Baby step forward for two records which are 'possible, but not enough to be exact.
1911/Saskatchewan/Regina/62Regina/page 4 (about June time?)
Which has Albert and James in Sask, right ages doing some sort of building work
25 Nov 1911 passenger list arriving Liverpool on the Empress of Ireland that has an Albert and a James HENRY on it. listed together. The ages are out and the occupations are both ditto-ed as 'farmer'
This morning I have found records for Albert in the database for the Amalgated Society of Carpenters and Joiners
1 May 6th 1907, Albert HENRY was admitted to the Society, Gateshead 2nd Branch, single, age 21 years and 9 months (Albert was born Aug 1885), having worked 7 years at his trade (he was now out of his apprenticeship and was a Master Joiner)
2 April 8th 1910, Albert HENRY, who was admitted to the Society, Gateshead 2nd Branch on May 6th 1907 at the age of 21 years and 9 months, single, transferred to the Toronto 1st Branch (this ties in with the 1910 crossing for Albert on the 'Canada' arriving Halifax from Liverpool 15 April 1910, destination Toronto)
3 15th November 1911, Albert HENRY, who was admitted to the Society, Gateshead 2nd Branch on May 6th 1907 (hand in the air, that actually says 1901 but I'd bet my boots it was misread when the entry was made) at the age of 21 years and 9 months, single, transferred FROM the Regina Branch back to Gateshead (this ties in with the crossing for Albert & James 25 Nov 1911 on the Empress of Ireland)
4 There is a later record all the same admission etc info and Gateshead Branch and it says that Albert HENRY married on 31st July 1915 (this matches the date my Albert married)
These records tick all the boxes for me, they have everything bar a note saying 'hey Boo, here's your Albert' :-)
So, not for James Arthur but as the Canadian census and crossing that were in doubt had Albert AND James its a bit more weight to be added to the likelihood of it being for these brothers.
Its a bit like doing a jigsaw puzzle, without the picture and someone has hidden half of the pieces! Its SO much fun though and totally mind-blowing that not only have these records survived all this time but bit by bit they are becoming available on the web :-)
Plus of course the web gives us access to places like this where, via the kindness of strangers, I can get new leads to follow, opinions on whether or not my logic is flawed etc etc.
Thanks everyone!
Boo