BINGO!!!!
Hiya Jan, I'm quite excited - can you tell?
Thanks to the extra information I think I've cracked it. Looked up Emma on the IGI parents James & Maria and came up with the following listings in Muggington -
Christenings -
Eliza Hutchinson - 29 Apr 1831
James Hutchinson - 25 Dec 1834
Charles Hutchinson - 21 May 1843
Emma Hutchinson - 21 May 1843
George Hutchinson - 2 Sept 1847
Muggington, Derby
Parents - James & Maria Hutchinson
----------------------------------------------------------------
Marriage -
James Hutchinson & Maria Keeling
23 Nov 1829
Muggington, Derby
-----------------------------------------------------------------
This enabled me to look for them in Muggington in 1841
1841Taghole Lane, Muggington
Mary Keeling 71 born in county - yes
Fanny Keeling 4 yes
James Hutchinson 35 Ag Lab yes
Maria Hutchinson 30 yes
James Hutchinson 6 yes
Charles Hutchinson 3 yes
(HO107/ 181/ 17/ 9)
All ties together nicely doesn't it!! The Charles from All Saints was obviously a red herring - as it looks as though your Charles was christened with his sister when he was a toddler. Sometimes you forget that christening dates and birthdates are not the same thing. By the way, Muggington is 4 miles west of Duffield.
I do love it when it all turns out right in the end.
All the best
Sue