Thanks very much for this. It looks like an earlier generation, which may carry me back further. The John I am looking for was baptised in 1809 to Edward and Ann (nee PONTING) and was definitely a brother to Jesse and Benjamin, whereas this person is more likely their uncle, if he's related at all!!
To make matters more complicated, I have found yet another BUTCHER - William - also born in Trowbridge in about 1794. In 1851 he has these children:
BUTCHER William 57 Spinner Trowbridge, Wilts.
Elizabeth 50 Twerton, Som.
Edward 23 Machinist Twerton, Som.
William 16 Cloth Worker Twerton, Som.
Mary 8 Scholar Twerton, Som.
FOREMAN William Lodger 17 Cloth Worker Twerton, Som.
When I look at the bathbmd website, Mary, born in 1843, is showing her mother's name as PONTING; indeed she has a sister Ann Ponting BUTCHER, born in 1838 (died in 1844) whose mother was also a PONTING.
SO, it looks as if William BUTCHER may have married Elizabeth PONTING, and had Elizabeth (1819), Sophia (1823) Edward (1828); William (1835); Ann (1938) and Mary (1843).
Could I impose on you to see if you can find John and Elizabeth in 1841 in Twerton and see who is living with them?
Many thanks indeed.
Philip