from Reply #84
James L. Dobbins
1830 • County Cork, Ireland
12 OCT 1898 • Manhattan, New York, USA
Mary A. Cryan
18 JUL 1837 • Ballycullane, Tintern, Wexford, Ireland
6 SEP 1914 • Fulton, New York
-----------
I don't think James' death is correct, and I'm having second thoughts about Mary's birth.
First: there is a link earlier in this thread to an article that said James was living in Rome, NY, and suffering from pneumonia in 1903, when his sons returned home. So he didn't die in NY City in 1898.
As for Mary, the 1870 census has an older Mary Crine in the household who is old enough to be the mother of Mary (Cryan) Dobbins. Until you eliminate that possibility, the 1837 baptism register of a Mary Crane whose mother is Catherine Furlong is not her.
You need to find or send for the death records of both James and Mary. They might name their parents. Narrow down the time frame by finding them on the 1900, 1910 censuses, etc. Failing that, look for obituaries that might mention their parents, county of origin, and survivors.
I have a feeling this family knew where they were from and if the information was asked, it would probably be correct.
If it exists, the death record for Mary Crine would be important also, though she probably died before they asked for much information.