It is very likely I am repeating myself, and also that I am duplicating information previously given on earlier threads, but to save others re-reading the earlier threads, may I please offer the following info
BACKGROUND
Pre Civil registration, (Civil rego commences in NSW in 1856) …
The details for a NSW marriage would be recorded by the officiating minister/priest in at least ONE local parish register, but often in TWO local parish registers. (One stored safely within the Church Building, and one kept close to the clergyman so that in case of fire he could immediately protect it)…. Where the clergyman was on a circuit, travelling from locality to locality he kept one with him in his saddle bag and one stayed behind for him to write it up on his return.
IF the celebrant obeyed the letter of the civil requirements (many did NOT, as they felt it more important to obey their Church laws and respect the sacredness of the details in their registers …. That is, not let secular eyes gain access, also keep it safe from persons of different denominations) THEN each quarter the celebrant would TRANSMIT the records to either the NSW Chaplains, or to his Sydney based Head Church Official for recording and onforwarding to the NSW Chaplains (This General Order dated from Gov Macquarie and was observed ‘more by the breach than by the actual observance’ particularly after the ceasation of Convicts being sent to NSW in 1840. So by 1856, many NSW ECR marriages are found in Church registers and not at NSW BDM indexes)
So, when you look on the NSW BDM online index for marriages, and you find references commencing with “V” you often find SEVERAL different registration numbers for the ONE ceremony. Finding only ONE reference does NOT actually confirm that it was celebrated in that specific church (it can, but it can also be that THAT register is the one that the NSW BDM has in its holdings.) It is unlikely that the officiating clergy noted the names of the parents for the bride or the groom on the early registers, UNLESS one of the parties were not yet 21 years of age, and the parent was available to give consent.
As an aside, the “V” stands for VOLUME. (ie the Volume number assigned to that book by the NSW BDM in around 1912 when they were starting to become a tad more organised in their record keeping)
Here’s my summary of (hopefully "all" the ECR) marriages of interest in the CHEATHAM/CHEETHAM NSW branch (pre civil registrations)
1820 James CHEETHAM married Elizabeth TAYLOR at St John’s Parramatta (C of E) but I have NOT found this listed at family search, sorry.
NSW BDM references
Vol 147B, line 942
Vol 3A, line 2481
1836 John CHEETHAM married Margaret SANDERS, 9 May 1836, St James (C of E)
https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTCT-Q4N https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTZK-9YG NSW BDM reference Vol 20, line 94, (NSW BDM have CHUTHAM for his surname)
1840 Leonard CHEETHAM married Anne CAHILL at Sydney Presbyterian (St Andrews Scots)
(30 June 1840, her father was John CAHILL)
https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTCN-LP2 https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTCG-L6Vhttps://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTZ7-YZW https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTZD-VWT NSW BDM
Vol 74A line 3407
Vol 75 line 711
1842 Samuel CHEETHAM married Hannah HAMMERSLEY atChrist Church St Laurence (temporary building donated by Terry HUGHES - St Lawrence’s Church, cnr Elizabeth and Albion Streets Sydney) 4 April 1842
https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTCP-K32 NSW BDM Vol 26C line 545
http://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/heritageapp/ViewHeritageItemDetails.aspx?ID=2424276 1846 Leonard James CHEETHAM married Elizabeth FRIEND at 9 October, 1846 at The Garrison Church (C of E)
https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTCR-P3B https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTZK-QJDNSW BDM Vol 31C line 624
1853 Mary Ann CHEETHAM married Thomas MAIDMENT at St Johns, Picton 5 May 1853 (C of E)
https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTC2-Q5VNSW BDM Vol 39C line 179
1853 John CHEETHAM married Fanny TYRRELL at St Lukes, Liverpool 5 June 1853
https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XTC2-QXZ NSW BDM Vol 39C line 159
It is my understanding that EACH of those family search results is from a parish register, so in the case of the 1840 marriage of Leonard and Anne, there are FOUR registers to be checked
I do have my own family tree fairly well documented in that era and I am not surprised at finding FOUR .... I have found one of my NSW ancestors marriage in six, back in the early 1820s.... twice in the local church, BOTH those then transmitted to the Wesleyans at Parramatta, and then re-transmitted to St Phillips, C of E. Yet, in recent times I am told that the current crop of Church Historians maintain that the Wesleyans only ever kept ONE register and rarely transmitted any records outside of their own denomination.
So I am not surprised by the lack of accuracy in the reply Bozzle received from NSW BDM.
Cheers, JM