So I have just checked NSW BDM online indexes.... free to search, and of course, a commercial website as I could order and pay online for NSW BDM certificates...
So I can clearly see the given and surnames of several of my ancestors, whom I recall vividly from my childhood. These are people who have been dead for more than 30 years. I can see the names of their parents on that index too. I can also see the names of several of my schoolfriends who were tragically killed in a multicar accident during my schoolyears, more than 30 years ago. In many instances their parents are still living, yet those parents names are listed on that index, free to search, not even needing a log in .... no subscriptions....
Then I look at Trove, another absolutely fantastic resource, ..... I can find many fairly current things about my ACT rellies and friends.... including engagement announcements from the 1990s .... I remember attending those functions with my husband and our families.... There's family history in those announcements .... one even has four generations of then living family in them. I am quite sure that little did the very proud parents who provided that info to the newspapers then expect that one day within their own lifetimes, those papers would be freely available to anyone (no need for any subscriptions, or log on) anywhere in the globe to come across those images of the newspapers online.
Hence, I cannot 'blame' Ancestory or Find My Past or those commercial websites. We as family history buffs need to take some responsibility, and we need to work towards some standards being developed to protect the research.... Yes, there's Australian copyright laws, yes, there's Privacy Laws, yes, there's T & C on the websites ..... but yes there's also copy and paste functions at the fingertips of any keyboard operator..... Should we 'blame' Bill Gates ....
Cheers, JM