Yes that's him….an older 2010 topics:
http://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=500604.0http://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php/topic,489299.0.htmlI realise this new post is on the Canada boards - but it's going to be nigh on impossible to find him, even with all the following that you have from the Australian end in the 2010 topics.
• Robert and a brother, of Scots descent, (brother's name not known), came from Canada to the Ballarat Goldfields circa 1870+.
• His birthday is known in the family to be 24th December.
• Robert married Mary Ann FRYAR in 1876 in Minmi, NSW at the residence of his bride's parents.
• The marriage lines didn’t name his parents. The marriage was Methodist.
• Occupations: Miner, and Engineer
• Supposedly built railway lines and timber mills in Hunter Valley area. Definitely drove tugboat "Undaunted"
• On all bar one of the Birth certs of his children, it says Robert was born Canada circa 1848 to 1852. The last child's birth cert says Robert was born New York USA
• On a 1890 birth cert, of one of his children, Robert's place of birth in Canada changes
• In 1896, his engineers certificate says he was born New York, USA 1850
• Family Story: he was born on board ship as it entered Quebec Harbour, but research says Quebec harbour would be frozen over on 24th December,
• Regards his unusual 3 forename of 'Aquila' or 'Aquilla' a ship by the same name sailed into N.Y during the right period but no passenger lists found.
• Oz family say he had a brother who lived in Melbourne, who had a son named Bob who was born 1893 and lived in Narrandera. Bob had a girlfriend named Essie Crinlan.
• The brother's grandaughter was raised by him (the brother?) This Grandaughter died 2000, age 101.
Did you ever trace the Grand-daughter back through her parents...to try identify her Grandfather?
Cheers
AMBLY