In this cutting the reporter has Donald McRAE assaulting David Hume at Dunmore.
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/18707476 Maitland Mercury 10 Oct 1863
In this cutting James HUME was charged with using threatening language towards Donald McCRAY at Dunmore… and David HUME also was on a charge against that same chap, Donald McCRAY.
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/18709990 MM 5 November 1863.
I cannot find any mention of a dispute over Matilda's baby's birth father in the Maitland Mercury.
I wonder if the person who wrote up the story for the Hunter Valley Genie forum may have assumed that ‘native’ indicated the person was an Aboriginal Person. I am certain that ‘native’ has been discussed quite a number of times on this board, and it does not indicate anything about ethnicity. It simply indicates where the person was born. So for example on the James Pattison shipping list mentioned recently, one of the headings should indicate the ‘native place’ for each passenger.
The NSW BDM birth registration for 1863 asks for the birth places for each of the parents. But if the mum is the informant and if she did not inform the registrar that she was a married person, then the baby’s registration would be extremely unlikely to name the baby’s father or give his native place information. A parish register for baptisms may well have a margin entry. I mentioned that option several years ago, on this thread.
JM