Signature Comparison & Thoughts Please?

[Rosinish]

Hi folks,

Looking for opinions please on these 4 signatures being from the same woman?

I was quite happy to believe them to be so but a recent discrepancy from a direct ancestor of the woman (a distant branch on my tree) believes there were only 3 children at this point although I believe there were 4?

Annie

Add...No. 2 - 1905 - C is the one in dispute.

[Kay99]

To me they look like the same person's signatures

Kay

[Wiggy]

Certainly look like the same signature, but the 'mother' in the first seems to have been written by someone else - or the 'M' at least.

Wiggy

[bbart]

For some reason, it amuses me how she crosses her t's.  In her name, she only crosses half the t to avoid running into the S, but in "mother" she consistently runs into the h.

I believe they are all the same person.

[Rosinish]

In her name, she only crosses half the t to avoid running into the S

This was one of the factors which helped me to decide it to be most likely the same person.

Certainly look like the same signature, but the 'mother' in the first seems to have been written by someone else - or the 'M' at least.

It is different but I believe it to have been the same hand as I've noticed I too can have different ways of writing the same letters at times (reason unknown) 

Annie

[a-l]

It looks like the same person to me

[Ruskie]

Another "yes" (same person despite the first M) 

[Rosinish]

Thanks all, will consider this as a definite!

Annie

[Treetotal]

It's a yes from me too....on the whole, the handwriting is consistent.
Carol