Date of old photos of Rebecca Cull

[rodhill]

Hi
I have 2 pictures of supposably the same woman can any one give a approximate date of the photos and opinion if the same person
Any assistance would be most appreciated
Rod

[Trishanne]

Hi Rod, I do  not think the two ladies are the same. In my opinion the first lady has a more protruding bottom lip and a larger nose, her eyes are deeper set with hooded lids and her forehead is longer.
This of course is just what I think, and I am often wrong!! but this has moved your post up for you and you will hopefully get somebody to date the ladies.
Pat

[Treetotal]

I would agree with Pat, not the same lady...the first one, from what I can see of the sleeves appears to have been taken in the 1890s and the second one about 1870s. They both appear to be reprints.
Carol

[Milliepede]

I agree too not the same lady. 

[Wiggy]

I agree - not the same lady.


I think the second photo (?1870) - looks older than the first - 1899 it says on the back of the photo.   

Wiggy

[mckha489]

I think they are the same! 
She just became more cuddly as she got older.

[matthewj64]

...the first lady has a more protruding bottom lip and a larger nose...

Her convict description at age 19 says a large nose and thick under lip

https://stors.tas.gov.au/CON19-1-12$init=CON19-1-12p24

[Trishanne]

Wow Matthew, I  never saw that record before. It's amazing, I never imagined her as a convict, that' s a great find.
Pat

[rodhill]

Thank to everyone that replied to my message
your assistance is most appreciated
Rod