I think he was the Willian Makin married to Mary Murphy - 18 November 1851 Emmanuel Church, Newton In Makerfield, Lancashire, England
Census, 1871,living in Wigan, Hindley in the Parish of Ince In Makerfield,Lancashire
William born Ainsworth, Lancashire, 45 years (b 1826)
Mary born, Padinan, Lancashire, 44 years (b 1827)
John born, Little Lever, Lancashire, 18 years (b 1853)
Thomas born, Bromwich, Lancashire, 16 years
Martha born, Little Lever, Lancashire, 11 years
Timing seems right and Newton and Wigan are not far apart. All from the IGI