Hi AlanBoyd,
Please excuse my confusion, but I don’t understand the reference to haplogroups. My understanding re Y-DNA was that if Man A and Man B had a common ancestor (in this case a 4xg grandfather), then both men would carry the same Y-DNA, inherited down the male line to each man via two different sons of the 4xg grandfather.
Five of our family members have now done DNA tests, and after months of investigation, the resulting atDNA matches have led us to a likely paternal grandfather family line, with a prime suspect for birth father who was in the right place at the right time. That line leads to Man B via his sister, who does match some of our family members. If the predicted paternal line is correct, then my understanding is that both Man A and Man B will have the same Y-DNA inherited from their common 4xg grandfather.
Do we need to test for a Y-DNA match? I’m not sure. Is having three atDNA matches at 4th Cousin level along that paternal line to the common 4xg grandfather sufficient proof to point the finger at our suspect? He has no living descendants, and no nephews or nieces either, so no-one here that could be tested for a closer match to our family. His aunt has provided three strong matches amongst her descendants, but those matches are all shared only with matches on her female (grandmother) line, and none with the aunt’s paternal line (and therefore the paternal line of our suspect).
I think the answer will be to just be patient and wait for more matches to hopefully appear on the radar in the not-too-distant future. In the meantime, I think I will upload the DNA to FTDNA and see if we get any matches there.
Thanks for all your help and advice. DNA is such a confusing part of genealogy, I guess because it is still fairly new and this is my first foray into the science. But I do feel we can break this brick wall, given enough time.