named on the cert of course! She was b at Deytheur Farm Guilsfield in 1901 & on that census Alice is living with her aunt & uncle & working as their dairy maid but that's at Coed Mawr. Now I don't know if Coed Mawr is the same farm as Deytheur Farm where the birth cert said Sarah Maria was born or not. Rumour now has it that her daughter was "not all there" either, what ever this means?? And she then had an illegitimate son. There's only one elderly man alive in the family who remembers her & she was about 50 when he was born so he only knows hearsay & this is where I've got this info from. He doesn't know what was supposed to be wrong with her other than as he puts it she "wasn't all there". He remembers if the family all went out they had to find a "sitter" to stay in with her, so she presumably, by the time he could remember her ,was never seen in public!!! That's all I can offer. Any more ideas? Thanks for all your earlier replies that I've only just found. Amberly