I`ll see what if anything I can find out.
But given the reference to the Theatrical Monument which is still there & the reference to a church, which was the Burial Chapel, no one there knows the actual date it was removed/demolished. There were 3 other chapels, one is now the Office, one is now the Book of Remeberance & the other is still in use (it was refurbished not long ago & is a very nice chapel...I might be able to post a photo or two).
Given the above, yes it was definetely Streatham Park Cemetery.....
I did wonder if/maybe the entries had been made incorrectly, maybe using a Christian Name rather than Surname, but not both entries...& at different times/years....but have dismissed that.
Alfred Smiths is on the corner of Meopham Road & it was there when I moved to Mitcham back in the mid 60`s aged 5yrs, always a chance they may have something on record?
The Lady who works there is nice, could be worth a phone call, they may have some archived records or may be willing to have a look?
They do have a few other branches so maybe they could have the records?
Bit of a long shot, I know, but never say never.
Is it possible that the surnames were mis-interpreted by the person entering the details? Just a thought, but if the same person wrote the names down on whatever forms they had too back then for both & the M looked like some other letter then the person who entered them may have interpreted them as another letter? Thats a possible scenario.
The Theatrical Monument is to have the area in front of it Landscaped this year, the Musical Hall Guild of Great Britain & America have gained some funding from the National Lottery I believe. They are quite nice people.