May be a ""Red Herring" but Familysearch.Org has this Marriage;
Thomas BUTLER, Spouse TUTHILL, December 1657, Saint Peter, Bedford, Bedfordshire
F/S also has a Fayth TURTLE Christened 25 July 1634, East Markham, Notts, to WILLIAM/JOANE
Siblings;
JOANE, 25 May 1728
GEORGE 1630
ELIZABETH, 2 July 1732
FreeREG has Baptism East Markhan, Father WILLM Turtle 1618-1628, no Mother named
Joane 1728 is there but not George/Elizabeth or Fayth
And a Marriage to Jane THWAITES 1616 for a William Turtle
As I said just a possible as Bedfordshire is a long way from Nottinghamshire.